| For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link |
| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA735/2015 [2017] NZCA 11 |
| BETWEEN | ANNA ELIZABETH OSBORNE AND SONYA LYNNE ROCKHOUSE |
| AND | WORKSAFE NEW ZEALAND |
| DISTRICT COURT AT WELLINGTON Second Respondent | |
| Hearing: | 9 August 2016 |
Court: | Kós P, Randerson and French JJ |
Counsel: | K N Hampton QC, S N Meikle and Z M McCoy for Appellant |
Judgment: | 16 February 2017 at 1.00pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A The appeal is dismissed.
B No order for costs.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Kós P)
On Friday, 19 November 2010 there was an underground explosion at the Pike River coal mine. Thirty-one men were in the mine. All but two were killed. The appellants both lost a family member: Ms Osborne her husband Milton, and Ms Rockhouse her son Benjamin. Ms Rockhouse’s other son Daniel was one of the two survivors.
Prosecutions under the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992 were commenced by the Department of Labour.[1] VLI Drilling International Pty Ltd,[2] a contractor, pleaded guilty to the three charges. It was fined $46,800. Pike River Coal Ltd,[3] the mine owner, faced nine charges. It did not defend them. It was in receivership by then. It was fined $760,000 and ordered to pay $3.41 million in reparation to the families of the 29 men killed and to the two survivors. That is, $110,000 per victim.
[1]Hereafter the “HSE Act”. The Department of Labour became part of the Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment (MBIE) in July 2012. Health and safety functions undertaken by the Department of Labour and MBIE were assumed by a section of MBIE called Worksafe New Zealand, the first respondent, in December 2013.
[2]Hereafter “VLI”.
[3]Hereafter “PRCL”.
PRCL’s chief executive, Mr Peter Whittall, faced 12 charges. He pleaded not guilty. In about August 2013 Mr Whittall undertook to make a voluntary payment of $3.41 million in the event the prosecution offered no evidence against him. The same sum PRCL had been ordered to pay. Given PRCL’s economic state, it was doubtful that payment would ever be made.
In December 2013 Worksafe decided that it would not offer any evidence in support of the charges against Mr Whittall. Judge Farish in the District Court then dismissed the charges against Mr Whittall. In due course the families received payments totalling $3.41 million from Mr Whittall.
Ms Osborne and Ms Rockhouse applied in September 2014 for judicial review of the prosecution decision not to offer evidence, and the District Court decision to dismiss the charges, against Mr Whittall.[4] They said the decisions were an unlawful bargain to stifle a prosecution in exchange for payment. It was not, however, suggested by the appellants that they would (or could) return the payments they had received.
[4]Hereafter “the Prosecution Decision” and “the District Court Decision” respectively.
Brown J dismissed their applications in November…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Osborne v Worksafe New Zealand and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZCA 11
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
- Nature of the dispute: The appellants argue that the decisions not to prosecute Mr Whittall and to dismiss the charges against him were unlawful, as they believe there was an unlawful bargain to stifle the prosecution in exchange for a payment of $3.41 million to the victims. They claim that Worksafe failed to comply with the Solicitor-General's Prosecution Guidelines, did not consider relevant factors, and did not consult them before making the decisions.
- Court: The Court of Appeal of New Zealand
- Legal issues: The court was required to decide whether the prosecutor's decision not to offer evidence in support of the charges against Mr Whittall was amenable to judicial review, if there was an unlawful agreement to stifle the prosecution, if the prosecutor failed to comply with the Prosecution Guidelines or failed to have regard to s 5(g) of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992, if the appellants had a legitimate expectation of consultation, and if the District Court's decision to dismiss the charges was unlawful.
- Court's reasoning and outcome: The Court of Appeal concluded that the prosecutor's decision was amenable to judicial review on all grounds raised. The court found that there was no unlawful bargain to stifle the prosecution, as the payment proposed by Mr Whittall was a conditional reparation undertaking, not a payment in exchange for dropping the charges. The court also found that Worksafe did not fail to comply with the Prosecution Guidelines or fail to have regard to s 5(g) of the HSE Act. Furthermore, the court held that the appellants did not have a legitimate expectation of consultation, as the statutory provisions and prosecution guidelines did not create such an expectation. Finally, the court determined that the District Court's decision to dismiss the charges was lawful.
- Final orders: The appeal was dismissed, and no order for costs was made.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated in the High Court of New Zealand where the appellants, Anna Osborne and Sonya Rockhouse, sought judicial review of the decision by Worksafe New Zealand not to proceed with the prosecution against Mr Peter Whittall, the former CEO of Pike River Coal Ltd. The High Court dismissed their application in November 2015. The appellants then appealed to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, which heard the appeal on 9 August 2016. The judgment was delivered on 16 February 2017, dismissing the appeal and affirming the decision of the High Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the prosecutor's decision on 4 December 2013 to offer no evidence in support of the charges against Mr Whittall on the basis that it was not in the public interest to do so ("Prosecution Decision") amenable to judicial review?
2. Did the prosecutor enter into an agreement with Mr Whittall that in return for the payment of $3.41 million to the victims it would offer no evidence in support of the charges against Mr Whittall?
3. In deciding not to proceed with the prosecution against Mr Whittall, did the prosecutor:
3.1 fail to comply with the Solicitor-General's Prosecution Guidelines; or
3.2 fail to have regard to s 5(g) of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992?
4. Did the applicants have a legitimate expectation that they would be consulted prior to the prosecutor making its decision?
5. If the answer to issues 2, 3 or 4 is yes, is the Prosecution Decision therefore unlawful, invalid or unreasonable?
6. If the answer to issue 5 is yes, should the relief sought by the appellants be granted?
7. Was the District Court's decision on 12 December 2013 to dismiss the charges against Mr Whittall unlawful by reason of:
7.1 the process whereby the decision was made;
7.2 the alleged unlawfulness of the Prosecution Decision; or
7.3 because the District Court Judge had recused herself?
Held
1. The prosecutor's decision on 4 December 2013 to offer no evidence in support of the charges against Mr Whittall on the basis that it was not in the public interest to do so is amenable to judicial review.
2. The prosecutor did not enter into an agreement with Mr Whittall that in return for the payment of $3.41 million to the victims it would offer no evidence in support of the charges against Mr Whittall.
3. The prosecutor did not:
3.1 fail to comply with the Solicitor-General's Prosecution Guidelines;
3.2 fail to have regard to s 5(g) of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992.
4. The applicants did not have a legitimate expectation that they would be consulted prior to the prosecutor making its decision.
5. The Prosecution Decision was not unlawful, invalid or unreasonable because the answer to issues 2, 3 or 4 is no.
6. The relief sought by the appellants should not be granted because the Prosecution Decision was not unlawful, invalid or unreasonable.
7. The District Court's decision on 12 December 2013 to dismiss the charges against Mr Whittall was not unlawful by reason of:
7.1 the process whereby the decision was made;
7.2 the alleged unlawfulness of the Prosecution Decision; or
7.3 because the District Court Judge had recused herself.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court examined the prosecutorial decision to offer no evidence in support of the charges against Mr Whittall and the District Court's decision to dismiss the charges against him. The Court concluded that the prosecutorial decision was amenable to judicial review as it was justiciable on the grounds raised. The Court found no evidence of an unlawful bargain to stifle the prosecution, and that the prosecutor did not fail to comply with the Prosecution Guidelines or fail to have regard to s 5(g) of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992. The Court also held that the applicants did not have a legitimate expectation to be consulted prior to the prosecutor making its decision. As a result, the Prosecution Decision was not unlawful, invalid, or unreasonable. Consequently, the relief sought by the appellants was not granted. The Court further found that the District Court Decision to dismiss the charges against Mr Whittall was not unlawful due to procedural errors or the District Court Judge's earlier recusal.
The Court emphasized the importance of judicial restraint in reviewing prosecutorial discretion, while acknowledging that in exceptional circumstances, such as allegations of an unlawful bargain, judicial review may be warranted. The Court examined the principles of prosecutorial discretion and the factors to be considered in making such decisions. It also discussed the role of reparation and the public interest in prosecutorial decisions. The Court concluded that the prosecutor's decision to consider the reparation payment as one of the factors in making the Prosecution Decision was lawful and did not amount to an unlawful bargain. The Court further held that the prosecutor's consideration of reparation and other factors in making the Prosecution Decision did not violate the Prosecution Guidelines or the purpose of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992. Finally, the Court found that the District Court Decision to dismiss the charges against Mr Whittall was lawful, as the Judge brought an independent mind to the decision and considered the interests of justice.