Fernandes v Immigration and Protection Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA10/2014
[2014] NZCA 52

BETWEEN

ROHAN DUART FERNANDES
Applicant

AND

IMMIGRATION AND PROTECTION TRIBUNAL
First Respondent

AND

MINISTER OF IMMIGRATION
Second Respondent

Hearing:

4 March 2014

Court:

Stevens, Wild and White JJ

Counsel:

N R Woods and C A Sawyer for Applicant
D L Harris for First Respondent, abiding the decision of the Court
C I J Fleming and S K Shaw for Second Respondent

Judgment:

7 March 2013 at 3.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for an extension of time in which to appeal under r 29A of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 is dismissed.

BThe application for interim relief is dismissed.

CThe applicant must pay the second respondent costs for a standard application on a Band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Stevens J)

Introduction

  1. The applicant, Mr Fernandes, is a 36-year old Indian national.  He was granted a residence permit on 6 May 2008, after a period of study in New Zealand.  He returned to India in August 2008, whereupon he married his wife (V) and shortly thereafter returned to New Zealand.  V followed him to New Zealand in January 2009.  Their son, D, was born on 11 June 2009.

  2. Mr Fernandes subjected V to ongoing domestic violence during their marriage.  This culminated in Mr Fernandes being convicted of contravening a protection order, injuring with intent to injure, speaking threateningly, assault with a weapon and a representative charge of common assault.  The offences in question took place between February to September 2009, with one isolated further event on 1 April 2010.  Mr Fernandes was sentenced to two years and two months’ imprisonment on 30 May 2011.

  3. Before his release from prison, Mr Fernandes was served with a deportation liability notice pursuant to the Immigration Act 2009 (the Act).[1]  After his release on parole in August 2012, Mr Fernandes appealed to the Immigration and Protection Tribunal (IPT) against his deportation.  In February 2013, the IPT dismissed his appeal.[2]  Mr Fernandes then applied to judicially review that decision in the High Court.  All grounds of the review were rejected by Ronald Young J.[3]

    [1]Immigration Act 2009, s 161.

    [2]Fernandes v The Minister of Immigration [2013] NZIPT 600013 [Tribunal decision].

    [3]RDF v Immigration and Protection Tribunal [2013] NZHC 2583, [2014] NZFLR 45 [High Court judgment].

  4. Mr Fernandes now applies for an extension of time under r 29A of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 (the Rules) to appeal against that decision of the High Court.  He also applies for a stay of execution of his deportation under r 12(3)(a) of the Rules, which is scheduled for 13 March 2014.  Counsel accepted in oral submissions that this should be treated as an application for interim relief.[4]

    [4]Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, r 12(3)(b) [the Rules] and Judicature Amendment Act 1972, s 8(1)(b).  This approach was considered by this Court in Parmanadan v Minister of Immigration [2010] NZCA 136

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fernandes v Immigration and Protection Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fernandes v Immigration and Protection Tribunal involved an appeal by the applicant, who was seeking to overturn a decision that his application for a visa be refused. The primary focus of the appeal was on the assessment of exceptional humanitarian circumstances and whether the public interest in deporting the applicant outweighed the private interest in him remaining in New Zealand. The applicant had a history of domestic violence, and his son, born while the applicant was in prison, was living with his mother in New Zealand.

The legal issues central to the court's decision were whether the relationship between the applicant and his son constituted an exceptional circumstance of a humanitarian nature, and whether the applicant had shown a sufficient change in character to warrant a favourable outcome on the public interest limb of section 207 of the relevant Act. The court needed to assess the quality and depth of the applicant's relationship with his son, as well as the applicant's propensity for violence and his efforts to address it.

The court determined that the relationship between the applicant and his son did not constitute an exceptional humanitarian circumstance because the applicant had not attempted to communicate with or provide for his son in the two years since his release from prison. The court found no evidence to suggest that the applicant's relationship with his son would become meaningful in the future. Regarding the public interest limb, the court concluded that the applicant had not sufficiently demonstrated a change in character or insight into his violent tendencies. The evidence showed that he had not completed the required anti-violence courses, and the court had no confidence that he would be safe for any future partners or the broader community.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Immigration and Protection Tribunal to refuse the applicant's visa application was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

So far as the interests of the son were concerned, the Tribunal said this:[15][75] Normally, we would place considerable weight on the importance to a child of growing up knowing his father (and on the importance to the father of contact with his son). We do not need to labour the point about the best interests of children. Such consideration, however, presumes a relationship of quality – one that is nurturing and beneficial to the child’s development and which has context and depth. That is not the case here. The failure of the appellant to attempt any communication with his son or provide for him, even very modestly once he has been released from prison does not point to his relationship with [D] being a substantial factor in finding exceptional circumstances of a humanitarian nature: see Singh v Minister of Immigration [2009] NZCA 50, at [20(e)]. We have no confidence that the appellant will have any meaningful relationship with [D] in the future, even if he stays in New Zealand.Conclusion on Exceptional Circumstances[76] Weighing all the above matters cumulatively, the appellant’s relevant circumstances are that he is reasonably well-settled here and has a son in New Zealand. The significance of the relationship with the son, however, is qualified by the fact that the appellant has had no contact with him for more than two years and the evidence does not satisfy us that this will change meaningfully, even if the appellant remains in New Zealand. At most, the son may seek him out when he is a teenager but that is remote in time and is no more than speculative.[15]At [75]–[76]. Having carefully reviewed all the evidence, the Tribunal concluded that there were no circumstances of a humanitarian nature which justified allowing the appeal.[16][16]Tribunal decision, above n 2, at [77]. On the public interest limb of s 207 of the Act, the IPT considered whether the applicant had turned his back on his propensity for violence. The IPT said the evidence confirmed Judge Perkins’ reservations at sentencing about Mr Fernandes’ lack of remorse and insight.[17] Then the IPT said this:[18]The appellant failed to fulfil the requirements of both the interim and the final protection orders that he attend an anti-violence course. Since his release on parole he had started one such course, but gave it up and then started another. Accordingly, we have an appellant before us who is untreated. We do not find that he has accepted that he has the violence problem that has been identified by the courts and by Father Roberts. We do not have confidence that any future relationship partner he might have would be safe if she differed from his wishes.[17]At [95].[18]At [96]. These findings are entirely consistent with those of the Parole Board in September 2011. The Parole Board was concerned that Mr Fernandes was contemplating playing a part in his son’s life. This was identified as one of the major concerns of his victim, as she feared not only for her own safety, but also for the child’s. Following the hearing, the Parole Board panel was satisfied that if Mr Fernandes had been released at the time he would be an undue risk to the safety of the community or anyone in that community between then and his sentence end date.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.