Turner v South Taranaki District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NEW PLYMOUTH REGISTRY

CRI-2013-443-015 [2013] NZHC 1603

BETWEEN  IAN BASIL TURNER Appellant

ANDSOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL

Respondent

Hearing:                   30 May 2013

Counsel:                  Appellant in person

J M Marinovich for Respondent

Judgment:                2 July 2013

JUDGMENT OF MILLER J

Introduction

[1]      Mr Turner owns a Great Dane, Floyd, which has been classified as menacing. On 1 or 2 January 20131  he permitted his boarder, Ian Schrider, to walk Floyd and another Great Dane.   Mr Turner did not normally permit Mr Schrider to walk the dogs.  He says that he specifically instructed Mr Schrider on this occasion that they must be muzzled and kept on a short leash, and that people must not be permitted to approach them.

[2]      Mr Schrider did not muzzle the dogs, he let them off the leads to exercise in a park, and he had them on long leads on the walk home, when Floyd bit and wounded

a passing pedestrian.

1   The precise date is in dispute, but nothing turns on it; the date is not an essential particular of the charge, and the incident itself is not disputed.

TURNER v SOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL [2013] NZHC 1603 [2 July 2013]

[3]      The Council charged Mr Turner with being the owner of a dog that attacked a person, and with allowing the dog in public unmuzzled.  The District Court Judge convicted him and ordered that Floyd be destroyed.  He brings this appeal from the latter order.   After discussion at the hearing, and for reasons which will become apparent, I have treated it as an appeal against conviction too.

The narrative

[4]      Mr Turner acquired Floyd some 5½ years ago as a rescue dog, meaning that the dog had been abused.  For this reason, as Mr Turner accepts, Floyd wants skilled handling.  The dog has no prior history of attacks, but in November 2010 the Council classified him as menacing for reported threatening behaviour.   A menacing dog must be muzzled in public.

[5]      The facts of the attack are not in dispute.   The victim and his wife were walking on Bridge Street, Eltham, when Mr Schrider rounded a corner with the two dogs.   As the victim walked past, Floyd bit him once, on the arm.   The resulting laceration required medical attention.  Mr Schrider tried to walk on.  He reluctantly gave Mr Turner’s details when confronted.

[6]      The Council charged Mr Turner with being the owner of a dog that attacked a person, contrary to s 57(2) of the Dog Control Act 1996, and allowing the dog in public without being muzzled, contrary to s 33E(1).   He responded that the dogs were not under his direct control and Mr Schrider had failed to comply with his express instructions for walking them.  He was convicted at a defended hearing on

26 February, and the Judge ordered that Floyd be destroyed.

[7]      Mr Schrider is one of a number of young people who Mr Turner has taken in over the years to help…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turner v South Taranaki District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1603
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Turner v South Taranaki District Council [2013] NZHC 1603 involved Ian Basil Turner, the owner of a menacing dog, Floyd, who attacked a pedestrian. Turner appealed the District Court's conviction and destruction order for Floyd. The primary legal issues were whether Turner could be held liable for the attack given he had instructed a boarder, Mr Schrider, to walk the dogs with specific safety measures, and whether Turner could be found guilty of allowing the dog in public without a muzzle if he had instructed Schrider to muzzle the dog.

The court found that Turner could not be deemed to have total absence of fault as he had failed to ensure Schrider, who had known issues with attention and memory, was reliable enough to follow the instructions. Turner’s history of not always muzzling Floyd, despite its classification, further undermined his argument. On the issue of liability for allowing the dog in public unmuzzled, the court determined that Turner must have had actual knowledge or been wilfully blind to Schrider's failure to muzzle the dog, a requirement not met by mere negligence. Since Turner had instructed Schrider to muzzle the dogs, the court held Turner believed the dogs would be muzzled, thus dismissing the appeal on this count.

The court dismissed the appeal against the conviction for the dog attack but allowed the appeal for the unmuzzled dog charge. The destruction order for Floyd was confirmed. Turner was thus held liable for allowing the dog to be in public unmuzzled, but not for the attack itself.