Westpac New Zealand Ltd v Adams

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2011-409-000412 [2013] NZHC 3113

BETWEEN  WESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LTD Plaintiff

ANDLINDSAY HUMPHREY WILLIAM ADAMS and JUDITH CAROL ADAMS First Defendants

ANDROGER ARCHIBALD ADAMS Second Defendant

AND  HAMISH GUY ENSOR

First Third Party and Second Counterclaim

Defendant

ANDBROOK LAW Second Third party

AND  ANDREW JOHN GRENFELL and

WILLIAM GUY BLACK
Third Third Parties/Third Counterclaim

Defendant

Hearing:                   6 November 2013

Appearances:           E E Thiele for Plaintiff/First Counterclaim

Defendant (excused)

C J R Baird and C M Hanafin for First
Defendants/Counterclaimants
R J Hopkins and J Ling for Second Counterclaim
Defendant/First Third Party (excused)
I J Law for Second Third Party (excused)
H K Harkess and J E Tomlinson for Third Third Parties
(excused)
R J Hopkins and J Ling for Ingrid General Partner Ltd

(non-party Respondent) Judgment:     25 November 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

as to non-party discovery

WESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LTD v ADAMS [2013] NZHC 3113 [25 November 2013]

[1]      The  first  defendants  (the Adams)  seek  an  order  that  a  non-party (Ingrid

General Partnership Ltd – “Ingrid”) provide discovery and inspection of documents.

[2]      The documents sought are in three categories:

(a)      Full production information from all harvests that Ingrid has been associated with since March 2011 to the present, including brix specifications;

(b)A cash flow forecast for the five years from the date of funding by Westpac, and any cash flow forecasts since that date based on known or expected changes in cash flow requirements, including revised forecasts,  and  any  reports  prepared  that  identify  changes  in  the forecast from a previous forecast; and

(c)       Forward price projections.

[3]      The Adams in this proceeding bring a counterclaim against Westpac together with three third party claims in relation to alleged financial losses through their sale of a farm property at Seddon (the property) and their subsequent investment in a vineyard operation (Edzell Vineyards Ltd – “Edzell”).

[4]      Ingrid’s documents are sought on the basis that they will contain information relevant to the assessment of the Adams’s losses.

[5]      I held a hearing of this application consecutively upon the hearing of other interlocutory applications for security for costs.  I issue the judgment in relation to

the security issues contemporaneously with this judgment.1

1      Westpac New Zealand Ltd v Adams [2013] NZHC 3112.

Background to the proceeding

[6]      The relevant background was adequately set out in the summaries which Mr Baird provided in his written submissions for the applications before me.   I adopt that background for the purposes of this application.

Sale of the Seddon property – incorporation of Edzell: 2005-2006

In   or   around   November   2005,   the  Adams   approached   the   plaintiff (Westpac),   and   more   particularly   the   first   third   party   and   second counterclaim defendant (Mr Ensor), with a proposal for the development of a vineyard on the Adams farm (Property).  The Adams allege that Mr Ensor provided negligent advice to them and breached fiduciary duties he owed to them.

Subsequently,  the  Adams  and  Mr  Ensor  together  with  Roger…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Westpac New Zealand Ltd v Adams and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Westpac New Zealand Ltd v Adams involved a dispute between the Adams, who had sold their farm property and invested in a vineyard operation, and Westpac New Zealand Ltd, which had provided finance for the vineyard. The Adams sought an order that a non-party, Ingrid General Partnership Ltd, provide discovery and inspection of documents related to the vineyard's performance since March 2011. The Adams argued that these documents were necessary for assessing their financial losses, while Ingrid opposed the application. The court had to decide whether the documents were relevant and necessary for the Adams' claims. The court found that the documents were relevant and necessary for the Adams' experts to assess the vineyard's performance and compare it with their own vineyard. The court also considered the principles of proportionality and the potential impact of the discovery on the non-party's interests. The court ordered Ingrid to provide the requested documents, subject to certain conditions, and ruled that the Adams would bear the costs of the application, while Ingrid would bear the costs of complying with the discovery order.