Moncrief-Spittle v Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI O AOTEAROA

 SC 57/2021
 [2022] NZSC 138
BETWEEN

MALCOLM BRUCE MONCRIEF‑SPITTLE
First Appellant

DAVID CUMIN
Second Appellant

AND

REGIONAL FACILITIES AUCKLAND LIMITED
First Respondent

AUCKLAND COUNCIL
Second Respondent

Hearing:

22 February 2022

Court:

Winkelmann CJ, William Young, Glazebrook, O’Regan and
Ellen France JJ

Counsel:

J E Hodder KC, P A Joseph and J A Tocher for Appellants
K Anderson, A S Butler KC and K E F Morrison for Respondents
J S Hancock for Human Rights Commission as Intervener

Judgment:

5 December 2022

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BLeave to adduce the affidavit of 18 February 2022 of David Cumin is declined.

CCosts are reserved.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS
(Given by Ellen France J)

Table of Contents

Para No.
The appeal [1]
Narrative of events [7]
The statutory framework [15]
The judgments below [28]
  High Court [28]
  Court of Appeal [31]
Does the Bill of Rights apply to RFAL’s decision? [36]
  The Bill of Rights [36]
  The s 3(b) test [38]
  Application to the present facts [50]
The rights engaged [61]
  The nature of the obligation to protect freedom of expression [67]
  Implications for RFAL [73]
Was the Court of Appeal correct to conclude RFAL’s decision was consistent with the Bill of Rights?
[75]
  The approach in the Court of Appeal [75]
  Submissions [78]
  Our view on the role of the Court [81]
  The s 5 test [87]
  A role for the heckler’s veto? [93]
  Conclusion on s 5 [101]
Is the decision amenable to judicial review? [105]
  Our approach [108]
Was the decision to cancel unreasonable? [114]
  The weight to be given to freedom of expression in the
  decision‑making process

[115]
  The process followed by RFAL [122]
New evidence [132]
Result [136]
Costs [138]

The appeal

  1. This appeal concerns the way in which freedom of expression affects the decision of the first respondent, Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd (RFAL), to cancel a contract for hire of the Bruce Mason Centre in Takapuna.  The Centre is one of Auckland Council’s venues which is managed by RFAL.  An Australian promoter, Axiomatic Media Pty Ltd (Axiomatic), had hired the Bruce Mason Centre for presentations by two speakers, Stefan Molyneux and Lauren Southern.  The speakers have been described as “alt-right” commentators.  Complaints were made about the event and the contract for hire was cancelled by RFAL because of concerns about health and safety risks arising from anticipated protests against the event.

  2. The decision to cancel the contract was challenged by the appellants, Malcolm Moncrief‑Spittle and David Cumin.  Mr Moncrief‑Spittle had bought a ticket for the event and was disappointed when it was cancelled.  Dr Cumin is an Auckland ratepayer and a member of the Auckland Jewish community.  His concern is that his community’s use of Council facilities could be adversely affected in the future by threats from those wanting to disrupt such events. 

  3. The appellants sought judicial review of the decision to cancel.  They argued, first, that RFAL had acted irrationally,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moncrief-Spittle v Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZSC 138
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Moncrief-Spittle v Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd concerned the way in which freedom of expression affected the decision of the first respondent, Regional Facilities Auckland Ltd (RFAL), to cancel a contract for hire of the Bruce Mason Centre in Takapuna. The Centre is one of Auckland Council’s venues which is managed by RFAL. An Australian promoter, Axiomatic Media Pty Ltd (Axiomatic), had hired the Bruce Mason Centre for presentations by two speakers, Stefan Molyneux and Lauren Southern. Complaints were made about the event and the contract for hire was cancelled by RFAL because of concerns about health and safety risks arising from anticipated protests against the event. The decision to cancel the contract was challenged by the appellants, Malcolm Moncrief-Spittle and David Cumin. Mr Moncrief-Spittle had bought a ticket for the event and was disappointed when it was cancelled. Dr Cumin is an Auckland ratepayer and a member of the Auckland Jewish community. His concern is that his community’s use of Council facilities could be adversely affected in the future by threats from those wanting to disrupt such events. The appellants sought judicial review of the decision to cancel. They argued, first, that RFAL had acted irrationally, perversely and arbitrarily. In concluding that there was an unacceptable security risk, they said that RFAL did not obtain and have regard to relevant information including the views of the police, Axiomatic’s security resources, and the ways that Australian venues (at which Mr Molyneux and Ms Southern had spoken) managed risks to security and safety. It was also alleged that if RFAL had obtained and had regard to all relevant information, it could not rationally have concluded that the event posed an unacceptable security risk justifying cancellation. Second, the appellants pleaded a failure to act consistently with rights guaranteed under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (the Bill of Rights), including the right to freedom of expression. The High Court dismissed the appellants’ claim. The appellants’ appeal to the Court of Appeal was unsuccessful. Although the outcome was the same in both Courts, the Courts adopted different reasoning. The High Court found that RFAL’s decision to cancel the contract was not amenable to judicial review and that the Bill of Rights did not apply. The Court of Appeal said that the decision was amenable to judicial review and that the Bill of Rights applied. But the claim failed because the decision to cancel was reasonable both in administrative law terms and under the Bill of Rights. The issues arising on the appeal were: (a) Does the Bill of Rights apply? (b) If the Bill of Rights is applicable, was the decision to cancel a breach of protected rights? (c) Is the decision by RFAL to cancel the contract amenable to judicial review and, if so, what are the available grounds of review? (d) If the decision is reviewable, was the decision to cancel unreasonable and how is freedom of expression taken into account in that assessment? The Court held that the appeal should be dismissed. The Court found that RFAL’s decision to cancel the contract was a reasonable limit on the right to freedom of expression. The Court held that the cancellation was a reasonable limit on the right to freedom of expression. RFAL’s functions, although expressed in different language, were derived from those formerly vested in territorial local government in relation to the holding and maintenance of land and buildings for purposes that included holding public meetings. The Court found that the decision to cancel was a reasonable limit on the right to freedom of expression and the Court declined to grant leave to adduce new evidence. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.