IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
CRI-2013-485-53 [2014] NZHC 1333
BETWEEN JULIE ANN SNODGRASS
Appellant
AND
KAPITI COAST DISTRICT COUNCIL Respondent
Hearing: 8 April 2014 Appearances:
M Robinson for appellant
E M Light for respondentJudgment:
13 June 2014
JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J
Introduction
[1] The appellant, Julie Snodgrass, was convicted on 17 June 2013 by Judge Hastings in the District Court at Porirua1 of being the owner of a dog (Beau) who attacked another dog (Ryder).2 Judge Hastings ordered that Beau be destroyed pursuant to s 57(3) of the Dog Control Act 1996 and sentenced Ms Snodgrass to a
$500 fine and reparation of $3484.10.3 Ms Snodgrass appeals against her conviction and sentence.
[2] Ms Snodgrass’ conviction appeal is on the basis that due to trial counsel incompetence there has been a miscarriage of justice that necessitates her conviction being set aside. Relevant good character evidence about Beau was not admitted, irrelevant and unfairly prejudicial evidence about previous incidents with Beau was admitted and not adequately challenged, and evidence from the vet that treated Ryder
was not admitted. There is a real risk that the outcome of the defended hearing
1 Kapiti Coast District Council v Snodgrass DC Porirua CRI-2012- 091-3560, 17 June 2013.
2 Dog Control Act 1996, s 57(2).
3 Kapiti Coast District Council v Snodgrass DC Porirua, CRI-2012-091-003560, 5 July 2013.
SNODGRASS v KAPITI COAST DISTRICT COUNCIL [2014] NZHC 1333 [13 June 2014]
would have been different if the good character and vet evidence was admitted and the evidence of previous incidents was not admitted or was adequately explained.
[3] Ms Snodgrass appeals against her sentence on the basis she should have received a discharge without conviction and that her sentence should not have included reparation to the Kapiti Coast District Council (the Council) for Beau’s impoundment and kennel fees.
Facts
[4] Beau is an American Staffordshire Terrier and Great Dane Cross. Ms Snodgrass also owns Sheba, Beau’s mother. On 11 September 2012, Ms Snodgrass, Beau and Sheba were at Matthews Park in Paraparaumu. Beau and Sheba were let off their leads. Ms Sutherland and her dog Ryder entered the other side of the park. Ryder too was let off his lead. Beau and Ryder saw one another, met midfield and sniffed at each other. When Beau started to growl, Ms Sutherland called Ryder back. Ryder complied and Beau chased him. As recorded by the Judge Ms Snodgrass and Ms Sutherland describe what followed differently:
…according to Ms Sutherland, [Beau] started to lunge and bite at [Ryder]. Ms Sutherland said that Beau attempted to grab Ryder’s neck, and when Ryder tripped and rolled, Beau succeeded in “locking down” and biting Ryder’s rear left leg. Ms Snodgrass said that Beau was “not snarling or biting or acting viciously” and he was not “locked onto Ryder’s leg.
[5] Both owners ran to the dogs. Ms Snodgrass kicked Beau to get him off Ryder when Beau did not respond to her verbal commands. Ms Sutherland noticed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Snodgrass v Kapiti Coast District Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 1333
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court found that there was no real risk that the outcome of the hearing would have been different if the additional evidence had been admitted. The evidence of Beau's good character and rough play had limited relevance to the question of whether the incident was an attack, as the ultimate question of whether a particular incident was an attack relies on an objective analysis of the way in which that particular incident played out. Moreover, the evidence from the vet that treated Ryder was not available and thus it was not possible to conclude that there was a real risk that the evidence could have affected the outcome of Ms Snodgrass' hearing. The Court further found that there was no real risk that the "Dog Owner Enquiry" file evidence affected the outcome of Ms Snodgrass' hearing.
The Court found that Ms Snodgrass' appeal against sentence on the basis that she should have received a discharge without conviction failed as the consequences of conviction were not out of proportion to the gravity of the offence. However, the Court found in favour of Ms Snodgrass on the issue of reparation. The impoundment and sustenance fees are civil debts and not the appropriate subject of a reparation order.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.