Paper Reclaim Ltd v Aotearoa International Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA70/04
[2007] NZCA 544

BETWEENPAPER RECLAIM LIMITED


Appellant

ANDAOTEAROA INTERNATIONAL LIMITED


Respondent

Court:William Young  P, Chambers and O'Regan JJ

Counsel:G J Judd QC for Appellant


A F Grant for Respondent

Judgment:28 November 2007 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AWith respect to costs in the High Court, the appellant must pay to the respondent costs calculated on a category 2 basis as follows:

(a)all pre-trial steps other than discovery and inspection are to be calculated on a band B basis;

(b)discovery and inspection are to be calculated on a band C basis;

(c)the allowance for trial (schedule 3, item 9.1) to be assessed as if the trial had taken ten days;

(d)trial preparation (schedule 3, item 8) to be assessed on basis of the assumed trial duration of ten days (ie 20 days).

BWith respect to disbursements in the High Court, the appellant must pay to the respondent:

(a)filing fees - $2,655

(b)travel expenses - $38.24

(c)photocopying - $8,289

(d)fax, tolls, courier and internet - $2,000

(e)70% of the hearing fees paid by the respondent.

C        The claim for disbursements in respect of David Appleby’s fees is deferred until the quantum hearing in the High Court, for determination by the judge who hears that quantum hearing. 

DThe appellant must pay to the respondent interest on the total sum payable under orders A and B.  Interest is to be calculated at 7.5% pa from 30 August 2004 down to the date of this judgment.

EThe parties are at liberty to apply to the High Court with respect to any matters arising from the implementation of orders A, B, and D.

F        No order as to costs in this court on this application. 

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Chambers J)

Table of Contents

Para No

The costs aftermath of a paper dispute  [1]
Issues on the appeal  [12]
Should there be no order for costs because of Aotearoa’s
           failure on so much of its claim against Paper Reclaim?  [21]
Should the proceeding be categorised as category 2
           or category 3?  [29]
What bands should apply to pre-trial steps?  [34]
Should interest be allowed on the costs order?  [40]
Should Aotearoa recover the cost of non-party discovery?        [46]
Should the disbursement for photocopying be reduced?           [55]
Should Aotearoa recover Mr Appleby’s fee at this stage?         [57]
Costs in this court  [62]

The costs aftermath of a paper dispute

[1]       Paper Reclaim Limited and Aotearoa International Limited had a business relationship from the 1980s until 2001.  Essentially, Aotearoa undertook the export of Paper Reclaim’s wastepaper on an exclusive basis and was entitled to be remunerated by commission at the rate of 10% of the sales price to the overseas buyer.  The arrangement appears to have been extremely advantageous to both companies.

[2]       In 2001, however, Paper Reclaim moved to end the relationship.  Aotearoa disputed Paper Reclaim's right to end the relationship.  It commenced a proceeding against Paper Reclaim, alleging multiple causes of action. 

[3]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paper Reclaim Ltd v Aotearoa International Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZCA 544
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand was tasked with determining the costs aftermath of a business dispute between Paper Reclaim Limited and Aotearoa International Limited. The companies had been in a business relationship since the 1980s, with Aotearoa exporting Paper Reclaim's wastepaper and being remunerated by commission. In 2001, Paper Reclaim ended the relationship, which Aotearoa disputed, leading to legal proceedings. Aotearoa was largely successful in the High Court, but Paper Reclaim appealed, and the Court of Appeal partially allowed the appeal, setting aside the costs judgment. The Supreme Court later upheld the Court of Appeal's judgment, and the Court of Appeal was asked to fix the costs.

The Court of Appeal considered various issues, including whether Aotearoa's failure on most of its claims against Paper Reclaim should result in no costs order, the appropriate category for the proceeding (category 2 or 3), the bands for pre-trial steps, whether interest should be allowed on the costs order, and whether Aotearoa should recover the cost of non-party discovery and the disbursement for photocopying. The Court of Appeal rejected the submission that costs should lie where they fall, and decided there should be a reduction in costs due to Aotearoa's failure on many of its claims. The proceeding was categorised as category 2, with pre-trial steps calculated on a band B basis, except for discovery and inspection, which were calculated on a band C basis. The Court of Appeal also allowed interest on the costs order from the date of the original costs judgment until the date of the Court of Appeal's judgment. The Court of Appeal did not allow Aotearoa to recover the cost of non-party discovery, as it was not directly relevant to the cause of action on which Aotearoa succeeded. However, the Court of Appeal allowed the claim for photocopying disbursement, as it was relevant to the cause of action on which Aotearoa succeeded. The Court of Appeal deferred the decision on Aotearoa recovering Mr Appleby's fee until the quantum hearing in the High Court. Finally, the Court of Appeal decided there would be no order for costs in respect of the application, as neither side's position had been completely upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

Paper Reclaim Limited and Aotearoa International Limited had a business relationship from the 1980s until 2001. Aotearoa exported Paper Reclaim's wastepaper on an exclusive basis, remunerated by a commission of 10% of the sales price to the overseas buyer. In 2001, Paper Reclaim moved to end the relationship, which Aotearoa disputed and commenced proceedings against. Aotearoa alleged multiple causes of action against Paper Reclaim. In the High Court, Aotearoa was largely successful, establishing an oral contract with Paper Reclaim, which was terminable on reasonable notice. Nicholson J fixed the period of reasonable notice at eight years. Aotearoa also succeeded on various other causes of action, with quantum to be determined later. On 30 August 2004, Nicholson J delivered a costs judgment, adopting an indemnity costs regime based on Paper Reclaim improperly defending the proceeding. However, the judge reduced the amount of costs by 20% due to various factors, including Aotearoa's failed claims and Paper Reclaim's success on its counterclaim. Aotearoa's solicitor-client costs came to approximately $515,000, with the award being 80% of that sum, approximately $412,000. In addition, Nicholson J awarded Aotearoa disbursements totalling $117,000.

Paper Reclaim appealed against both judgments. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in part, setting aside the costs judgment and reducing the reasonable notice period to 12 months. The Supreme Court upheld the Court of Appeal's judgment in all respects but one, resulting in Aotearoa receiving even lower damages once quantum is determined. Following the Supreme Court's decision, memorandums were filed, and the Court of Appeal considered the question of costs on the papers.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Should there be no order for costs in the High Court because of Aotearoa's failure on so much of its claim against Paper Reclaim?
2. Should the proceeding be categorised as category 2 or category 3?
3. What bands should apply to pre-trial steps?
4. Should interest be allowed on the costs order?
5. Should Aotearoa recover the cost of non-party discovery?
6. Should the disbursement for photocopying be reduced?
7. Should Aotearoa recover Mr Appleby's fee at this stage?

Held
1. There should be a costs order in the High Court, reduced in accordance with Aotearoa's partial success.
2. The proceeding should be categorised as category 2.
3. All pre-trial steps other than discovery and inspection are to be calculated on a band B basis; discovery and inspection are to be calculated on a band C basis.
4. Interest should be allowed on the costs order from 30 August 2004 down to the date of this judgment.
5. Aotearoa should not recover the costs of non-party discovery.
6. The disbursement for photocopying should not be reduced.
7. Aotearoa should not recover Mr Appleby's fee at this stage.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the costs aftermath of the dispute between Paper Reclaim and Aotearoa International. Aotearoa had largely succeeded in the High Court, but failed on several of its causes of action and on its counterclaim. The Court of Appeal had previously set aside the costs order, finding Aotearoa had not established that Paper Reclaim improperly defended the proceeding. The Court of Appeal was now required to determine an appropriate costs order in the High Court. The parties disagreed on several issues, including whether Aotearoa should be allowed to recover costs at all, the categorisation of the proceeding, the banding of pre-trial steps, the allowance of interest, the recovery of non-party discovery costs, the reduction of photocopying disbursements, and the recovery of Mr Appleby's fees at this stage.

The Court rejected the argument that there should be no costs order because of Aotearoa's failure on so much of its claim. While Aotearoa did fail on many of its pleaded causes of action, it succeeded on the fundamental issue of the existence of an oral contract. The Court concluded there should be a costs order, but reduced to reflect Aotearoa's partial success.

The proceeding was categorised as category 2 at an early stage, and the Court held it should remain as such. The Court found no special reasons for recategorisation, as the proceeding remained of average complexity.

The Court determined that all pre-trial steps other than discovery and inspection should be calculated on a band B basis, while discovery and inspection should be calculated on a band C basis. The Court found increased costs above band C were not warranted for inspection and preparation, as the time spent was within the allocated band C limits.

The Court allowed interest on the costs order from 30 August 2004 down to the date of this judgment, to compensate Aotearoa for the delay in securing a "proper" costs award. The Court did not backdate interest to the date of Nicholson J's liability judgment, as it seemed unfair to burden Paper Reclaim with interest on costs it did not know would be ordered until later.

The Court found Aotearoa should not recover the costs of non-party discovery, as the documents were sought in relation to causes of action on which Aotearoa had failed. The Court did not need to determine whether the non-party discovery would have been ordered had its relevance been confined to the credibility of Paper Reclaim's directors, as it was clear that was not the basis upon which the discovery was sought.

The Court allowed Aotearoa's claim for photocopying disbursements, as Mr Judd's challenge was rather lacking in specifics.

The Court held it was premature to award Mr Appleby's fee at this stage, as his work was primarily focused on quantum, which has yet to be determined. The judge presiding over the quantum hearing would be in a better position to assess the reasonableness of the claim for Mr Appleby's fee.

The Court made no order for costs in respect of this application, as neither side's position had been completely upheld. The levels of success were roughly equal.