West Harbour Holdings Limited v Tamihere

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-4474 [2013] NZHC 2279

BETWEEN WEST HARBOUR HOLDINGS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) Plaintiff

AND

JOHN HENRY TAMIHERE Defendant

AND

BRENT ALEXANDER IVIL First Counterclaim Defendant

AND

NICHOLAS ANTONIUS HENDRIKUS Van DIJK

Second Counterclaim Defendant

AND

THE COVE LIMITED
Third Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing: 2 September 2013

Appearances:

D E Smyth for Plaintiff
T J G Allan for Defendant
J Perry for First, Second and Third Counterclaim Defendants

Judgment:

2 September 2013

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

Solicitors:

McDonald Law (Stephen McDonald), Remuera, Auckland, for Plaintiff

Grove Darlow (TJG Allan) Auckland, for Defendant

Keegan Alexander, Auckland for 1st-3rd Counterclaim Defendants

WEST HARBOUR HOLDINGS LIMITED (IN LIQ) v TAMIHERE [2013] NZHC 2279 [2 September 2013]

[1]      Mr Tamihere, the defendant, has applied for security for costs to be provided by the plaintiff.  The case has some added features which take it out of the run-of- the-mill for an application for security for costs.

[2]      Mr Tamihere is  sued for $500,000 plus interest.   The interest is said  to amount to $122,875 as at September 2011.  Daily interest from then plus costs are also claimed.   Mr Tamihere’s case is that he did receive a loan for $500,000. However, he says that the person who lent him the money was not West Harbour Holdings Ltd, the plaintiff.  His case is:

(a)      the person who lent him the money was Brent Alexander Ivil, the first counterclaim defendant;

(b)      the arrangement was interest-free; and

(c)       he is entitled to set-off against his liability to Mr Ivil the sum of

$210,000 that he had earlier lent to Mr Ivil.

[3]      West Harbour Holdings Ltd applied for summary judgment.  Andrews J dismissed the application.  She found that Mr Tamihere had arguable defences.  In particular she found there were issues of credibility which could only be determined at trial.

[4]      It  is  relevant  to  note  the  different  roles  of  the  different  parties  in  this proceeding.

(a)      West Harbour Holdings Ltd is in liquidation.  It went into liquidation by shareholder resolution.   It is acknowledged to be insolvent.  The liquidators are Damien Grant and Kirsten Smith at Waterstone Insolvency.  West Harbour Holdings Ltd says that it is suing as a bare trustee for The Cove Ltd, the third counterclaim defendant.

including The Cove Ltd and West Harbour Holdings Ltd.    Mr Ivil

presently faces significant proceedings against him personally.  One is

based on a guarantee he gave to support West Harbour Holdings Ltd’s

borrowing from Waipareira Investments Ltd.   Mr Ivil says that he has

no assets to his name.  If the proceedings against him are successful

he is likely to face bankruptcy.  I have taken into account the potential

for him to be adjudicated bankrupt in this decision.

(c)

The  Cove  Ltd  is  the  entity  which  carried  out  the  bulk  of  the

development at Clearwater Cove.   The Cove Ltd transferred seven

units which it was developing to West Harbour Holdings Ltd without

consideration.   That was done to allow it to refinance borrowings.

The seven…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read West Harbour Holdings Limited v Tamihere and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

West Harbour Holdings Limited, a company in liquidation, sued John Henry Tamihere for the sum of $500,000 plus interest, claiming that Tamihere had borrowed the money from them. Tamihere, on the other hand, argued that the loan was given by Brent Alexander Ivil, not West Harbour Holdings Limited, and that the loan was interest-free. The case came before the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, where Tamihere applied for security for costs on the basis that West Harbour Holdings Limited was insolvent. The court had to decide whether Tamihere was entitled to security for costs, and if so, what form that security should take.

The court noted that the proceeding was complex, involving multiple parties with varying interests in the case. The court considered the potential for Tamihere to receive a barren order for costs if he succeeded in his defence, but also noted that the plaintiff and other defendants had given undertakings that the fund held by Tamihere's solicitors could be used to meet any order for costs in his favour. The court held that this arrangement adequately protected Tamihere's interests, and that it would not be proper to hold the Official Assignee bound by the undertaking if Ivil were later adjudicated bankrupt. The court decided not to make any order giving Tamihere security for costs, but stood the application over to allow it to be brought on for hearing again if necessary.

The court also made some case management directions, including a requirement for the parties to decide whether it was necessary to leave the trustees of the Cove Trust in as parties to the proceeding, and a requirement for standard discovery in electronic form. The court awarded costs in Tamihere's favour on a 2B basis, but allowed only a quarter of a day for the hearing of the matter, discounting for the consent that was produced.

In conclusion, the court held that Tamihere's interests were adequately protected by the undertakings given by the plaintiff and other defendants, and that it was not necessary to make any order giving Tamihere security for costs. The court stood the application over to allow it to be brought on for hearing again if necessary, and made some case management directions to ensure that the proceeding progressed efficiently.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established