Mathias v Toka Tū Ake - Natural Hazards Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2021-009-2441 [2025] NZHC 1887

BETWEEN  CAROL ANN MATHIAS

Plaintiff

ANDTOKA TŪ AKE – NATURAL HAZARDS COMMISSION

Defendant

Hearing:                   On the papers

Counsel:                   G D R Shand for Plaintiff

J A Tocher, E R Gatenby and C J Curran for Defendant

Judgment:                10 July 2025


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE PAULSEN (COSTS)


This judgment was delivered by me on 10 July 2025 at 3.30 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

MATHIAS v TOKA TŪ AKE – NATURAL HAZARDS COMMISSION [2025] NZHC 1887 [10 July 2025]

[1]In a judgment of 15 May 2025, I resolved several issues including:1

(a)the dates of trial;

(b)applications by NHC:

(i)to recategorise the proceeding for cost purposes;

(ii)for security for costs; and

(iii)that Ms Mathias provide further discovery.

[2]        NHC was successful in all respects and is entitled to costs. I have received memoranda from counsel on the quantum of such costs.

[3]        NHC’s counsel provided a schedule of costs and disbursements sought, totalling $37,703.44 (attached as Schedule A). The costs claim comprised:

(a)scale 3B costs of $26,475.00;

(b)increased costs on the discovery application of $4,765.50; and

(c)reasonable disbursements of $6,462.94.

[4]The plaintiff challenges the claims made in the following respects.

[5]        First, the plaintiff says costs should be awarded on a category 2 basis as the category 3 classification only applies since 15 May 2025, being the date of my judgment.

[6]        My judgment did not deal with the date from which the reclassification of the proceeding should apply. I note that cases have taken different approaches in relation to this. There are, for instance, cases where the reclassification has been ordered only


1      Mathias v Toka Tū Ake [2025] NZHC 1170.

from a particular stage of a proceeding.2 It was not my intention that the reclassification would apply to steps taken prior to the date of my judgment. I award costs on a category 2 basis.

[7]        NHC claims for two counsel which the plaintiff says was not required in respect to a hearing of interlocutory applications of less than one day. It was noted there were no live witnesses, and the affidavit evidence was minimal with few important documents. It is also noted that Ms Mathias proceeded with only one counsel. Mr Shand submits that making an award for second counsel would be contrary to the principles of pt 14 of the High Court Rules 2016 (the Rules), and an award should not encourage multiplicity of lawyers resulting in increased costs for participants. Mr Shand also notes that to make an allowance for second counsel has flow-on effects in respect to disbursements for airfares and accommodation.

[8]        In my view, second counsel was not reasonably necessary given the nature of the applications which, except in relation to security for costs, raised no difficult issues. All matters could have been comfortably dealt with by Mr Curran. I make no allowance for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mathias v Toka Tū Ake - Natural Hazards Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 1887
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Mathias v Toka Tū Ake – Natural Hazards Commission was presided over by Associate Judge Paulsen. The matter primarily dealt with the costs and timetable directions following a previous judgment concerning various interlocutory applications. The plaintiff, Carol Ann Mathias, challenged the Natural Hazards Commission's (NHC) claims for costs and disbursements, while also proposing an earlier trial timetable.

The court had to decide several legal issues concerning the assessment of costs and the proposed timetable for the trial. The specific issues included whether the costs should be awarded on a category 2 or 3 basis, the necessity of having two counsel for the NHC, the allowance for costs related to submissions and bundles, and the appropriateness of awarding costs for the cost application itself. The court also deliberated on the proposed timetable for the trial, considering the plaintiff's appeal against the earlier judgment and the need for security for costs.

The court found that costs should be awarded on a category 2 basis as the reclassification to category 3 only applied from the date of the judgment. The court determined that having two counsel for NHC was not reasonably necessary given the nature of the applications. It also ruled that there should be a single award for submissions and bundles, with a specific allowance for the preparation of submissions related to the discovery application. The court rejected the claim for costs on the cost application itself, noting that both parties had success in relation to issues of costs. An uplift of 25% was awarded for increased costs in relation to the discovery application due to the plaintiff’s failure to engage on discovery issues.

Regarding the timetable, the court agreed with NHC that it was premature to commence pre-trial steps due to the plaintiff's appeal and unresolved security for costs issues. The court set a close of pleadings date and provided detailed directions for the preparation and filing of briefs, expert conferral, and other pre-trial steps. It also reserved the right for either party to apply to vary the timetable if circumstances required it.

The court ordered NHC to be awarded costs and disbursements totalling $12,607.25 and $4,777.17 respectively. The timetable directions included specific deadlines for the service of briefs, expert conferral, and the filing of a joint memorandum on witnesses and time estimates. The common bundle of documents was to be prepared by the plaintiff’s solicitors and filed by a specified date. The court also scheduled a pre-trial conference and set the trial date.