Southland Building Society v Barlow Justice Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2012-412-000331 [2013] NZHC 1125

BETWEEN  SOUTHLAND BUILDING SOCIETY Plaintiff

ANDBARLOW JUSTICE LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         16 May 2013

(Heard at Christchurch)

Appearances: M J Borcoski for Applicant/Defendant

O G Paulsen for Respondent/Plaintiff

Judgment:      16 May 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE [as to particular discovery and interrogatories]

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiff, Southland Building Society (“SBS”) is a bank.  It lent $520,000 to a borrower (“the 2008 borrower”) partly as to $306,000 in March 2008 and partly as to $214,000 in June 2008.  It took security over three properties.  Before lending, it received a valuation report by the defendant (“Barlow”) of the properties which put the value, two months before the date of the report, at $800,000 plus GST, if any (“the Barlow valuation”).

[2]      The borrower defaulted.  SBS, as mortgagee, sold the properties.

[3]      SBS now sues Barlow for the short-fall of $380,504.04.  SBS alleges that the Barlow valuation was negligent and, in particular, that it overstated the value of the properties.  It alleges that the properties at the date of valuation were worth no more

than $380,000 plus GST, if any.

SOUTHLAND BUILDING SOCIETY V BARLOW JUSTICE LIMITED HC DUN CIV-2012-412-000331 [16

May 2013]

[4]      Barlow  denies  negligence.     It  pleads  alternatively  that  if  there  was negligence:

(a)       the negligence did not cause SBS’s loss; (b)     there was contributory negligence of SBS; (c)     SBS failed to mitigate its damage.

The present applications

[5]      Barlow makes two applications –

(a)       An application for particular discovery under r 8.19 High Court Rules; (b)    An application for an order that SBS answer interrogatories under

r 8.38 High Court Rules.

Further background

[6]      There was a sequence of transactions by which SBS had previously lent money on the security of the properties.   Without determining that the following narrative is fully accurate, I treat it as very likely to be so and take it from an amended pleading which Barlow intends to file:

(a)      In 2005 the properties were purchased by Adventure Tourism Limited (“ATL”), which is a company associated with the same individuals who were involved with the 2008 borrower.   ATL obtained a loan from SBS to complete the purchase of the properties in 2005 (“the

2005 loan”);

(b)In  about  2007,  upon  the  liquidation  of ATL,  the  properties  were transferred  to  shareholders  of ATL  and  the  shareholders  obtained loans from SBS to repay the ATL loan (“the 2007 loans”);

(c)      In about 2008, the properties were transferred to the 2008 borrower, whose shareholders were the previous owners of the properties and the previous shareholders of ATL;

(d)      When the 2008 loans were made to the 2008 borrower, the loan was

used to repay the shareholders’ loan.

The thrust of Barlow’s argument as to relevance

[7]      The  further  background  is  relied  on  by  Ms  Borcoski  for  Barlow  as establishing the relevance of the information sought (both under the discovery and under the interrogatories application).     Ms Borcoski submits that this factual background is relevant to two key issues…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southland Building Society v Barlow Justice Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1125
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Southland Building Society is suing Barlow Justice Limited for the short-fall of $380,504.04, alleging that Barlow's valuation report overstated the value of the properties that were used as security for a loan. Barlow denies negligence and argues that even if there was negligence, it did not cause the loss, and that there was contributory negligence and failure to mitigate damage. Barlow applied for particular discovery and an order that the plaintiff answer interrogatories. The court found that the documents sought for discovery were not relevant to the issues in the proceeding, and the interrogatories were not relevant to the matters in question. The court dismissed the applications, but reserved leave to apply if there was no agreement on certain facts for the purposes of trial. The defendant was to pay the plaintiff's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established