Sportzone Motorcycles Ltd (in liq) v Commerce Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 40/2015
[2016] NZSC 53
BETWEEN

SPORTZONE MOTORCYCLES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
First Appellant

MOTOR TRADE FINANCES LIMITED
Second Appellant

AND

COMMERCE COMMISSION
Respondent

Hearing:

10 and 11 November 2015

Court:

Elias CJ, William Young, Glazebrook, Arnold and O'Regan JJ

Counsel:

D J Goddard QC, I J Thain and C M Moody for Appellants
S J Mills QC, K C Francis and P J L Arnold for Respondent

Judgment:

12 May 2016

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellants must pay the respondent costs of $25,000 plus reasonable disbursements (to be determined by the Registrar in the absence of agreement between the parties).  We certify for two counsel.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS
(Given by O’Regan J)

  1. This appeal addresses the provisions of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 (the 2003 Act) regulating fees charged by financiers to consumers under consumer credit contracts.

  2. The appellants, Sportzone Motorcycles Limited (in liquidation) (Sportzone) and Motor Trade Finances Limited (MTF), provided finance to consumers in connection with the purchase of motorcycles from Sportzone.  Sportzone assigned each consumer credit contract to MTF under an arrangement between Sportzone and MTF.  MTF then became the creditor under the assigned contracts. 

  3. The respondent (the Commission) alleged that the fees provided for in these consumer credit contracts were unreasonable for the purposes of the 2003 Act.  After an eleven day hearing in the High Court, Toogood J delivered a judgment in which he found that the fees were, in some respects, unreasonable (the HC liability judgment).[1]  In a subsequent judgment (the HC quantum judgment), Toogood J quantified the extent to which the fees were unreasonable.[2]

  4. Sportzone and MTF appealed to the Court of Appeal which dismissed the appeal against both the HC liability judgment and the HC quantum judgment.[3]

    [3]Sportzone Motorcycles Ltd (in liq) v Commerce Commission [2015] NZCA 78, [2015] 3 NZLR 191 (Harrison, Stevens and Simon France JJ) [Sportzone (CA)].

  5. This Court gave Sportzone and MTF leave to appeal on the following question:[4]

    Did the Court of Appeal err in finding that the fees charged by [Sportzone and MTF] were unreasonable for the purposes of s 41 of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003?

  6. Sportzone and MTF also sought leave to appeal on a second question.  However, leave to appeal on that question was declined.[5]

The financing arrangements and the fees charged

[5]The second question was: “Did the Court of Appeal err in finding it had been established that the debtors had suffered loss or damage for the purposes of s 94 of [the 2003 Act]?”

  1. As its name suggests, MTF provides funding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sportzone Motorcycles Ltd (in liq) v Commerce Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZSC 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sportzone Motorcycles Ltd (in liq) and Motor Trade Finances Ltd (MTF) appealed against the High Court and Court of Appeal's decisions that the fees charged to debtors were unreasonable under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal. The Court found that the fees charged by MTF were unreasonable because they were higher than the costs incurred by MTF in relation to the activities for which the fees were charged. The Court found that the fees charged by MTF were not reasonable because they were higher than the costs incurred by MTF in relation to the activities for which the fees were charged. The Court found that the costs that could be recovered by MTF through fees were those that were closely connected with the activity for which the fee was being charged. The Court found that the costs that could be recovered by MTF through fees were those that were closely connected with the activity for which the fee was being charged. The Court found that the Court of Appeal's approach to determining whether fees were reasonable was correct. The Court found that the Court of Appeal's approach to determining whether fees were reasonable was correct. The Court found that the costs that could be recovered by MTF through fees were those that were closely connected with the activity for which the fee was being charged. The Court found that the costs that could be recovered by MTF through fees were those that were closely connected with the activity for which the fee was being charged. The Court found that the Court of Appeal's approach to determining whether fees were reasonable was correct.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns the fees charged by Sportzone Motorcycles Limited (Sportzone) and Motor Trade Finances Limited (MTF) to consumers under consumer credit contracts for the purchase of motorcycles. Sportzone, a motorcycle dealer, provided finance to consumers and assigned each credit contract to MTF, which became the creditor. The Commerce Commission alleged that certain fees charged under these credit contracts were unreasonable under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003. The High Court found the fees were unreasonable in some respects, a decision upheld by the Court of Appeal. The Supreme Court of New Zealand was asked to determine if the Court of Appeal erred in its findings.

The case originated in the High Court, where Toogood J ruled in two judgments that the fees charged by Sportzone and MTF were unreasonable, leading to an appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal upheld the High Court's findings. Sportzone and MTF sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, which was granted on one specific question regarding the interpretation of the reasonableness of fees under the 2003 Act. The Supreme Court heard the appeal and dismissed it, upholding the decisions of the lower courts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What are the relevant purposes of the 2003 Act? In particular, is one of the purposes of the 2003 Act flexibility in pricing models and the encouragement of innovation by creditors?
2. What approach to the assessment of the reasonableness of fees provides the best basis for comparing credit offerings by competing credit providers?
3. Should fees be assessed on a per transaction basis or by reference to the activities undertaken by the creditor?
4. What measure of costs should be adopted? The possibilities canvassed in argument were (short term) variable costs, variable costs plus some allowance for fixed costs as found by the High Court, avoidable costs or any cost beneficially related to the activity for which the fee is charged.
5. Whether the Court should consider the fallback argument advocating an avoidable costs measure, given that it has not been raised in the lower Courts.
6. Whether the assessment of the reasonableness of fees should be based on cost only, or on a broader consideration as advocated by MTF.
7. Whether the fact that averaging is permitted affects the method of determining the reasonableness of fees.
8. Whether the approach of the lower Courts leads to absurd outcomes and, if so, whether this should lead us to adopt a different measure in an effort to avoid those outcomes.

Held
1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The appellants must pay the respondent costs of $25,000 plus reasonable disbursements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court examined the purposes of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 (2003 Act), concluding that the primary objectives of the legislation are consumer protection and the comparability of credit arrangements, as outlined in section 3 of the Act. While the promotion of efficiency and innovation by credit providers was a factor driving the reform, these were not mentioned in section 3 and therefore were deemed less important than the express purposes stated by Parliament. The Court found that the approach of the lower Courts in assessing the reasonableness of fees under sections 42 and 44 of the Act was consistent with these purposes, focusing on transaction-specific costs that are sufficiently close and relevant to the activity for which the fee is charged. The Court rejected the appellants' argument that all costs beneficially related to the activity should be recoverable in fees, emphasizing the need to limit fees to those that are reasonable in nature and extent. The Court also held that while factors other than cost may be relevant in determining reasonableness, they are unlikely to render a fee reasonable if it exceeds the level required to recover the reasonable costs associated with the activity. The Court concluded that the approach of the lower Courts did not lead to absurd outcomes and that there was no error in the Court of Appeal's analysis, which essentially adopted the approach of the High Court. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs.