Singh v Minister of Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA48/2009
[2009] NZCA 50

BETWEENMAHINDER SINGH


First Appellant

ANDADELAIDE ATAPETA TIOPIRA


Second Appellant

ANDCYDNEY MICHELLE KAUR


Third Appellant

ANDKULWINDER SANTOS ILIJAH SINGH


Fourth Appellant

ANDQTANA SHARMA


Fifth Appellant

ANDMINISTER OF IMMIGRATION


First Respondent

ANDTHE ATTORNEY GENERAL


Second Respondent

Hearing:17 February 2009

Court:William Young  P, Hammond and Robertson JJ

Counsel:F C Deliu and R Zhao via video link for Appellants


I C Carter and M R L Silverwood for First Respondent

Judgment:3 March 2009 at 3.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

THE APPEAL IS DISMISSED.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by William Young P)

Introduction

[1]       Before us is what is expressed to be an application for leave to appeal against a judgment of Heath J delivered on 17 December 2008 in which he dismissed an application for interim relief to restrain the removal of the first appellant, Mr Mahinder Singh, from New Zealand, pending determination of judicial review proceedings.  The appellants have also filed an associated application to this Court for interim relief pending the hearing of the appeal.

[2]       There is no leave requirement in relation to the judgment of Heath J and we propose to treat the case as an appeal against his judgment. 

[3]       The case involves the now very familiar situation of an overstayer relying on New Zealand born children in judicial review proceedings which seek to prevent removal under the Immigration Act 1987: see Ye v Minister of Immigration [2008] NZCA 291 and Huang v Minister of Immigration [2008] NZCA 377. We note that the debate generated by that litigation will continue because the Supreme Court has granted leave to appeal against both judgments. In those cases, as in this case, the primary focus was on what is known as the humanitarian interview. In Ye, three conflicting approaches to the scope of judicial review in this context were adopted, none of which commanded majority support.  In Huang, a unanimous position on the role of the interview and the limits of judicial review was established but this of course is subject to change given the grants of leave to appeal in the two cases.

Background

[4]       The nature and timing of Mr Singh’s interactions with the Immigration Service are firmly established but beyond that the factual background is murky to say the least.

[5]       Mr Singh is an Indian national who arrived in New Zealand in November 1995 on a visitor’s permit.  He sought but failed to obtain refugee status.  The Refugee Status Appeals Authority concluded that his narrative of events was not credible.  His visitor’s permit expired on 23 August 1997.  Mr Singh did not, however, comply with his obligation to leave New Zealand.  In 1998 he married the second appellant, Adelaide Tiopira, a New Zealand citizen.  She has three children, Cydney, Kulwinder and Qtana, who are all New Zealand citizens and were born on 17 January 1999, 7 November 2000 and 9 November 2002 respectively.  Her children are also parties to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh v Minister of Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZCA 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the proposed removal of Mr Mahinder Singh from New Zealand, an Indian national who has overstayed his visa. The appellants, including Mr Singh and his three children born to a New Zealand citizen, sought interim relief to prevent his removal pending the determination of judicial review proceedings. The legal issues primarily revolve around whether the statutory discretions associated with Mr Singh's removal have miscarried and whether the procedures followed by the Immigration Service breached his rights under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.

The Court considered the general argument that the statutory discretions have miscarried because the interests of Mr Singh's children were not adequately addressed, as well as the particular argument that the procedures violated his rights due to the absence of an interpreter and legal assistance during the humanitarian interview. However, the Court found that Mr Singh's case had been thoroughly addressed by relevant authorities, and his relationship with his children had significantly weakened, making it unlikely that his removal would involve an unreasonable exercise of statutory discretions. Additionally, the Court noted that the processes followed by the immigration officers might be challenged at trial, but any success would likely be temporary as Mr Singh's prospects of remaining in New Zealand are slim.

The Court applied the legal test under section 8 of the Judicature Amendment Act 1972, which permits interim orders if necessary to preserve the applicant's position. However, the Court balanced the need to preserve Mr Singh's position against the consequences of preventing his removal, including facilitating his ongoing breach of legal obligations and the risk of flight. The Court also considered broader policy implications, such as the enforcement of immigration policies and the potential demoralization of the Immigration Service.

Ultimately, the Court dismissed the appeal, finding that the appellants did not have a substantial prospect of success in the substantive proceedings and that the adverse consequences of granting interim relief outweighed the need to preserve Mr Singh's position. The associated application for interim relief was deemed redundant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established