Westpac New Zealand Ltd v Adams

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2011-409-000412 [2013] NZHC 3112

BETWEEN  WESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LTD Plaintiff

ANDLINDSAY HUMPHREY WILLIAM ADAMS and JUDITH CAROL ADAMS First Defendants

ANDROGER ARCHIBALD ADAMS Second Defendant

AND  HAMISH GUY ENSOR

First Third Party and Second Counterclaim

Defendant

ANDBROOK LAW Second Third Party

AND  ANDREW JOHN GRENFELL and

WILLIAM GUY BLACK
Third Third Parties/Third Counterclaim

Defendant

Hearing:                   5 November 2013

Appearances:           E E Thiele for Plaintiff/First Counterclaim Defendant

(attendance excused)
C J R Baird and C M Hanafin for First
Defendants/Counterclaimants
R J Hopkins and J Ling for Second Counterclaim
Defendant/First Third Party
I J Law for Second Third Party
H K Harkess and J E Tomlinson for Third Third Parties

Judgment:                25 November 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

as to security for costs

WESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LTD v ADAMS [2013] NZHC 3112 [25 November 2013]

Introduction

[1]      The first defendants (the Adams) experienced financial disaster through a vineyard development.  The vineyard banker sues them in this proceeding on their guarantee.    References  from  this  point  in  the  judgment  to  “defendants”  are  a reference to the first defendants (the plaintiff already having obtained judgment against the second defendant).

[2]      The Adams bring a counterclaim against Westpac together with three third party claims in relation to the sale of their farm property at Seddon (the property) and the subsequent investment in a vineyard operation (Edzell Vineyards Ltd  – “Edzell”).

[3]      The third parties apply for orders as to security for costs.

[4]      The Adams accept that they would be unable to pay costs if unsuccessful in this proceeding and that the threshold test for security is therefore established.  The key issues raised by the Adams in opposition are –

(a)       The Adams say they would be unable to proceed with the third party claims if security is ordered.

(b)The Adams assert that their impecuniosity was a consequence of the acts and omissions of the third parties as pleaded.

(c)       The Adams assert that the third party claims have strong prospects of success.

(d)The Adams  say,  alternatively,  that  in  the  event  security  is  to  be ordered it should be for a substantially lower sum than sought.

Background to the proceeding

[5]      I held a hearing of this application in conjunction with the hearing of another interlocutory application for orders as to discovery by non-parties.   I issued the

judgment in relation to the non-party discovery contemporaneously with this judgment.1

[6]      In the non-party judgment I have set out in some detail the background to the litigation and the precise manner in which the various claims and counterclaims have been pleaded.2

[7]      I adopt that more detailed background as if it were set out fully in this judgment.

[8]      For the purposes of the discussion that follows a summary will suffice.

[9]      The Adams sold their farm property to Edzell which was to be the investment vehicle for a vineyard development and operation.

[10]     The 100 ordinary shares in Edzell were held by the Adams jointly as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Westpac New Zealand Ltd v Adams and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3112
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Westpac New Zealand Ltd v Adams involved a dispute between the plaintiff, Westpac New Zealand Ltd, and the Adams, who were the first defendants. Westpac sued the Adams on their guarantee, while the Adams counterclaimed against Westpac and brought third-party claims against Mr Ensor, Mr Brook, and the receivers (Mr Grenfell and Mr Black). The third parties applied for orders as to security for costs. The primary issue was whether security should be granted in the sums sought by the third parties.

The court held that it would be inappropriate to order security for costs if the Adams were prevented from pursuing their third-party claims, as it would deny their basic right to access to justice. The court found that the Adams' third-party claims had a realistic prospect of success, and there was no clear conclusion as to their prospects of success or failure. Additionally, the court found that the Adams' impecuniosity was not causally linked to the third parties' actions.

Considering the potential for the third parties to be exposed to wasted costs and the importance of access to justice, the court concluded that it would be just for the Adams to provide a modest level of security for the costs of each third party. The court ordered the Adams to provide a total of $20,000 for each third party in two tranches, with the first tranche due by January 31, 2014, and the second tranche due on the service of the plaintiff's briefs of evidence. The court also ordered that the claims against any third party would become stayed if any tranche of payment was not made on the due date. Finally, the court ordered the Adams to pay the costs of the relevant security application and of the order on a Scale 2B and B basis together with disbursements to be fixed by the Registrar.