Commerce Commission v Bluestone Mortgages NZ Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2009-409-000617 [2012] NZHC 1946

BETWEEN  COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

ANDBLUESTONE MORTGAGES NZ LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing:         14 June 2012

Appearances: S J Mills QC for Plaintiff

D J Goddard QC for Respondent

Judgment:      6 August 2012

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 6 August 2012 at 4:00 pm

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date......................................

Solicitors:           Meredith Connell, P O Box 2213, Auckland 1140

Fax:  (09) 336-7629 –

Bell Gully, P O Box 4199, Auckland 1140

Fax: (09) 916-8801

Counsel:             S J Mills QC, P O Box 4338 Shortland Street, Auckland 1140

Fax: (09) 377-6956 – Email: stephen.mills@shortlandchambers.co.nz

D J Goddard QC, P O Box 1530, Wellington 6140

Fax: (04) 499-6118 – Email: david.goddard@chambers.co.nz

COMMERCE COMMISSION V BLUESTONE MORTGAGES NZ LTD HC AK CIV-2009-409-000617 [6

August 2012]

Introduction

[1]     The first defendant, Bluestone Mortgages Limited (Bluestone), lends on residential mortgages to what are commonly referred to nowadays as sub-prime borrowers.   Although loans were typically granted for a 30-year term, most were repaid within the first four years.1      The loan agreements included a credit fee called a deferred establishment fee (DEF) payable in the event of early repayment.  Under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 (CCCF Act) credit fees of this

kind must not be unreasonable.  The Commerce Commission alleges that the DEF provided for in the Bluestone mortgages was unreasonable and breached ss 41(1) and s 51 of the CCCF Act.  It is seeking a refund of a number of such fees.

[2]      Initially, the Commission’s allegations were limited to loans entered  into between 5 April 2005 and 13 October 2006.  However, its second amended statement of claim seeks to extend this time frame to cover loans entered into between 5 April

2005 and 6 July 2011.   The defendants assert that some of the loans entered into within this extended time frame are barred by High Court r 7.77 and the limitation provision in s 95(2) of the CCCF Act.  The parties have made a joint application2 for the determination of the following questions before trial:

Question one:  whether, in respect of a fee which breaches any of sections 41,

51 or 543 of the CCCF Act, the limitation period under s 95(2) of the CCCF Act commences:

(i)on  the  date  when  a  borrower  and  a  lender  enter  into  a  contract containing the fee; or

(ii)       on the date when a lender charges the borrower the fee.

1  The loans were securitised and the second and third defendants, Trustees Executors Limited and TEA Custodians (Bluestone) Ltd, acted as trustees on the securitisation. This aspect is not relevant to the present application.

2 Pursuant to r 10.15 of the High Court Rules.

3 Although the parties have referred to s 54 amongst the provisions allegedly breached, the statement of claim alleges breaches of s 41 “by virtue of” ss 42-44 and a breach of s 51 “by virtue of”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Bluestone Mortgages NZ Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1946
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Commerce Commission has brought proceedings against Bluestone Mortgages Limited (Bluestone) seeking a refund of deferred establishment fees (DEF) charged on residential mortgages. The Commission alleges that the DEF provided for in the Bluestone mortgages was unreasonable and breached ss 41(1) and s 51 of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 (CCCF Act). The parties made a joint application for the determination of two questions before trial, relating to the commencement of the limitation period under s 95(2) of the CCCF Act and whether the Commission is time-barred from amending its first amended statement of claim to include causes of action arising from loans settled or discharged after certain dates. The court held that the limitation period under s 95(2) of the CCCF Act commences on the date when a borrower and a lender enter into a contract containing the fee, and that the Commission is time-barred from amending its first amended statement of claim to include causes of action arising from loans settled after 13 October 2006 or discharged after 5 March 2007 and which were also settled before 6 July 2008. The Commission's attempt to bring a representative claim was found to be insufficient to avoid the application of the limitation provisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established