Osborne v Worksafe New Zealand

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2014-485-11211 [2015] NZHC 2991

UNDER the Judicature Amendment Act 1972

IN THE MATTER

of an application for judicial review of decisions under s 185 and s 188 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 and s 68 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957

BETWEEN

ANNA ELIZABETH OSBORNE First Applicant

AND

SONYA LYNNE ROCKHOUSE Second Applicant

AND

WORKSAFE NEW ZEALAND First Respondent

AND

DISTRICT COURT AT WELLINGTON Second Respondent

Hearing: 25-26 May 2015

Counsel:

N Hampton QC and S Meikle for Applicants
J Holden and M Conway for First Respondent
No Appearance for Second Respondent

Judgment:

27 November 2015

JUDGMENT OF BROWN J

OSBORNE & OR v WORKSAFE NZ & OR [2015] NZHC 2991 [27 November 2015]

Table of Contents

Paragraph No.

Introduction  [1] The issues  [7] Relevant factual background  [9]

The proposal  [12] The decision-making phase  [15] The Prosecution Decision  [22] Steps prior to the District Court Decision  [24] The District Court Decision  [29] Two matters in dispute  [30]

Is the Prosecution Decision amenable to judicial review?  [31]

In deciding not to proceed with the prosecution against
Mr Whittall did the prosecutor fail to comply with the

Guidelines?  [44]

Alleged illegal agreement  [52]

Was the proposal of a voluntary payment an

irrelevant consideration?  [60]

Worksafe’s consideration of other pleaded factors  [64]

In deciding not to proceed with the prosecution against
Mr Whittall did the prosecution fail to have regard to s 5(g)

of the Act?  [78]

Did the applicants have a legitimate expectation that they would be consulted prior to the prosecutor making its decision and, if so, did the failure to so consult with them render the Prosecution Decision unlawful, invalid or

unreasonable?  [83]

Was the District Court Decision unlawful by reason of the

process whereby the decision was made?  [95]

Alleged failure to conduct hearing on the merits  [98]

Alleged failure to act judicially  [103]

Was the District Court Decision unlawful by reason of the

alleged unlawfulness of the Prosecution Decision?  [118]

Was the District Court Decision unlawful because the

District Court Judge had recused herself?  [123] Disposition  [137]

Introduction

[1]      The tragic events at the Pike River Mine on 19 November 2010 are well known.1      Twenty-nine  workers  perished  in  the  explosion.    The  first  applicant, Ms Osborne, lost her husband; the second applicant, Ms Rockhouse, lost a son.

[2]      On 10 November 2011 Keith Stewart, a health and safety inspector of the first respondent (Worksafe, formerly the Department of Labour),2 filed in the District Court at Greymouth informations against Pike River Coal Ltd (in receivership) (PRCL), VLI Drilling Pty Ltd and Peter William Whittall, an employee and officer of PRCL (Mr Whittall) alleging breaches of various sections of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992 (the Act).

[3]      On    26 October 2012    in    the    District    Court    at    Greymouth    before Judge J A Farish VLI Drilling Pty Ltd pleaded guilty to the three charges and was fined a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Osborne v Worksafe New Zealand and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 2991
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Ms Osborne and Ms Rockhouse, sought judicial review of decisions made by Worksafe and the District Court at Wellington in the course of the criminal proceedings brought against Mr Whittall for his role in the Pike River Mine explosion. The applicants sought to challenge the legality of the Prosecution Decision, the decision by Worksafe not to proceed with the prosecution against Mr Whittall, and the District Court Decision, the dismissal of the charges against Mr Whittall by the District Court. The applicants contended that the decisions were unlawful and amounted to an extraordinary decision striking at the heart and integrity of the criminal justice system in New Zealand. The applicants pleaded two causes of action against Worksafe and three against the District Court. The issues were whether the Prosecution Decision was amenable to judicial review, whether the prosecutor had failed to comply with the Solicitor-General’s Prosecution Guidelines and whether the prosecutor had failed to have regard to relevant considerations in deciding not to proceed with the prosecution against Mr Whittall. The applicants also contended that they had a legitimate expectation that they would be consulted prior to the prosecutor making its decision. The District Court Decision was alleged to be unlawful by reason of the process whereby the decision was made, the alleged unlawfulness of the Prosecution Decision and the District Court Judge having recused herself. The court found that the Prosecution Decision was not amenable to judicial review. The court found that the prosecutor had not failed to comply with the Prosecution Guidelines. The court found that the prosecutor had not failed to have regard to relevant considerations in deciding not to proceed with the prosecution against Mr Whittall. The court found that the applicants had not had a legitimate expectation that they would be consulted prior to the prosecutor making its decision. The court found that the District Court Decision was not unlawful by reason of the process whereby the decision was made, the alleged unlawfulness of the Prosecution Decision or the District Court Judge having recused herself. The application for judicial review was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established