Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (in liq) v Yan

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2015-404-1094

[2019] NZHC 1637

BETWEEN

MAINZEAL PROPERTY AND

CONSTRUCTION LIMITED (IN LIQ)
First Plaintiff

AND

KING FAÇADE LTD (PREVIOUSLY KNOWN AS RICHINA LAND LTD) (IN LIQ)

Second Plaintiff

AND

MAINZEAL GROUP LIMITED (IN LIQ)

Third Plaintiff

AND

ANDREW JAMES BETHELL AND BRIAN MAYO-SMITH

Fourth Plaintiffs

AND

RICHARD CILIANG YAN

First Defendant

AND

PETER GOMM

Second Defendant

AND

RT HON JENNIFER MARY SHIPLEY

Third Defendant

AND

CLIVE WILLIAM CHARLES TILBY

Fourth Defendant

AND

PAUL DAVID COLLINS

Fifth Defendant

AND

RICHINA GLOBAL REAL ESTATE LIMITED (IN LIQ)

Seventh Defendant

AND

ISOLA VINEYARDS LIMITED (PREVIOUSLY KNOWN AS WAIHEKE VINEYARDS LIMITED) (IN LIQ)

Eighth Defendant

MAINZEAL PROPERTY AND CONSTRUCTION LIMITED (IN LIQ) v YAN AND OTHERS [2019] NZHC 1637 [12 July 2019]

Hearing: 8 May 2019

Counsel:

M D O’Brien QC and M D Pascariu for the Plaintiffs

D J Chisholm QC and T P Mullins for the First Defendant
J E Hodder QC and J Marcetic for the Second to Fifth Defendants

Judgment:

12 July 2019


JUDGMENT (NO 2) OF COOKE J

(Applications to alter quantum, and costs)


Table of Contents

ALTERATIONS TO QUANTUM[3]

Application by liable defendants[9]

The plaintiffs’ application[23]

Conclusion on applications to alter quantum[31]

COSTS[36]

Time band uplifts[40]

Discovery (items 20 and 21)[43]

Preparation of common bundles (item 31)[46]

Preparation of plaintiffs’ briefs (step 30)[49]

Preparation for hearing (step 33)[53]

Plaintiffs’ claim for increased costs[57]

Settlement offers — r 14.6(3)(b)(v)[58]

Uplift on rule 14.6(3)(c)[64]

Fifth defendant’s costs[67]

The basis of the award[68]

Sanderson and Bullock orders[78]

Reduction in costs[81]

Disputed disbursements[91]

Mr Apps[92]

Mr Jones[95]

Mr Schubert[98]

Litigation disbursements[100]

Costs against Isola[108]

Slip rule corrections[109]

ORDERS[110]

[1]        There are two matters arising out of the judgment in these proceedings to be addressed:1

(a)the plaintiffs and the liable defendants have each applied for orders altering the amount of compensation awarded; and

(b)the plaintiffs and the fifth defendant have applied for costs.

[2]        As a consequence of these matters I scheduled a further hearing of the parties on 8 May 2019. Following that hearing the parties filed a number of supplementary memoranda addressing issues that emerged.

ALTERATIONS TO QUANTUM

[3]        In the judgment I reserved leave to the parties to apply to alter the judgment sum.2 The plaintiffs and the liable defendants have both made application to alter the amount awarded by the Court. Broadly speaking, the plaintiffs contend that the Court did not address their claim for interest on the second cause of action which would increase the sum awarded. The first to fourth defendants contend that the Court’s assessment of the losses to the companies’ creditors caused by the breach were exaggerated because the Court used the gross amount owing to the creditors without taking into account expected recoveries from the assets of the companies in liquidation. For reasons explained in greater detail below I accept that both applications raise legitimate points.

[4]        There is an initial jurisdictional point that has been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (in liq) v Yan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 1637
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves a proceeding between Mainzeal Property and Construction Limited and others (the plaintiffs) and Richard Ciliang Yan and others (the defendants) regarding compensation and costs in relation to breaches of directors' duties. The High Court of New Zealand heard applications to alter the quantum of compensation awarded and applications for costs. The Court considered the plaintiffs' claim for interest under the second cause of action and the liable defendants' contention that the Court's assessment of the losses to the companies' creditors was exaggerated. The Court found that both applications raised legitimate points but concluded that they effectively cancelled each other out and no adjustment to the compensation awarded was necessary. The Court also addressed various issues concerning costs, including time band uplifts, discovery, preparation of briefs, and preparation for trial. The Court awarded costs to the plaintiffs and the fifth defendant while denying certain claims for increased costs and disbursements. The Court made orders dismissing the applications to alter the quantum of compensation, awarding costs to the plaintiffs and the fifth defendant, and correcting errors in the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established