McClintock v Taupo District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CRI-2016-463-000041 [2017] NZHC 58

BETWEEN

KENNETH ERNEST MCCLINTOCK

Appellant

AND

TAUPO DISTRICT COUNCIL

Respondent

Hearing: 12 December 2016

Counsel:

D M Johnston for appellant
J S Gurnick for respondent

Judgment:

1 February 2017

JUDGMENT OF KATZ J

This judgment was delivered by me on 1 February 2017 at 3:00pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:      Tompkins Wake, Lawyers, Hamilton

Counsel:       D M Johnston, Barrister, Taupo

MCCLINTOCK v TAUPO DISTRICT COUNCIL [2017] NZHC 58 [1 February 2017]

Introduction

[1]      In 2010 Kenneth McClintock’s dog Scooby was classified as a dangerous dog under the Dog Control Act 1996 (“Act”) following an incident with a postal delivery officer.  As a result, Mr McClintock was required to either keep Scooby within a securely fenced portion of his property, or confined completely within a vehicle or cage, or muzzled and on a leash.1

[2]      On 12 August 2015 Mr McClintock breached these requirements by leaving Scooby, who was not muzzled, in a van at his business premises with the van’s sliding side door open.   The victim, Mr Rean, drove onto the property and got out of his car to ask for directions.   Scooby ran out of the van and bit Mr Rean on the back of his calf, causing puncture wounds and bruising.

[3]      Mr McClintock pleaded guilty to two charges under the Act.   First, he had breached his obligation to keep Scooby within a secure area, or otherwise muzzled and on a lead.2   Second, he was the owner of a dog that attacked a person.3   The Act requires that when a person is convicted of either of these offences the court must make an order for destruction of the dog, unless satisfied that the circumstances of the offence were exceptional and do not warrant destruction of the dog.

[4]      Mr McClintock argued in the District Court that the circumstances of both offences were exceptional and, as a result, Scooby should not be destroyed.   A disputed facts  hearing  was  held  to  consider the issue.    Judge M A MacKenzie concluded, however, that the circumstances of the offending were not exceptional.4

She therefore made an order for the destruction of the dog.   Mr McClintock now appeals that decision.   He says that the Judge erred:

(a)       in assessing the evidence concerning whether Scooby was provoked; (b)      in her assessment of Council records detailing the history of the dog

and its owner; and

1      Section 32(1).

2      See s 32(3).

3      See s 57(2).

4      Taupo District Council v McClintock [2016] NZDC 14885 at [66].

(c)       in concluding that the circumstances were not exceptional and that the destruction of the dog was therefore warranted.

[5]       The appeal is framed as an appeal against conviction.   I accept the Crown’s submission, however, that the appeal is more appropriately viewed as an appeal against sentence, given that only the destruction order, an order which emanated from the conviction, is appealed.5  This is a general appeal, which I can allow…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McClintock v Taupo District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In McClintock v Taupo District Council, Kenneth McClintock appealed against the decision of the District Court that his dog, Scooby, a previously classified dangerous dog, should be destroyed following an incident where he was not properly contained and bit a member of the public. The appeal was brought under the Dog Control Act 1996 which requires that an order for destruction of a dangerous dog must be made when an owner is convicted of certain offences, unless the court is satisfied that the circumstances of the offence were exceptional and do not warrant destruction of the dog. The District Court found that the circumstances were not exceptional, and an order was made for the dog’s destruction. The appeal was heard by Katz J in the High Court at Rotorua. Katz J dismissed the appeal. Katz J accepted that the appeal was more appropriately viewed as an appeal against sentence, given that only the destruction order, an order which emanated from the conviction, was appealed. Katz J considered three issues on appeal: whether the District Court erred in concluding that Mr Rean did not provoke the dog by kicking him; whether the District Court erred in taking into account various alleged incidents in the history of Mr McClintock’s dog ownership and Scooby’s past behaviour; and whether the District Court erred in finding that the circumstances of the offending were not exceptional. Katz J found that the District Court’s conclusion that Mr Rean did not provoke Scooby by kicking him was well open to her on the evidence before the Court. Katz J found that there was no error in the District Court’s taking into account various alleged incidents in the history of Mr McClintock’s dog ownership and Scooby’s past behaviour, and Katz J found that the District Court was correct to conclude that the circumstances of the offending were not exceptional. Katz J found that the statutory obligation on Mr McClintock because of Scooby’s dangerous dog classification, and the fact that he had failed to keep Scooby muzzled or contained, meant that the circumstances were not exceptional. Katz J found that Katz J was not persuaded that the various factors raised on appeal were sufficient, in combination, to meet the exceptional circumstances threshold. Katz J accordingly dismissed the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.