S v S

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NEW PLYMOUTH REGISTRY

CRI 2017-443-2 [2017] NZHC 1584

BETWEEN

IAN BASIN TURNER

Appellant

AND

SOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL

Respondent

Hearing: 2 May 2017

Counsel:

Appellant in Person
J M Marinovich for Respondent

Judgment:

10 July 2017

JUDGMENT OF ELLIS J

[1] This is an application for leave to a appeal on a question of law by Mr Turner, who was unsuccessful in his prosecution of the South Taranaki District Council under the Animal Welfare Act 1999 (the AWA) in the District Court.1

[2]      Mr Turner adopts rescue dogs – dogs that have been abused – and cares for and trains them.  One of these dogs was a Great Dane named Floyd.  Floyd required skilled handling, but Mr Turner knew what he was doing.  Although Floyd had no history of attacks, the Council classified him as menacing in November 2010, for reported threatening behaviour. A menacing dog must be muzzled in public.

[3]      Mr Turner also rescues people.   And so it was that he came to take in a

boarder, Mr Ian Schrider.  It seems that Mr Schrider had a few “issues” and was not

wholly reliable or responsible.

1      Turner v South Taranaki District Council [2017] NZDC 495.

TURNER v SOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL [2017] NZHC 1584 [10 July 2017]

[4]      In early January 2013 Mr Schrider took Floyd and another Great Dane out for a walk.  He used a long, rather than a short leash, giving him less control over the dogs.  Floyd was not wearing his muzzle even though Mr Turner said he had told Mr Schrider that it was required.

[5]      While  walking  home,  Floyd  bit  a  passerby  on  the  arm.     Floyd  was impounded.  Mr Turner was later convicted of being the owner of a dog that attacked a person, and with allowing Floyd to go unmuzzled in public.  And because Floyd committed an “attack”, the Dog Control Act 1996 required him to be destroyed, in the absence of exceptional circumstances.

[6]      Mr Turner’s appeals against his conviction for owning a dog that made an attack and against the destruction order failed.2     On 3 July 2013, the day after Miller J’s decision in the appeal, Mr Turner accepted that Floyd would have to be destroyed.

[7]      By the time of Floyd’s death he had been living for six months at the South Taranaki District Council Dog Pound.  The conditions there were far from ideal for a dog like Floyd, especially on a long term basis.  It seems likely that being in a bare cage caused him to become aggressive; he routinely tore up his bedding.  Those who worked at the Pound were unable to handle him and he could not be exercised.  It was thought he could not safely socialise with other dogs.   He lost weight and condition, even when his food intake was increased.   He was fed nutritional high energy biscuits instead of the meat he was used to.  Come winter, his cage was cold and  poorly protected  from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read S v S and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1584
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Mr Ian Basin Turner sought leave to appeal against a decision of the District Court that dismissed his prosecution of the South Taranaki District Council under the Animal Welfare Act 1999 (AWA). Mr Turner had rescued a Great Dane named Floyd, who was classified as menacing by the Council. Floyd bit a passerby, and Mr Turner was convicted of being the owner of a dog that attacked a person and of allowing Floyd to go unmuzzled in public. The District Court found that the Council had taken all reasonable steps to comply with its obligations under the AWA, and dismissed Mr Turner's private prosecution against the Council.

The legal issues in the case were whether the District Court erred in law in finding that the Council had taken all reasonable steps to comply with its obligations under the AWA, and whether Mr Turner's notice of appeal was sufficient to obtain leave to appeal. The Court found that the notice of appeal was defective because it did not specify the relevant question of law, as required by statute. However, the Court treated the notice of appeal as an application for leave to appeal, and considered whether the application should be granted. The Court found that the application should be declined because the grounds of appeal were factual in nature, and there was no clear-cut error in the District Court's approach or conclusions. The Court also noted that it was not realistic to expect the Council to accede to an impounded dog owner's request to care for their dog over a considerable period of time.

The Court declined to grant leave to appeal, and the decision of the District Court stands. The Court noted that while Mr Turner's position was difficult, the wider policy considerations underlying the way in which the AWA deals with dangerous dogs are obvious. The Court sympathised with Mr Turner's distress, but found that the Council had taken all reasonable steps to comply with its obligations under the AWA.

In conclusion, the High Court declined Mr Turner's application for leave to appeal against the decision of the District Court. The Court found that the grounds of appeal were factual in nature, and there was no clear-cut error in the District Court's approach or conclusions. The Court also noted that it was not realistic to expect the Council to accede to an impounded dog owner's request to care for their dog over a considerable period of time. The decision of the District Court stands, and the Council is not liable for failing Floyd under the AWA.