Moncrief-Spittle v Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA531/2019
 [2021] NZCA 142

BETWEEN

MALCOLM BRUCE MONCRIEF‑SPITTLE
First Appellant

DAVID CUMIN
Second Appellant

AND

REGIONAL FACILITIES AUCKLAND LIMITED
First Respondent

AUCKLAND COUNCIL
Second Respondent

Hearing:

4 and 5 August 2020

Court:

Kós P, Cooper and Courtney JJ

Counsel:

J E Hodder QC and J K Grimmer for Appellants
K Anderson, KEF Morrison and O J Towle for Respondents
F M Joychild QC, J S Hancock and E C Vermunt for Human Rights Commission as Intervener

Judgment:

30 April 2021 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal against the High Court’s substantive decision is dismissed. 

B        The appeal against the High Court’s costs decision is allowed. 

CCosts and disbursements payable in the High Court are reduced by 70 per cent.

D        Counsel may file memoranda as to costs on the appeal within 10 working days from the date of this decision. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Courtney J)

Table of Contents
Para No
Introduction [1]
Factual background [11]
The case in the High Court
The basis for challenge [19]
The High Court decision [23]
Issue 1:  is the decision to cancel reviewable?
The issues [29]
The statutory context [33]
RFAL’s status [45]
Is the decision to cancel reviewable and on what basis? [51]
Did the decision to cancel have important public consequences? [69]
Common callings [71]
Issue 2:  was the decision unlawful by reason of it being irrational, perverse or arbitrary?
The issues [72]
The events leading up to the decision to cancel [73]
Was the decision made prematurely and without adequate information? [88]
Did RFAL fail to follow its to follow the health and safety policy? [94]
The “heckler’s veto” [97]
Misdirection on the law [110]
Issue 3:  was the cancellation an unreasonable limit on the BORA rights engaged?
The BORA rights engaged [111]
Was the decision to cancel a reasonable limitation on the rights of freedom of expression and peaceful assembly? [116]
Issue 4:  did the appellants have standing to bring the proceedings? [128]
Issue 5:  did the Judge err in making the costs order against the appellants? [133]
Result [142]

Introduction 

  1. In New Zealand the right to freedom of expression, including the freedom to seek, receive and impart information and opinions of any kind in any form, is protected by the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (BORA).  The question in this appeal is whether a council-controlled organisation (CCO) is under an obligation to facilitate the right to freedom of expression when it hires out a venue for a paid event.

  2. Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd (RFAL) is wholly owned by the Auckland Council.  It is the trustee of Regional Facilities Auckland, a charitable trust and CCO established as part of the Auckland “super city” merger in 2010 to hold and manage assets previously held by territorial authorities in the Auckland region.  One of these assets is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moncrief-Spittle v Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZCA 142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the cancellation of a venue hire agreement for an event to be held at the Bruce Mason Centre on Auckland’s North Shore. The Centre is managed by Regional Facilities Auckland (RFAL), a council-controlled organisation wholly owned by Auckland Council. The appellants, Mr Moncrief-Spittle and Dr Cumin, sought judicial review of the decision to cancel the hire agreement, arguing that it was unlawful and an unreasonable limitation on their rights protected by the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (BORA). They also sought to overturn a costs order against them. In the High Court, Jagose J held that RFAL’s decision to cancel was not reviewable because RFAL was not exercising a public power. As a result, nor did the Judge accept that RFAL’s decision was made in the performance of any public function or power for the purposes of s 3(b) of BORA and, therefore, the BORA-protected right to freedom of expression was not engaged. The Judge also held that neither Mr Moncrief-Spittle nor Dr Cumin had standing to bring the proceedings. The appellants appealed against these findings and the costs order. They argued that the decision to cancel was reviewable, unlawful and an unreasonable limitation on their BORA rights. They also argued that they had standing and that the Judge had erred in making the costs order against them. The respondents supported the decision of the Judge and argued that the appeal should be dismissed. The Human Rights Commission intervened on the question whether BORA was engaged. The Court found that the decision to cancel was reviewable because it was made in the exercise of a public function or power for the purposes of BORA and/or because it had important public consequences. It found that the decision was lawful and not an unreasonable limitation on the BORA rights engaged. It found that both appellants had standing to bring the proceedings. It found that the Judge had erred in making the costs order against the appellants and reduced the costs and disbursements payable by 70 per cent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd (RFAL) is a council-controlled organisation wholly owned by the Auckland Council. It manages public venues, including the Bruce Mason Centre. In June 2018, Axiomatic Media Pty Ltd hired the Bruce Mason Centre for a performance on 3 August 2018 featuring speakers Stefan Molyneux and Lauren Southern. The speakers were self-described "alt-right" activists. After the event became public knowledge, Auckland Peace Action signalled its intention to blockade the venue. RFAL decided to cancel the event due to concerns about health and safety risks arising from anticipated protests. The venue hire agreement was cancelled on 6 July 2018. Mr Malcolm Bruce Moncrief-Spittle, who had purchased a ticket for the event, and Dr David Cumin, an Auckland ratepayer and a member of the Auckland Jewish community, sought judicial review of the decision to cancel the venue hire agreement. They argued that RFAL was under public law obligations to facilitate the right to freedom of expression and had cancelled the event without being satisfied that there were clear and sufficient public safety grounds for doing so.

The matter began as a claim for breach of contract by Axiomatic Media Pty Ltd and judicial review by Axiomatic and the appellants. The application for interim relief was withdrawn, and Axiomatic took no further steps. The substantive hearing proceeded on the basis of a third amended statement of claim. The substantive decision was handed down on 3 December 2019, and the costs decision was handed down on 14 October 2019. The appellants appealed both the substantive decision and the costs decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the decision to cancel reviewable?
2. Was the decision to cancel unlawful by reason of it being irrational, perverse or arbitrary?
3. Was the cancellation an unreasonable limit on the BORA rights engaged?
4. Did the appellants have standing to bring the proceedings?
5. Did the Judge err in making the costs order against the appellants?

Held
1. The appeal against the High Court's substantive decision is dismissed.
2. The appeal against the High Court's costs decision is allowed.
3. Costs and disbursements payable in the High Court are reduced by 70 per cent.
4. Counsel may file memoranda as to costs on the appeal within 10 working days from the date of this decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the Court of Appeal considered whether the decision by Regional Facilities Auckland Limited (RFAL) to cancel a venue hire agreement was reviewable, and if so, whether it was lawful and whether it constituted an unreasonable limitation on the Bill of Rights Act (BORA) rights engaged. The Court also considered whether the appellants had standing to bring the proceedings and whether the Judge erred in making the costs order against the appellants.

Firstly, the Court found that the decision to cancel the venue hire agreement was reviewable. It concluded that RFAL's status was such that it stood in the shoes of the Auckland Council and that the decision to cancel was made pursuant to a core statutory function that engaged BORA rights. The decision had important public consequences, and the Court found that it was reviewable both on usual public law principles and under s 3(b) of BORA.

Secondly, the Court found that the decision to cancel was not unlawful as it was not irrational, perverse or arbitrary. The decision was based on the risk of injury or damage to persons or property, and the Court considered that RFAL was entitled to make its own assessment of the risk and of the practical steps that would be required to manage that risk based on the knowledge and resources then available to it.

Thirdly, the Court found that the cancellation was a reasonable limitation on the BORA rights engaged. It held that the decision to cancel was a justified limitation on the appellants' BORA-affirmed rights to freedom of expression and freedom of peaceful assembly, as the decision was a rational and reasonable response to the security risks involved.

Fourthly, the Court found that the appellants had standing to bring the proceedings. Mr Moncrief-Spittle, as a ticket-holder, had a bona fide interest in having a matter of public interest considered, and Dr Cumin, as a ratepayer, had a genuine interest in the way the Council and CCOs managed public assets.

Lastly, the Court found that the Judge erred in making the costs order against the appellants. It held that the proceeding raised novel and important questions of public importance relating to fundamental rights and freedoms under BORA and at common law, and that the appellants had acted reasonably in the conduct of the proceeding. Consequently, the costs and disbursements payable by the appellants should have been reduced by 70 per cent.