IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2015-404-1094
[2019] NZHC 255
BETWEEN MAINZEAL PROPERTY AND CONSTRUCTION LIMITED (IN LIQ)
First PlaintiffAND
KING FAÇADE LIMITED (PREVIOUSLY KNOWN AS RICHINA LAND LTD) (IN
LIQ)
Second PlaintiffAND
MAINZEAL GROUP LIMITED (IN LIQ)
Third Plaintiff
AND
ANDREW JAMES BETHELL AND BRIAN MAYO-SMITH
Fourth Plaintiffs
AND
RICHARD CILIANG YAN
First Defendant
AND
PETER GOMM
Second Defendant
AND
RT HON JENNIFER MARY SHIPLEY
Third Defendant
AND
CLIVE WILLIAM CHARLES TILBY
Fourth Defendant
AND
PAUL DAVID COLLINS
Fifth Defendant
AND
RICHINA GLOBAL REAL ESTATE LIMITED (IN LIQ)
Seventh Defendant
AND
ISOLA VINEYARDS LIMITED
(PREVIOUSLY KNOWN AS WAIHEKE VINEYARDS LIMITED) (IN LIQ)
Eighth Defendant
MAINZEAL PROPERTY AND CONSTRUCTION LTD (IN LIQ) v YAN AND OTHERS [2019] NZHC 255
[26 February 2019]
Hearing: 17–21 September; 24–28 September; 1–5 October; 8–12 October;
15–19 October; 22–26 October; 29 October–2 November; 5–9
November; 12–13 November 2018Counsel:
M D O’Brien QC, Z G Kennedy and M D Pascariu and Y J Lee for the Plaintiffs
D J Chisholm QC, T P Mullins, C I Hadlee, and R E Schultz for the First Defendant
J E Hodder QC, M D Arthur and J Marcetic for the Second to Fifth DefendantsJudgment:
26 February 2019
JUDGMENT OF COOKE J
Table of contents
INTRODUCTION [1]
FACTUAL FINDINGS [7]
The evidence [8]
Richina Pacific’s acquisition of Mainzeal [12]
Establishment of Independent Board in 2004 [18]
Funds extracted from Mainzeal [25]
Initial period of operations [32]
Chinese regulations [39]
2008-2009 restructuring [42]
PricewaterhouseCoopers concerns [57]
The post-delisting arrangements [61]
2010: Issues of concern raised [71]
Expressions of support [92]
Mr Pearce’s concerns [101]
Early 2011: Ernst & Young report [107]
Project Citron: The Pre-Paid Goods Agreement [114]
2012: Cash flow difficulties emerge [120]
Legal advice obtained [134]
The collapse [139]
SECTION 135 COMPANIES ACT 1993 [150]
The authorities [153]
The text in light of purpose [160]
Maintaining adequate capital [169]
Shareholder support [175]
Interests of the group [180]
APPLICATION OF SECTION 135 TO THIS CASE [186]
Policy of Trading Whilst Insolvent [190]
Was Mainzeal insolvent? [191]
Using creditors’ funds as working capital [203]
Reliance on group support [204]
Not clearly formulated [210]
Conditional [212]
Not binding [214]
The limitations of Chinese law [215]
The support that was provided [217]
Effect of restructuring [226]
Requests for clarification [231]
Conclusion on group support [235]
Financial trading position [238]
Trading position [239]
Prospects of one-off losses [244]
Leaky building liabilities [249]
Changed business plans [253]
Conclusion on financial trading position [258]
Additional Factors [259]
Reliance on auditors [260]
No legal advice taken [265]
Corporate governance standards [270]
Creditor knowledge [274]
Conclusion [277]
The timing of the breach [288]
SECTION 136 COMPANIES ACT 1993 [294]
DID THE DIRECTORS BREACH THEIR DUTIES UNDER S 136? [302]
THE KFL DEBT RESTRUCTURE [312]
Purpose and effect of KFL debt restructure [315]
Sixth and seventh causes of action – breaches of ss 131, 135 and 136 and breach of
fiduciary duties [327]
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (in liq) v Yan and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NZHC 255
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the directors did breach their duties under section 135 by continuing to trade while the company was insolvent. The company had been effectively insolvent from 2005 onwards due to loans extracted by the Richina Pacific group, which were used for investments in China. Although the directors claimed to have assurances from Richina Pacific that support would be provided, these assurances were not legally binding and were subject to significant limitations. The court held that the directors' reliance on these assurances was unreasonable, and their conduct exposed creditors to a substantial risk of serious loss, which amounted to a breach of section 135. The court assessed the loss to creditors and determined the appropriate contribution from the directors to the deficiency in liquidation. The court also addressed other claims brought by the plaintiffs, largely dismissing them but upholding a smaller claim by one of the plaintiffs against a defendant. The court reserved leave for the parties to apply for corrections to the judgment, particularly concerning potential arithmetical errors or omissions. The court further granted leave to the liquidators to apply if any claims were made by Richina Pacific in relation to certain liabilities.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi