Cares Appliances Ltd v Smith City (Southern) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2012-409-002451 [2014] NZHC 1979

BETWEEN

CARES APPLIANCES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

SMITHS CITY (SOUTHERN) LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 12 August 2014

Appearances:

G J Ryan for Plaintiff
M Fogarty for Defendant

Judgment:

20 August 2014

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

[1]      Cares Appliances Limited (Cares) sells used household appliances.   Smiths City (Southern) Limited (Smiths) sells new appliances.  In the course of doing so it receives trade-ins.   On 14 April 2008 the companies entered a contract whereby Smiths would sell to Cares trade-ins and items repossessed from defaulting purchasers, on certain terms.  On 8 May 2012 Smiths wrote to Cares cancelling the agreement with immediate effect.  Cares issued this proceeding challenging Smiths’ purported  cancellation  of  the  contract.    It  sought  specific  performance  of  the contract, and damages.

[2]      In its amended statement of claim it has broadened its allegations of breach of contract.   It now says that Smiths also breached the contract by failing to supply certain categories of goods which it was obliged to supply, and goods sourced from stores located in areas other than Christchurch, as it was obliged to do.  It no longer seeks specific performance of the contract.   Although the damages  it seeks  are presently quantified at $529,185.50, it is in the process of reassessing the damages it

says it has incurred.

CARES APPLIANCES LTD v SMITHS CITY (SOUTHERN) LTD [2014] NZHC 1979 [20 August 2014]

[3]      This  judgment  determines  an  application  for  further  discovery.     The discovery sought falls into two distinct categories.   The first category comprises documents and electronic records which Cares maintains Smiths holds, and which it says are required to enable it to assess the ambit of Smiths’ breaches of the contract prior to its termination and the damages it has suffered as a result.   The second category of documents comprises those containing legal advice given to Smiths, which is referred to in a letter from Smiths to Cares; Cares says that Smiths has waived the privilege which would otherwise have attached to that advice.

[4]      In respect of both categories of discovery Cares relies on r 8.7:

Standard discovery

Standard discovery requires each party to disclose the documents that are or

have been in that party’s control and that are –

(a)     documents on which the party relies; or

(b)     documents that adversely affect that party’s own case; or

(c)     documents that adversely affect another party’s case; or

(d)     documents that support another party’s case.

[5]      Cares says that the documents sought are within paragraphs (b) and (d) of this rule.  As the documents it seeks have not been discovered it seeks an order pursuant to r 8.19:

Order   for   particular   discovery   against   party   after   proceeding commenced

If at any stage of the proceeding it appears to a Judge, from evidence or from the nature or circumstances of the case or from any document filed in the proceeding, that there are grounds for believing that a party has not discovered 1 or more documents or a group…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cares Appliances Ltd v Smith City (Southern) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1979
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cares Appliances Limited (Cares) commenced proceedings against Smiths City (Southern) Limited (Smiths) seeking damages for breach of contract and specific performance of a contract whereby Smiths agreed to supply trade-ins and repossessed items to Cares. Smiths cancelled the agreement with immediate effect on 8 May 2012. Cares sought further discovery from Smiths, including documents relating to its breaches of the contract and the legal advice on which it based its cancellation of the agreement. Smiths opposed the application. The court first considered whether Cares' application for further discovery was filed out of time. Cares had filed the application four days late due to the late provision of further discovery by Smiths. The court granted leave for the late filing of the application as there was a sound reason for the delay and Smiths could not point to any prejudice as a result. The court then turned to the first issue of whether Smiths was required to give further discovery of documents relating to the agreement. Cares sought documents relating to appliances and transfers of appliances from 14 April 2008, the commencement of the agreement, to date. The court found that Smiths was required to give discovery of the documents without limitation based on its view of the meaning of the agreement. The documents sought related to issues which would be in issue before the court at trial. The court ordered Smiths to provide the documents sought by Cares. The court then considered whether Smiths had waived the privilege attaching to its legal advice. Cares argued that Smiths had waived the privilege by referring to the legal advice in its letter cancelling the agreement. The court found that Smiths had not waived the privilege as the disclosure of the legal advice was not inconsistent with maintaining the confidentiality of the advice and there was no unfairness to Cares in not seeing the whole opinion. The application for discovery of the legal advice was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.