West Harbour Holdings Ltd (in liq) v Tamihere

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

ORDER AS TO CONFIDENTIALITY AND RESTRICTING ACCESS TO THE COURT FILE WITHOUT LEAVE OF A JUDGE

(IN TERMS OF PARAGRAPH [51] OF THIS JUDGMENT)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-4474 [2014] NZHC 716

BETWEEN  WEST HARBOUR HOLDINGS LIMITED (In Liquidation) Plaintiff

ANDJOHN HENRY TAMIHERE Defendant

OFFICIAL ASSIGNEE
First Counterclaim Defendant

CALEDONIAN NOMINEES (No.2) LIMITED

Second Counterclaim Defendant

THE COVE LIMITED
Third Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing:                   2 April 2014

Appearances:           D E Smyth for Plaintiff

T J G Allan for Defendant
C Jones for Official Assignee as First Counterclaim Defendant
G Bogiatto for Second and Third Counterclaim Defendants

Judgment:                2 April 2014

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

Solicitors:

Waterstone Insolvency (B J Norling), North Shore City, for Plaintiff

Grove Darlow & Partners (TJG Allan), Auckland, for Defendant

Official Assignee’s Office (C Jones), Auckland, for First Counterclaim Defendant

George Bogiatto, Auckland, for Second and Third Counterclaim Defendants

Copy for:

David E Smyth, Barrister, Auckland

WEST HARBOUR HOLDINGS LIMITED (In Liquidation) v TAMIHERE [2014] NZHC 716 [2 April 2014]

[1]      The plaintiff and the defendant apply for further and better discovery.  The documents they seek are set out in the schedules to this decision.

Background

[2]      I spelt out the background to this proceeding in my security for costs decision of 2 September 2013.1     Since that decision, the trustees of The Cove Trust have changed.  Mr van Dijk and Mr Palmer are no longer trustees.  Caledonian Nominees (No.2) Ltd has taken their place and is now the second counterclaim defendant. West Harbour Holdings Ltd was formerly represented by an independent solicitor but now the solicitor instructing Mr Smyth - who has remained counsel for the plaintiff throughout – is with the insolvency practice which is responsible for the liquidation of the plaintiff.

[3]      Mr Ivil, the first counterclaim defendant, was recently adjudicated bankrupt. One consequence of this is that any of his assets are now vested in the Official Assignee.  It was agreed that this proceeding should nevertheless continue. to ensure that there is a proper determination of the issues affecting the plaintiff, the defendant and the other counterclaim defendants, and also Mr Ivil and the Official Assignee.  If Mr Tamihere is successful in his defence, the outcome will be that the money he owes will be paid to the Official Assignee.   It is therefore relevant to the administration   of   Mr   Ivil’s   bankruptcy   whether   the   debt   claimed   against Mr Tamihere is an asset of Mr Ivil’s estate.  I have therefore substituted the Official Assignee as first counterclaim defendant for Mr Ivil.  It seems to me that it is not necessary to grant the Official Assignee leave to continue the proceeding, but if leave is required under clause (c) of the Sch 1 of the Insolvency Act 2006, I grant it. Leave under s 76 of the Insolvency Act is not required, as the Official Assignee’s role in this proceeding is as a potential creditor of Mr Tamihere.

[4]      The general factual background to this proceeding is set…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read West Harbour Holdings Ltd (in liq) v Tamihere and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 716
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case West Harbour Holdings Ltd (in liq) v Tamihere [2014] NZHC 716 concerns a dispute over the disclosure of certain documents, the nature of a loan, and the calculation of interest. The plaintiff, West Harbour Holdings Ltd (in liquidation), is suing the defendant, John Henry Tamihere, for the repayment of a $500,000 loan, plus interest. The defendant argues that the loan was not made by West Harbour Holdings Ltd but by Mr Ivil personally, and that the loan was interest-free. The case involves multiple parties, including the Official Assignee as a first counterclaim defendant, Caledonian Nominees (No.2) Ltd as a second counterclaim defendant, and The Cove Ltd as a third counterclaim defendant. The central legal issues in this case are whether Mr Ivil became a debtor of Mr Tamihere or Mr Tamihere's company Consultus when the funds were advanced, who is the creditor of Mr Tamihere for the sum of $500,000, and whether the interest charged on the loan was applicable.

The court considered the applications for further and better discovery made by both the plaintiff and the defendant. The court found that there were reasonable grounds to believe that documents had been misused in the course of the discovery process. Therefore, the court imposed safeguards to ensure that additional documents disclosed by the defendant would not be misused. These safeguards included treating all disclosed documents as confidential and requiring anyone who wishes to inspect those documents to provide an express confidentiality undertaking. The court also restricted the disclosure of these documents to counsel acting for the plaintiff and the counterclaim defendants.

The court denied the defendant's application for further discovery, finding that the requested documents were not relevant to the issues in the case. The court emphasised that discovery is to be used for the purpose of the proceeding and not for any other purpose, and that parties must comply with the requirements of discovery honestly, faithfully, and to the best of their efforts. The court also clarified the principles governing relevance in discovery, stating that documents are to be disclosed if they are relevant to a question in the proceedings and capable of advancing a party's case or damaging the case of its adversary. However, discovery will not be ordered when its sole purpose is to impeach the credit of someone who may give evidence in a proceeding.

In summary, the court granted the plaintiff's application for further and better discovery with certain safeguards, denied the defendant's application for further discovery, and clarified the principles governing relevance in discovery. The case highlights the importance of maintaining strict policies on the use of disclosed documents and the need for parties to comply with the requirements of discovery honestly and faithfully.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established