| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA307/2022 [2022] NZCA 612 |
| BETWEEN | ESTELLE GRETA LOW |
| AND | NEW PLYMOUTH DISTRICT COUNCIL |
| Hearing: | 14 September 2022 |
Court: | Brown, Goddard and Katz JJ |
Counsel: | J C Hannam for Appellant |
Judgment: | 7 December 2022 at 10.00 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe application for leave to appeal is granted.
BThe appeal is dismissed.
___________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Goddard J)
Is a dog walker an “owner” of the dog under the Dog Control Act 1996?
[1] The Dog Control Act 1996 imposes a number of obligations on owners of dogs. It creates a number of strict liability offences: for example, being the owner of a dog that attacks a person or a domestic animal.[1] The Act gives the term “owner” an extended definition that includes every person who owns the dog, or who has the dog in their possession, with certain specified exceptions.[2]
[1]Dog Control Act 1996, s 57(1).
[2]Section 2 definition of “owner”, paras (a)–(b).
[2] Is a dog walker who is temporarily looking after a dog, by agreement with its owner, treated as an owner of the dog for the purposes of the offence provisions in the Dog Control Act? We consider it is clear that the answer is “yes”, in light of the text of the legislation and the relevant authorities.
[3] It follows that the appeal must be dismissed. Our reasons are set out below.
Background
[4] Ms Low, the appellant, operates a dog day care service. On 22 June 2021 she was walking five dogs along Bell Block beach, north of New Plymouth. She was the owner of two of the dogs. The other three dogs belonged to clients. The dogs were not leashed.
[5] The complainant was riding her horse along the beach. Three of the dogs ran at the horse. The New Plymouth District Council (the Council) alleges that three of the dogs — Dante (owned by Ms Low) and Diesel and Richie (owned by clients) jumped up at the horse, biting at the horse’s legs and body. The complainant’s horse suffered a number of abdominal lacerations.
[6] The Council laid seven charges against Ms Low arising out of this incident:
(a)three charges that, being the owner of a dog, she failed to keep the dog under control (one charge in relation to each of the three dogs);[3]
[3]Sections 52(1) and 53(1).
(b)two charges of being the owner of a dog that rushed at an animal in a manner that caused a person to be endangered (one charge relating to each of the dogs Richie and Diesel);[4] and
[4]Section 57A.
(c)two charges of being the owner of a dog that attacked a domestic animal.[5]
[5]Section 57(1)(b), (2) and (3).
[7] Ms Low applied for the charges to be dismissed under s 147 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 on the basis that she did not come within…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Low v New Plymouth District Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NZCA 612
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal considered whether a dog walker, who is temporarily looking after a dog with the consent of its owner, can be treated as the owner of the dog for the purposes of the offence provisions in the Dog Control Act. The Court found that the definition of "owner" in the Act includes not only the person who owns the dog, but also any person who has the dog in their possession, unless the possession is for the purpose of preventing the dog causing injury, damage, or distress and lasts no longer than 72 hours. The Court concluded that Ms Low came within the definition of the term "owner" in relation to the dogs she was looking after, as she had possession of them for more than 72 hours, and her possession was not for the purpose of preventing the dogs causing injury, damage, or distress.
The Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal and dismissed the appeal, holding that Ms Low was the owner of the dogs in her care for the purposes of the Dog Control Act. As a result, the charges against her stand.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was first heard in the District Court, where Judge A S Greig dismissed the charges against Ms Low. The New Plymouth District Council appealed the decision to the High Court, where Justice Simon France allowed the appeal. Ms Low now seeks leave to appeal the High Court's decision to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal and heard the case on 14 September 2022. The judgment was delivered on 7 December 2022.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is a dog walker an “owner” of the dog under the Dog Control Act 1996?
2. Does the 72-hour limit in the definition of “owner” create a safe harbour protecting people from liability under the Act whenever they have a dog in their possession for less than 72 hours, regardless of the purpose for which the dog was in their possession?
Held
1. A dog walker is an “owner” of the dog under the Dog Control Act 1996. This includes anyone who has a dog in their possession, however briefly, unless the possession is for the purpose of controlling the dog or returning it to the owner and does not exceed 72 hours.
2. The 72-hour limit in the definition of “owner” does not create a safe harbour protecting people from liability under the Act whenever they have a dog in their possession for less than 72 hours, regardless of the purpose for which the dog was in their possession.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered the definition of “owner” under the Dog Control Act 1996 and concluded that a dog walker who has a dog in their possession, even for less than 72 hours, is treated as an owner of the dog for the purposes of the offence provisions in the Act. The Court held that the purpose of the statute is to impose strict liability for breaches of the obligations imposed by the Act, and that a person who has a dog in their possession, however briefly, is the owner of the dog for the purposes of the Act unless certain exceptions apply. The Court disagreed with the approach taken by the District Court Judge and adopted the approach set out by the High Court Judge, which held that a person who has possession of a dog for more than 72 hours has all the duties of an owner under the Act, and commits an offence under s 57(2) if the dog attacks a person or an animal during that period. The Court also held that the 72-hour limit to the exception was intended to limit the operation of the exception, requiring a person wishing to avoid liability for a dog’s behaviour to return the dog to its true owner, or otherwise deal with it, within the 72-hour window. It was not intended to create a new safe harbour protecting people from liability under the Act whenever they had a dog in their possession for less than 72 hours, regardless of the purpose for which the dog was in their possession. In this case, Ms Low had possession of the dogs in her care for the purpose of looking after them generally, and not in order to prevent them causing injury, damage or distress. Therefore, she was the owner of the dogs in her care for the purposes of the Dog Control Act, and the appeal to this Court must be dismissed.