Max Fortuna 3 Ltd v Kitchener Trust Investments Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2024-404-000837

[2024] NZHC 3458

UNDER the Arbitration Act 1996

IN THE MATTER

of an appeal against Arbitration Tribunal’s award

BETWEEN

MAX FORTUNA 3 LTD

First Appellant

JI HO RYU
Second Appellant

AND

KITCHENER TRUST INVESTMENTS LTD

Respondent

Hearing:

22 August 2024

(Further submissions filed: 6 September 2024)

Counsel:

S Kang for Appellants

J Carlyon and R C B Kendall for Respondent

Judgment:

20 November 2024


JUDGMENT OF BREWER J


This judgment was delivered by me on 20 November 2024 at 10 am pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Fairbrother Family Law (Napier) for Appellants Meredith Connell (Auckland) for Respondent

MAX FORTUNA 3 LTD v KITCHENER TRUST INVESTMENTS LTD [2024] NZHC 3458 [20 November 2024]

Introduction

[1]                  On 17 January 2024, Mr Royden Hindle (the Arbitral Tribunal) gave a partial award in favour of Kitchener Trust Investments Ltd (the landlord). The issue was whether Infrastructure Growth Charges (IGCs), imposed by Watercare Services Ltd (Watercare) on the landlord in response to the use of water by Max Fortuna 3 Ltd (the tenant), as tenant of the landlord’s property, should be paid by the tenant. The Arbitral Tribunal ruled that they should be paid by the tenant.

[2]                  The tenant obtained leave to appeal (with the consent of the landlord) on a question of law:

Whether the Arbitration Tribunal made an error of law holding that Watercare’s Infrastructure Growth Charge (IGC) was a levy/outgoing under the parties’ Agreement to Lease and Deed of Lease that the first plaintiff Max Fortuna 3 Ltd as lessee is liable to contribute $60,100 plus GST towards it (performance of which has been guaranteed by the second plaintiff, Mr Ryu).

[3]                  During the hearing on 22 August 2024, Mr Kang, for the tenant, made an oral application to extend the question of law. This was a surprise for counsel for the landlord, who opposed the application. In my Minute of 22 August 2024, I granted Mr Kang’s application and gave my reasons. I amended the question of law to read:1

Whether the Arbitration Tribunal made an error or errors of law in holding that Watercare is a local or territorial authority and that its Infrastructure Growth Charge (IGC) was a levy/outgoing under the parties’ Agreement to Lease and Deed of Lease that the first plaintiff Max Fortuna 3 Ltd as lessee is liable to contribute $60,100 plus GST towards it (performance of which has been guaranteed by the second plaintiff, Mr Ryu).

[4]                  I gave counsel for the landlord the opportunity to have a further oral hearing or to file written submissions. Counsel chose the latter course.

[5]                  In addition to the tenant’s appeal, leave was granted to the landlord to bring a cross-appeal. The question of law is:


1      I commented further in [14] of my Minute: “It should go without saying that changing the scope of the appeal on the morning of the appeal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Max Fortuna 3 Ltd v Kitchener Trust Investments Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 3458
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Max Fortuna 3 Ltd and Ji Ho Ryu, as the first and second appellants, appealed against a partial award by the Arbitral Tribunal that found that Infrastructure Growth Charges (IGCs) imposed by Watercare Services Ltd on the landlord, Kitchener Trust Investments Ltd, should be paid by the tenant. The Arbitral Tribunal ruled that IGCs were a levy, and therefore, an outgoing under the Agreement to Lease and Deed of Lease. The tenant contended that the Arbitral Tribunal erred in holding that IGCs were a levy and that Watercare is a local or territorial authority. The landlord, as the respondent, cross-appealed on the issue of whether IGCs were a charge for water.

The High Court found that the tenant's appeal failed. The court agreed with the Arbitral Tribunal that Watercare is a local or territorial authority and that IGCs are in the nature of levies. The court held that the reference in the lease to "local or territorial authority" did not exclude wholly-owned corporate bodies used by local or territorial authorities to perform mandated functions. The court also found that IGCs are a non-negotiable fee imposed by a territorial authority, making them a levy. Consequently, the tenant is liable to contribute towards IGCs as an outgoing under the lease.

Regarding the landlord's cross-appeal, the High Court allowed it. The court held that if IGCs are not payments in the nature of levies, they are water charges. The court agreed with the landlord that IGCs are charges for the tenant's water use and fall within the category of water charges under the lease. The court concluded that the lease's structure, being a net lease, requires the tenant to pay outgoings attributable to their use of the premises. IGCs are charges for the tenant's water use, and there is no reason to exclude them from water charges.

In conclusion, the High Court dismissed the tenant's appeal and allowed the landlord's cross-appeal. The tenant remains liable to contribute towards IGCs as an outgoing under the lease. Costs are to be addressed by memoranda to be filed by specified dates.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established