Karam v Fairfax New Zealand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2010-404-005021 [2012] NZHC 887

BETWEEN  JOSEPH FRANCIS KARAM Plaintiff

ANDFAIRFAX NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         19 and 20 March

(with additional written submissions 5 April 2012 and 18 April 2012) (Heard at Auckland)

Counsel:         P A Morten and M A Karam for Plaintiff

R K P Stewart and S B Kellett for Defendant

Judgment:      10 May 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE [as to plaintiff ’s strike out application and both parties’ applications for further discovery]

KARAM V FAIRFAX NEW ZEALAND LIMITED HC AK CIV-2010-404-005021 [10 May 2012]

Index

The background ................................................................................................................................... [5] The articles............................................................................................................................................ [9] Facebook article (second cause of action) .................................................................................................. [10] Dominion Post article (third cause of action) ........................................................................................... [11] Compensation article (first cause of action) .............................................................................................. [13] Sunday Star-Times article (fourth cause of action) ................................................................................... [16] Fairfax’s defence ................................................................................................................................ [17] Plaintiff’s application for discovery ....................................................................................................... The object of the application .................................................................................................................... [21] The object of the application largely falls away ......................................................................................... [22] Should some discovery orders yet be made? ............................................................................................... [25] Order ................................................................................................................................................... [29] Plaintiff’s application for order striking out defence of honest opinion ......................................... The defence of honest opinion as pleaded .................................................................................................. [31] Plaintiff’s application for order striking out defence .................................................................................. [34] Defendant’s grounds of opposition ........................................................................................................... [35] Strike out application – the principles ..................................................................................................... [36] The defence of honest opinion .............................................................................................................. The defence under s 10 Defamation Act 1982........................................................................................ [38] The basis and ingredients of the defence of honest opinion ......................................................................... [44] Television New Zealand v Haines .......................................................................................................... [50] Fairfax’s responses to the criticisms of its honest opinion pleading ................................................ Ground 1: Absence of pleading to the defamatory meanings ..................................................................... [55] Ground 2: Failure to identify which defamatory meanings are opinions .................................................... [58] Ground 3: Particularisation of opinion aspects (and factual aspects) of the publications ............................ [61] Ground 4: Defendant does not plead any publication facts ....................................................................... [66] Ground 5: Failure to particularise whose opinion is being expressed ........................................................ [68] Ground 6: Inadmissibility of three items in Schedule A........................................................................... [71] Ground 7:  Defence of honest opinion not sustainable .............................................................................. [75] The “genuineness” of the opinion – discussion .................................................................................. The test under s 10(2)(b)........................................................................................................................ [79] Can the Schedule A items respond to the pleaded imputations?................................................................ [81] Mr Morten’s first developed example: Schedule A item 29 ...................................................................... [93] Mr Morten’s second developed example: Schedule A item 41................................................................... [99] Mr Morten’s third developed example: Schedule A items 42 - 43 ......................................................... [104] The post-2009 Schedule A facts ........................................................................................................... [110] Remaining Schedule A “facts” – items 1 - 55 ...................................................................................... [114] Conclusion as to the honest opinion defence ............................................................................. [118] Orders................................................................................................................................................ [120] Defendant’s application for discovery................................................................................................... The object of the application .................................................................................................................. [121] Background to the discovery application................................................................................................. [122] Cases for Fairfax ................................................................................................................................. [125] Case for Mr Karam.............................................................................................................................. [126] Discussion – discovery under the new High Court Rules ........................................................ [128] Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................ [150] Order ................................................................................................................................................. [151]

[1]      Mr Karam sues Fairfax in defamation.

[2]      Fairfax pleads a number of affirmative defences, including…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Karam v Fairfax New Zealand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 887
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Joseph Karam sues Fairfax New Zealand Ltd in defamation. Fairfax pleads a number of defences, including honest opinion. Karam applies to strike out that defence. Each party also seeks orders for further and better discovery. Associate Judge Osborne dismisses Karam’s application for further and better discovery by Fairfax. Costs are reserved. The Court dismissed Karam’s application to strike out the defence of honest opinion. Karam’s application for an order striking out the defence of honest opinion specified four grounds. The first was that the amended statement of defence did not specify how the “facts” relied upon by the second defendant supported a defence of honest opinion to the defamatory meanings pleaded by the plaintiff. The second ground was that the facts set out in Schedule A of the amended statement of defence were irrelevant to the issues in question in this proceeding. The third ground was that the second defendant did not separately identify publication facts from other facts and circumstances capable of proving the publication facts. The fourth ground was that the “facts” relied upon by the second defendant in Schedule A were not set out on Counterspin or generally known, and so were not “publication facts”, and were not “other facts and circumstances that are capable of proving the publication facts”. Fairfax posed the application on six stated grounds. The first was that the affirmative defence of honest opinion pleaded by the second defendant in its amended statement of defence disclosed a reasonably arguable defence. The second was that the second defendant was not required to specify how the facts set out in Schedule A were relied on to support a defence of honest opinion to the meanings pleaded by the plaintiff. The third ground was that all of the facts set out in Schedule A of the amended statement of defence were relevant to the issues in question in this proceeding. The fourth ground was that the second defendant was not required to separately identify publication facts from other facts and circumstances capable of proving the publication facts. The fifth ground was that all of the facts set out in Schedule A of the amended statement of defence were either set out on Counterspin, generally known, or other facts and circumstances capable of proving publication facts. The sixth ground was that in the event the second defendant’s pleading of honest opinion was found to be defective, it was capable of repair by amendment. The Court found that the defence of honest opinion was sustainable. The Court ordered that items 56, 57, 58 and 59 of Schedule A of the second amended statement of defence were struck out. The plaintiff’s application to strike out the defence of honest opinion was otherwise dismissed. Costs are reserved for determination in the light of the outcome of the four applications which were heard together. Fairfax seeks discovery of all documents relating to the matters set out in items 1 – 59 of Fairfax’s Schedule A. The application is opposed. Fairfax has the protection of r 8.31 (the equivalent of the former r 8.37) which effectively precludes Karam from producing in evidence a document which he says is relevant to the Schedule A issues but which he did not produce through discovery. The Court found that the circumstances of this case, given Fairfax’s position as a media organisation, pointed to Fairfax itself having records of and access to much material pertaining to these very issues. Fairfax chose not to seek to define more narrowly the categories of documents which it sought. The Court found that the application by the defendant for particular discovery must fail. Costs are reserved for determination in the light of the outcome of the four applications which were heard together.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established