Ye v Minister of Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

NOTE:  ANY PUBLICATION OF THE ADDENDUM TO GLAZEBROOK J'S JUDGMENT IS TO BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE RESTRICTIONS SET OUT IN THAT ADDENDUM AT [366] - [369].

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA184/06 [2008] NZCA 291

BETWEEN  WILLIE YE, CANDY YE AND TIM YE Appellants

ANDMINISTER OF IMMIGRATION First Respondent

ANDYUEYING DING Second Respondent

CA192/06

AND BETWEEN            ALAN QIU AND STANLEY QIU Appellants

ANDMINISTER OF IMMIGRATION First Respondent

ANDHE QIN QIU Second Respondent

ANDXIAO YUN QIU Third Respondent

CA205/05

AND BETWEEN            MINISTER OF IMMIGRATION Appellant

ANDYUEYING DING Respondent

Hearing:         5, 6 and 7 June 2007

Court:            Glazebrook, Hammond, Chambers, Robertson and Wilson JJ

PUBLIC VERSION - YE & ORS V MINISTER OF IMMIGRATION AND ANOR CA CA184/06  7 August

2008

Counsel:         R E Harrison QC and M K Macnab for Appellants in CA184/06

A G Mahon for Appellants in CA192/06
I C Carter and M G Coleman for Appellant in CA205/05 and First
Respondent in CA184/06 and CA192/06
I C Bassett for Respondent in CA205/05 and Second Respondent in
CA184/06
No appearance for Second and Third Respondents in CA192/06

Judgment:      7 August 2008         at 4.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

CA184/06 (The Ye children’s appeal)

A        The appeal is allowed.

BThe matter is remitted to the Immigration Service to be reconsidered, if it sees fit, in light of the reasons for judgment given by Hammond and Wilson JJ.

CThe cross-appeal is allowed but only to the extent that the declaration made by the High Court that the appellants cannot be removed from New Zealand without parental consent is set aside.

DCosts of $12,000 plus usual disbursements are to be paid by the Crown to the second respondent.

CA192/06 (The Qiu children’s appeal) E     The appeal is dismissed.

FThe cross-appeal is allowed but only to the extent that the declaration made by the High Court that the appellants cannot be removed from New Zealand without parental consent is set aside.

G       There is no order as to costs.

HThe  second  and  third  respondents  must  not  be  removed  from  New Zealand within 20 working days after the date of this decision.  If, within that time, they or the appellants apply for leave to appeal to the Supreme

Court, the second and third respondents must not be removed from New Zealand before that application is determined, unless the Supreme Court determines otherwise.

CA205/05 (The Minister of Immigration’s appeal) I          The appeal is dismissed.

J         There is no order as to costs.

REASONS

Glazebrook J  [1] Hammond and Wilson JJ  [380] Chambers and Robertson JJ  [425]

GLAZEBROOK J

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1] The Ye/Ding family  [1] The Qiu family  [8] Issues  [11]

Should the welfare and best interests of any child be the first and paramount consideration in any immigration decision

affecting the child or his or her parents?  [14]

CARE OF CHILDREN ACT (CCA)  [18] Policy analysis of CCA  [19] Textual analysis of CCA  [25] APPELLANTS’…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ye v Minister of Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZCA 291
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ye v Minister of Immigration, CA184/06, CA192/06, and CA205/05, was heard by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeals involved the removal orders issued to the parents of children born in New Zealand to Chinese parents who were in the country unlawfully. The children argued that their welfare and best interests should be the first and paramount consideration in any immigration decision affecting their parents. The Court of Appeal considered several issues, including the effect of the Care of Children Act 2004 (CCA) on immigration decisions, the proper application of the Puli’uvea test, and the relevance of the New Zealand citizenship of the children in removal decisions.

The Court of Appeal rejected the argument that the CCA applied directly to immigration decisions, stating that it was limited to closely-related legislation where the interests of children were directly at issue. The Court also rejected the argument that the Puli’uvea test should be aligned with the exceptional circumstances test in s 47(3) of the Immigration Act, holding that neither s 54 nor s 58 was subject to the s 47(3) test. The Court found that the New Zealand citizenship of the children was a relevant factor in any decision relating to the removal of their parents, but it did not create an absolute right to have parents remain. The Court held that the removal orders and the decision not to cancel the removal orders were not reviewable in the circumstances, and the appeals were dismissed. However, the matter was remitted to the Immigration Service to be reconsidered if it saw fit.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established