Sportzone Motorcycles Ltd (in liq) v Commerce Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA727/2013

CA593/2014 [2015] NZCA 78

BETWEEN

SPORTZONE MOTORCYCLES

LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) First Appellant

AND

MOTOR TRADE FINANCES LIMITED Second Appellant

AND

COMMERCE COMMISSION Respondent

Hearing:

19–20 November 2014 (further submissions received

12 December 2014)

Court:

Harrison, Stevens and Simon France JJ

Counsel:

D J Goddard QC, I J Thain and C M Moody for First and
Second Appellants
S J Mills QC and K C Francis for Respondent

Judgment:

30 March 2015 at 11.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A     The appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellants must pay the respondent costs for a complex appeal on a band B basis and usual disbursements. We certify for second counsel.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Stevens J)

SPORTZONE MOTORCYCLES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) AND MOTOR TRADE FINANCES LIMITED V COMMERCE COMMISSION CA727/2013 AND CA593/2014 [2015] NZCA 78 [24 March 2015]

Table of Contents

Para No

Unreasonable fees?  [1] The competing cases  [5] Core case for Sportzone/MTF   [5] Commission’s response  [10] Issues on appeal   [11] Background  [13] Commission’s intervention  [19] The statutory scheme  [23] Establishment fees  [29] Other credit and default fees  [31] Liability judgment  [34] The test under s 41 - did the appellant charge unreasonable fees?  [44] Submissions of the parties  [44]

(i)   Sportzone/MTF  [44] (ii)  Commission’s response  [49] Our decision  [51] Analysis   [51] Practical issues  [68]

Is relief available under s 94?  [82] Submissions of the parties  [84] Our analysis  [88] Has the Commission proved any loss?  [94] Does s 45 assist MTF?   [101] What is the quantum of loss?   [114] Result and costs   [122]

Unreasonable fees?

[1]    This appeal concerns fees (establishment fees, default fees and other credit fees) charged by the appellants to consumers through consumer credit  contracts governed by the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 (CCCFA).  The appellants,  Sportzone  Motorcycles  Ltd  (in  liq)  (Sportzone)  and  Motor  Trade Finances Ltd (MTF), appeal from findings in the Auckland High Court that certain fees provided for in credit contracts entered into by Sportzone with borrowers were

unreasonable for the purposes of the CCCFA.1    These findings are set out in two

1      Sportzone has since been placed in liquidation and the liquidators have given their consent to the continuation of this proceeding against Sportzone.

judgments of Toogood J, the first dealing with liability, the second with quantum

(referred to as the liability judgment and the quantum judgment, respectively).2

[2]    The findings and conclusions in both the liability and quantum judgments are challenged.3   The substance of this appeal is largely a matter of interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions.  We approach this interpretative exercise with an eye to the policy apparent from the text of the CCCFA and its underlying purpose as an important consumer protection measure.

[3]    The appellants reject what they call the High Court’s “fine-grained costs-based approach” to determining whether a fee is unreasonable under s 41 of the CCCFA. They argue the High Court wrongly accepted the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sportzone Motorcycles Ltd (in liq) v Commerce Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZCA 78
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sportzone Motorcycles Ltd (in liq) and Motor Trade Finances Ltd (MTF) appealed against findings of the Auckland High Court that fees charged by them were unreasonable under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 (CCCFA). The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal. The Court upheld the approach of the High Court to the interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CCCFA. The Court held that the statutory language required a close connection between the fee charged and the costs incurred in generating that portion of the credit service. The Court found that the High Court had correctly applied the principles of management or cost accounting in determining the reasonableness of the fees charged. The Court also held that the Commission was entitled to seek orders under s 94 of the CCCFA for the repayment of amounts by MTF reflecting the unreasonable portion of the fees on behalf of the relevant borrowers under the 39 credit contracts. The Court rejected MTF's argument that s 45 of the CCCFA could immunise MTF from scrutiny by the court as to the fees charged by MTF to Sportzone. The Court also held that the Commission had proved loss and that the quantum of loss determined by the High Court was correct. The Court ordered that the appellants must pay the respondent costs for a complex appeal on a band B basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established