Commerce Commission v Sportzone Motorcycles Limited (in liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

JUDGMENT RE-ISSUED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF FIGURES IN PARAGRAPHS [90] AND [93] OF THE JUDGMENT.  FILE NOT TO BE SEARCHED WITHOUT THE LEAVE OF A JUDGE; PARTIES TO BE NOTIFIED OF ANY APPLICATION FOR

ACCESS TO THE COURT FILE TO ENABLE THE COURT TO RECEIVE SUBMISSIONS ON COMMERCIAL SENSITIVE CONTENT.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2010-409-000026 [2014] NZHC 2486

UNDER

the Credit Contracts and Consumer

Finance Act 2003 and the Fair Trading Act
1986

BETWEEN

COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

AND

SPORTZONE MOTORCYCLES LIMITED (In Liquidation)

First Defendant

AND

MOTOR TRADE FINANCES LIMITED Second Defendant

AND

MTF SECURITIES LIMITED Third Defendant

Hearing: 27 June 2014

Appearances:

KC Francis and CSM Henley for Plaintiff
IJ Thain and CM Moody for Defendants

Judgment:

9 October 2014

JUDGMENT (NO. 2) OF TOOGOOD J

This judgment was delivered by me on 20 October 2014 at 2:00 pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

COMMERCE COMMISSION v SPORTZONE MOTORCYCLES LIMITED (In Liquidation) [2014] NZHC

2486 [9 October 2014]

Table of Contents

Paragraph

Number

Introduction

[1]

Factual background [6]
Summary  of  findings  in  the  liability  judgment  as  to applicable principles [7]
The Court’s jurisdiction to order recovery of unreasonable fees [12]
Quantification of the remedies sought under s 94(1)(b) of the CCCFA [17]
Illustration of MTF’s approach – finance costs claimed as part of establishment fee [18]
Two matters of principle not agreed by the parties [25]
The onus of proof [27]
MTF’s argument [27]
The Commission’s argument [30]
Discussion and conclusion [31]
Is the creditor entitled to rely on cost allocations not used in setting the fee? [37]
Conclusion [41]
Recovery of particular costs [42]
Some  cost  items  fail  to  meet  the  close  relevance  test  in connection with any fee [43]
Training [44]
Travel [45]
Directors’ fees and travel costs [46]
Professional/accounting fees [48]
Legal fees [49]
Audit fees [50]
Establishment fees [54]
Finance cost centre [55]
Salaries and performance scheme [56]
Premises [58]
Bank [60]
Payment waiver insurance [61]
Communication [63]
Treasury cost centre [65]
PC banking and direct credit and debit facilities [66]
Other treasury costs [67]
Table of Contents

Paragraph

Number

Credit cost centre [70]
Salaries,       performance       scheme       costs       and communications costs [71]
Customer service/dealer support cost centre [75]
Salaries,       performance       scheme       costs       and communications costs [76]
Motochek fees [77]
System development cost centre [78]
Product development cost centre [79]
IT production cost centre [81]
Salaries    (including    temporary    staff),    performance scheme costs and cell phone costs [83]
Other    communications     costs    –    paper,    printing, stationery and postage [85]
Hardware and software depreciation [86]
Security and storage [87]
Securitisation and bank cost centre [88]
Cost of capital [90]
Account maintenance fees [95]
Finance cost centre [96]
Salaries [96]
Bank [97]
Software maintenance [98]
Treasury cost centre [99]
Customer service/dealer support cost centre [100]
System development cost centre [101]
Information technology cost centre [102]
Arrears fees [105]
Finance cost centre [106]
Credit cost centre [107]
Customer service/dealer support cost centre [108]
System development cost centre [109]
IT…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Sportzone Motorcycles Limited (in liqu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2486
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case Commerce Commission v Sportzone Motorcycles Limited (In Liquidation) involves a dispute over the reasonableness of fees charged by Sportzone Motorcycles Limited and Motor Trade Finances Limited (MTF) to borrowers of motor vehicle finance. The court held that the fees charged were unreasonable and now must determine the appropriate remedies. The court held that it had the jurisdiction to order the recovery of unreasonable fees under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003. The court considered the principles of management or cost accounting to be practical guidance for lenders, the Commission, and the court in determining whether a fee is reasonable. The court concluded that the creditor is not entitled to rely on cost allocations not used in setting the fee, but that the court's assessment should be based on the available evidence of what costs were actually incurred. The court disallowed certain cost items from being recovered as components of a reasonable fee, such as training, travel, directors' fees and travel costs, professional/accounting fees, legal fees, and audit costs. The court also disallowed certain costs from being recovered through establishment fees, such as securitisation costs, bank costs, and the cost of capital. The court allowed certain costs to be recovered through establishment fees, such as salaries, premises, bank activity fees, and communication costs. The court also allowed certain costs to be recovered through account maintenance fees, such as salaries, bank costs, and software maintenance. The court disallowed certain costs from being recovered through arrears fees, such as bad debt costs, securitisation costs, bank costs, and the cost of capital. The court reserved leave to any party to apply for the making of formal orders directing the payment of refunds to the borrowers.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established