Mathias v Toka Tū Ake - Natural Hazards Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2021-009-2441 [2025] NZHC 1170
BETWEEN

CAROL ANN MATHIAS

Plaintiff

AND

TOKA TŪ AKE – NATURAL HAZARDS COMMISSION

Defendant

Hearing: 20 February 2025

Appearances:

G D R Shand for Plaintiff

J A Tocher, E R Gatenby and C J Curran for Defendant

Judgment:

15 May 2025


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE PAULSEN

SECURITY FOR COSTS AND FURTHER DISCOVERY


This judgment was delivered by me on 15 May 2025 at 11.30 am pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

MATHIAS v TOKA TŪ AKE – NATURAL HAZARDS COMMISSION [2025] NZHC 1170 [15 May 2025]

Allocation of trial fixture  [5]

Parties’ positions  [6]

My assessment  [17]

Re-categorisation of the proceeding  [26]

The law  [29]

Parties’ positions  [37]

My assessment  [42]

The application for security for costs  [45]

The law  [48]

My assessment  [50]

The application for further discovery  [71]

Are the documents sought relevant?  [76]

Are there grounds for belief that the documents sought exist?  [77]

Is discovery proportionate?  [81]

Is an order appropriate?  [82]

Future timetable  [84]

Result  [86]

[1]                   Ms Mathias purchased a property damaged in the Canterbury earthquake sequence (CES) and upon which the Earthquake Commission (EQC) had undertaken repairs under its Christchurch Home Repair Programme. She also took an assignment of her vendor’s rights, interests and title in respect to claims against EQC (now Toka Tū Ake – Natural Hazards Commission (NHC)) under the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 (the Act).

[2]                   Ms Mathias says the repairs were not to the standard required by the Act and she is now faced with an uninsured gap, being the difference between her statutory entitlement and the actual cost to repair the property to the required standard, which she seeks to recover in this proceeding.

[3]                   Ms Mathias was granted leave under r 4.24 of the High Court Rules 2016 (the Rules) to serve as a representative plaintiff on behalf of other on-sold homeowners in her position.1 The common issue to be determined at stage I of the proceeding is:2

Whether, when settling a claim for natural disaster damage to a residential building pursuant to ss 18 and 29 of the Act, EQC owed a duty of care to a future purchaser of that residential building to:

(a)exercise due skill and care in its recording, scoping and costing of the natural disaster damage; and/or

(b)if a managed repair occurred, to provide/produce a repair that met the standard required by the EQC Act.

[4]                   Ms Mathias’s claim is ready to be set down for trial but a number of issues have arisen that must first be resolved. This judgment concerns the following matters:

(a)allocation of dates for the trial;

(b)an application by NHC to re-categorise the proceeding as category 3 for costs purposes;

(c)an application by NHC for security for costs;


1      Mathias v The Earthquake Commission [2022] NZHC 2097.

2 At [24].

(d)an application by NHC that Ms Mathias provide further…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mathias v Toka Tū Ake - Natural Hazards Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 1170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Carol Ann Mathias, the plaintiff, purchased a property damaged in the Canterbury earthquake sequence (CES). Upon purchase, she took an assignment of her vendor’s rights, interests, and title in respect of claims against the Earthquake Commission (EQC), now known as Toka Tū Ake – Natural Hazards Commission (NHC). Mathias alleges that the repairs undertaken by EQC were not to the standard required by the Earthquake Commission Act 1993 and that she now faces an uninsured gap, being the difference between her statutory entitlement and the actual cost to repair the property to the required standard. Mathias seeks to recover this difference in the proceeding. Mathias was granted leave to serve as a representative plaintiff on behalf of other on-sold homeowners in her position. The common issue to be determined at stage I of the proceeding is whether EQC owed a duty of care to a future purchaser of the residential building to exercise due skill and care in its recording, scoping, and costing of the natural disaster damage and, if a managed repair occurred, to provide/produce a repair that met the standard required by the EQC Act.

The court addressed several issues, including the allocation of trial dates, re-categorisation of the proceeding for costs purposes, an application by NHC for security for costs, an application by NHC that Mathias provide further discovery, and the making of pre-trial directions. The court found that the trial should be set down for 34 days commencing on 12 April 2027. The court also found there were special reasons to re-categorise the proceeding as category 3 for costs purposes. The court found that NHC was entitled to security for costs in the amount of $628,882.50 and ordered Mathias to provide further discovery of documents relating to her efforts to obtain insurance, documents attached to certain emails, documents provided by the land agent, documents relating to her awareness of issues with the property after purchase, documents relating to any repairs carried out after purchase, documents relating to her ability, intention, and plans to repair the property, and documents relating to her awareness of concerns about repairs made to earthquake-damaged properties in Christchurch.

The court's final orders were that the case is to be set down for trial for 34 days commencing 12 April 2027, the proceeding is re-categorised for costs purposes as category 3, Mathias shall provide by 1 August 2025 a first tranche of security for NHC's costs and disbursements in the sum of $628,882.50, Mathias shall file and serve a further affidavit of documents by 27 June 2025 specifying whether the documents described in Schedule B are or have been in her control, and Mathias is to provide all documents listed in her further affidavit to NHC for inspection by 11 July 2025.