Scrapbook Alley Limited v Chow

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

CIV 2011-454-141 [2012] NZHC 2395

BETWEEN  SCRAPBOOK ALLEY LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDDAN CHOW, FAI CHOW AND DAVID ALAN LEA

Defendants

Hearing:         3 September 2012

Counsel:         G A Paine for Plaintiff

T G A Manktelow for Defendants

Judgment:      14 September 2012

JUDGMENT OF THE HON JUSTICE KÓS (Security for costs)

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiff, Scrapbook Alley Limited, is unlikely to be able to pay costs if it loses.   Notwithstanding that, an Associate Judge concluded that security for costs should not be awarded to the defendants.

[2]      The defendants submit that the Judge erred in his discretion in two respects. First, in concluding that there was a reasonable probability that it could be shown that the plaintiff’s impecuniosity resulted from the defendants’ actions the subject of the proceedings.   Secondly, in failing to conclude that the plaintiff’s prospects of success were poor.

[3]      I am asked to review, and reverse, the Judge’s decision.

SCRAPBOOK ALLEY LIMITED v CHOW & ORS HC PMN CIV 2011-454-141 [14 September 2012]

Background

[4]      The plaintiff is a scrapbook retailer.   Scrapbooking is a hobby activity in which the participants collect and retain ephemera in books.   The plaintiff was described by its counsel, Mr Gordon Paine, as itself something of a hobby activity.  It was not a large enterprise.   It operated via two branches.   Its main branch was in Palmerston North.  A smaller branch was established in Pahiatua.  It is that branch with which we are concerned here.

[5]      In February 2010 the plaintiff leased a shop in a small block owned by the defendants in Pahiatua.  The defendants were, therefore, the plaintiff’s landlord.  The rent was small: $5,200 per annum or $100 a week.   Also payable were certain outgoings (20 per cent of the rates and insurance premium payable in respect of the premises by the defendants).

[6]      In May 2010 there was a fire.  It appears to have been caused by an electrical fault in the building.  The plaintiff says that the fire caused some $62,000 damage to the plaintiff’s stock.   The plaintiff was given access immediately after the fire to remove salvageable items.   There appears to be an issue about whether they had completed removal by the time they reopened in the new premises.  The director of the plaintiff, Ms Patricia Street deposes:

At the end of the first week work started on the damaged premises and our shop was completely cleared out of all remaining items.   This must have been done by the defendants and/or agents as we were not advised about the clearing of the premises nor consulted about any of the remaining shop contents which were taken by the defendants may well have been destroyed, or it is possible that the defendants sold those items and have retained the proceeds.

[7]      After the fire the defendants terminated the lease.   There is no argument about whether they were entitled to do so.  The premises were no long tenantable. The defendants assisted the plaintiff obtain alternative…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scrapbook Alley Limited v Chow and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2395
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Scrapbook Alley Limited sued Dan Chow, Fai Chow and David Alan Lea for a fire that occurred at its Pahiatua shop in May 2010. The shop was leased from the defendants. The defendants terminated the lease and the plaintiff moved to temporary premises in Pahiatua within a week. The plaintiff ceased to trade altogether. The defendants sought security for costs in the amount of $15,000. An Associate Judge refused the application, finding that there was a reasonable probability that the plaintiff’s impecuniosity resulted from the defendants’ actions complained of in the proceeding. The defendants sought to review that decision. The plaintiff argued that the Judge was wrong in two respects: first, in concluding that there was a reasonable probability that it could be shown that the plaintiff’s impecuniosity resulted from the defendants’ actions the subject of the proceedings. Secondly, in failing to conclude that the plaintiff’s prospects of success were poor. The court concluded that the Judge erred in concluding that there was a reasonable probability that the plaintiff’s impecuniosity was the consequence of a cause of action in the claim. It was a possibility but, given the silence of the plaintiff, not a probability. The court disagreed with the plaintiff that the prospects of success of the plaintiff’s claim were poor. The Judge reached a reasoned view that the plaintiff’s claim was not so hopeless as to require strike out. The court concluded that ordering security of the amount sought would bring the plaintiff’s claim to a dead halt. It ordered a modest sum of $7,500 by way of security, which should not prevent the case from proceeding, but which will give the defendants some assurance in the event of success at trial. The application for review was allowed. There will be an order that the plaintiff pay security for costs of $7,500 before it takes any further steps in this proceeding. The defendants are entitled to costs on a category 2 band B basis.