Yan v Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI O AOTEAROA

 SC 48/2021
SC 52/2021

 [2023] NZSC 113
BETWEEN

RICHARD CILIANG YAN
First Appellant

PETER GOMM
Second Appellant

JENNIFER MARY SHIPLEY
Third Appellant

CLIVE WILLIAM CHARLES TILBY
Fourth Appellant

AND

MAINZEAL PROPERTY AND CONSTRUCTION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
First Respondent

ANDREW JAMES BETHELL AND ANDREW MCKAY
Second Respondents

Hearing:

 Further Submissions:

7–11 March 2022


22 November 2022 and 2 March 2023

Court:

Winkelmann CJ, William Young, Glazebrook, O’Regan and Ellen France JJ

Counsel:

D J Chisholm KC, T P Mullins and T Hu for Mr Yan
J E Hodder KC, M D Arthur and J Marcetic for Mr Gomm, Dame Jennifer Shipley and Mr Tilby
M D O’Brien KC, Z G Kennedy and M D Pascariu for Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (in liq) and Messrs Bethell and McKay

Judgment:

25 August 2023

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeals by the directors are dismissed. 

BThe cross-appeal by the liquidators is allowed to the extent that in lieu of the remittal of the proceedings back to the High Court, we order the directors to contribute to the assets of Mainzeal $39.8 million together with interest at prescribed rates since 28 February 2013 with the liabilities of Dame Jennifer Shipley and Messrs Tilby and Gomm each limited to $6.6 million and interest.

CThe directors are to pay costs in the sum of $65,000 together with reasonable disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

(Given by Winkelmann CJ and William Young J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction [1]
Factual background [12]
  Takeover by interests associated with Mr Richard Yan [13]
  Relationship between Mainzeal and its controlling shareholders [15]
  Funds extracted from Mainzeal for use in China [20]
  Trading 2005–2012 [24]
  Balance sheet solvency/insolvency [31]
  Promises of shareholder support [36]
  Mainzeal’s strategy for dealing with the irrecoverable loans [45]
  Window dressing [50]
  Events in 2010 [51]
  The position as at 31 January 2011 [69]
  Events February 2011–February 2013 [73]
The High Court’s approach [100]
The Court of Appeal’s approach [106]
Legal context and history [111]
Preliminaries [112]
  The 1993 Act and relevant principles and features of company law [115]
The statutory antecedents of ss 135, 136 and 301 [126]
Judicial recognition of a requirement for directors to have regard to
  the interests of creditors

[142]
The report and recommendations of the Law Commission [144]
The Parliamentary process in relation to the 1993 Act [149]
Section 301 as enacted [155]
  Recent case law [170]
Debut Homes [170]
BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA [178]
Stanford International Bank Ltd (in liq) v HSBC Bank Plc [185]
Where we get to [189]
Liability under s 135 [190]
The directors’ arguments as to how s 135 should be applied [190]
The liquidators’ arguments as to how s 135 should be applied [194]
Our approach to the application of s 135: overview [195]
Fault requirement [200]
Can directors balance loss on insolvency against risk of loss of
    trading on?

[212]
Our approach compared to that adopted in Sequana and
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yan v Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (in liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZSC 113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the insolvency of Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd, a major New Zealand construction company that was placed in receivership and liquidation in February 2013. The liquidators brought claims against the directors of Mainzeal, alleging breaches of s 135 and s 136 of the Companies Act 1993. The High Court allowed the s 135 claim but dismissed the s 136 claim. The Court of Appeal allowed the s 136 claim but held that the liquidators had not established losses for which compensation could be awarded under s 135. The liquidators cross-appealed, seeking a larger award of compensation under s 135, a finding that the directors had also breached s 136 and compensation for that breach. The Court of Appeal held that the directors breached s 136 by entering into obligations incurred in respect of four major projects entered into after 31 January 2011 and all obligations incurred from 5 July 2012 onwards. It held that for those breaches of s 136, compensation should be fixed by reference to the amount of the debts incurred after the relevant breach dates, to the extent that those debts remain unsatisfied after allowing for any dividends in the liquidation. It remitted the proceedings to the High Court to determine the amount of the relevant new debt and to decide whether, in the exercise of a discretion conferred by s 301 of the 1993 Act, that amount or a lesser sum should be awarded as compensation. The Court of Appeal judgment is now before this Court. The directors appeal against the Court of Appeal judgment and the liquidators cross-appeal. The liquidators ask that this Court fix compensation in respect of both claims rather than referring the issue back to the High Court. The appeals and cross-appeal raise issues of fundamental importance to the business community. They involve the scope and application of duties under ss 135 and 136 of the Companies Act 1993 — provisions that address the interests of creditors — and how compensation for breach of these duties should be assessed. The central issue in this case is whether the directors of Mainzeal breached s 135 and/or s 136 of the Companies Act 1993. The directors say that they did not breach s 135 because they had reasonable grounds to believe that Mainzeal would be able to meet its debts when they fell due. The liquidators say that the directors breached s 135 by continuing to trade when they did not have reasonable grounds to believe that Mainzeal would be able to meet its debts when they fell due. They also say that the directors breached s 136 by incurring obligations when they did not have reasonable grounds to believe that Mainzeal would be able to meet those obligations when they fell due. The directors say that they did not breach s 136 because the four major projects entered into by Mainzeal after 31 January 2011 were not “debts” and because Mainzeal had reasonable grounds to believe that it would be able to meet its debts when they fell due. The liquidators say that the directors breached s 136 by entering into the four major projects and by incurring obligations after 5 July 2012. In this judgment, we first set out the relevant provisions of the Companies Act 1993 and the associated case law. We discuss the statutory antecedents of ss 135, 136 and 301, the associated case law, the reform proposals developed by the Law Commission in the late 1980s and the rather confused legislative history of the 1993 Act. We then set out the factual background and the approaches of the High Court and Court of Appeal. The factual background is set out in detail in the judgments of the High Court and Court of Appeal. We do not repeat it in this judgment but refer to it where necessary. We then turn to the issues of liability under ss 135 and 136. We conclude that the directors breached s 135 and s 136. We also conclude that the Court of Appeal’s approach to quantifying compensation for breach of s 136 was correct, albeit with some modifications. We fix compensation in respect of the breaches of s 135 and s 136 at $39.8 million. The Court of Appeal held that the liquidators had not established losses for which compensation could be awarded under s 135. We disagree with that conclusion. The liquidators have made concessions that adequately addressed all factual uncertainties to the point that we are satisfied that it is more likely than not that the losses for which compensation can be awarded exceed the amount now claimed by the liquidators. We fix the loss calculated on a new debt basis at $39.8 million. Treating culpability as the critical factor, the Court has directed the directors to pay compensation of $39.8 million together with interest apportioned on the basis that Mr Yan is responsible for the entire amount, with the liability of the other directors limited to $6.6 million and interest each. The orders of the Court are: (a) The appeals by the directors are dismissed. (b) The cross-appeal by the liquidators is allowed to the extent that in lieu of the remittal of the proceedings back to the High Court, we order the directors to contribute to the assets of Mainzeal $39.8 million together with interest at prescribed rates since 28 February 2013 with the liabilities of Dame Jennifer Shipley and Messrs Tilby and Gomm each limited to $6.6 million and interest. (c) The directors must pay costs to the liquidators of $65,000 plus usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established