For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA199/06
[2007] NZCA 407BETWEENSKYCITY AUCKLAND LIMITED
First AppellantANDSKYCITY CASINO MANAGEMENT LIMITED
Second Appellant
ANDTHE GAMBLING COMMISSION
Respondent
Hearing:27 June 2007
Court:O'Regan, Arnold and Ellen France JJ
Counsel:A R Galbraith QC and G M Coumbe for Appellants
C P Browne and J A Browne for Respondent
Judgment:11 September 2007 at 3 pm
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A The appeal is dismissed.
B The appellants must pay to the respondent costs of $6,000 plus usual disbursements.
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by O’Regan J)
Table of Contents
Para No
Issue [1]
Declaration sought [2]
Skycity’s arguments [8]
(a) Ordinary meaning [10]
(b) Arguments based on context(i) Noscitur a sociis and ejusdem generis [17]
Wide words associated with more specific words [18]
Examples form a class [20]
Examples do not exhaust class [22]
No contrary legislative intention [24]
Conclusion on ejusdem generis [25](ii) Other provisions in the 2003 Act [27]
(iii) Interpretative presumptions [29]
Presumption against taking property without compensation [30]
Presumption that penal statutes are construed strictly [33]
(c) Legislative history [38]
Should we consider Cabinet papers? [39]
The legislative process in this case [43]
(d) Unworkable or undesirable consequences [56](i) Unworkable or absurd consequences [57]
(ii) Overlap of functions of Commission and Secretary [67]
(iii) Commission deciding its own jurisdiction [72]
Overall assessment [75]
Result [79]
Costs [80]Issue
[1] This appeal concerns the meaning of the term “opportunities for casino gambling” which appears in ss 11, 12 and 139(2)(d) of the Gambling Act 2003 (the 2003 Act). This has particular importance for the appellants (to which we will refer collectively as “Skycity”) because the prohibition in s 11 of the 2003 Act of any increase in gambling opportunities significantly affects Skycity’s casino business. Skycity says that the phrase “opportunities for casino gambling” relates only to the number of casino games and/or the number of player positions associated with casino games in a particular casino. The Gambling Commission, which is the body charged with the regulating of casinos under the 2003 Act, contends that “opportunities for casino gambling” has a much broader meaning. The issue for determination is whether the narrow interpretation suggested by Skycity is correct.
Declaration sought
[2] In the High Court, Skycity sought a declaration in terms supporting its interpretation. Cooper J declined to make the declaration: Skycity Auckland Ltd & Anor v The Gambling Commission HC AK CIV 2005-404-1369 24 August 2006. Skycity appeals against that decision.
[3] In this Court Skycity amended slightly the form of the declaration from that which it sought in the High Court. The declaration it now seeks is in the following terms:
The words “opportunities for casino gambling” in ss 11, 12 and 139(2)(d) of the 2003 Act are limited to the number of casino games, and/or the number of player positions associated with casino games, as set out in paragraphs 32(a) to (e) of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Skycity Auckland Ltd v Gambling Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NZCA 407
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated in the High Court where Skycity sought a declaration in support of its narrow interpretation of the phrase "opportunities for casino gambling". The High Court declined to grant the declaration, leading Skycity to appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal heard the appeal and ultimately dismissed it, affirming the decision of the High Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the term "opportunities for casino gambling" should be interpreted narrowly to mean only an increase in the number of gaming machines, table games, or player positions, or broadly to include other factors such as speed of play and total floor area of the gambling area.
2. Whether the Court should consider the legislative history and Cabinet papers to interpret the term "opportunities for casino gambling".
3. Whether the broad interpretation of the term leads to unworkable or undesirable consequences.
Held
1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The appellants must pay to the respondent costs of $6,000 plus usual disbursements.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered the interpretation of the phrase "opportunities for casino gambling" in sections 11, 12, and 139(2)(d) of the Gambling Act 2003. Skycity argued for a narrow interpretation, limiting the term to an increase in the number of gaming machines, table games, or player positions. The Gambling Commission contended that the term should be interpreted broadly to include factors such as speed of play and total floor area of the gambling area. The Court rejected Skycity's arguments, holding that the term should be interpreted broadly. The Court found that the ordinary meaning of "opportunities" was not inherently ambiguous and that interpretative aids such as noscitur a sociis and ejusdem generis did not support a narrow interpretation. The legislative history and statutory context also did not support limiting the term narrowly. The Court also dismissed Skycity's contention that a broad interpretation would lead to unworkable or undesirable consequences. The Court concluded that the Gambling Commission was entrusted with the task of determining what constitutes an increase in gambling opportunities, a role that involves difficult and uncertain assessments. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the term "opportunities for casino gambling" should be interpreted broadly to include factors beyond just the number of gaming machines, table games, or player positions.