Commerce Commission v Air New Zealand Ltd (No 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2008-404-008352 [2012] NZHC 2113

BETWEEN  COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

ANDAIR NEW ZEALAND LTD Defendant

CIV-2008-404-008350

AND BETWEEN            COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

ANDMALAYSIAN AIRLINE SYSTEM BERHAD LTD

Defendant

CIV-2008-404-008354

AND BETWEEN            COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

ANDTHAI AIRWAYS INTERNATIONAL PUBLIC CO LTD

Defendant

CIV-2008-404-008356

AND BETWEEN            COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

ANDSINGAPORE AIRLINES LTD & SINGAPORE AIRLINES CARGO PTE LTD

Defendants

CIV-2008-404-008357

COMMERCE COMMISSION V AIR NEW ZEALAND LTD HC AK CIV-2008-404-008352 [20 August 2012]

AND BETWEEN            COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

ANDCATHAY PACIFIC AIRWAYS LTD Defendant

Hearing:         8 August 2012

Counsel:         BWF Brown QC, JCL Dixon and LCA Farmer for Plaintiff

SJP Ladd for Air New Zealand
IJ Thain for Cathay Pacific
JL Land for Malaysian Airlines
MD O'Brien and JH Stevens for Singapore Airlines
TC Weston QC and AW Lear for Thai Airways

Judgment:      20 August 2012

JUDGMENT (No 6) OF ASHER J (Interrogatories)

This judgment was delivered by me on Monday, 20 August 2012 at 5pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:
Meredith Connell (Auckland) for Commerce Commission
Bell Gully (Auckland/Wellington) for Air New Zealand & Singapore Airlines

Kensington Swan (Auckland) for Malaysian Airlines Lowndes Associates (Auckland) for Thai Airways DLA Phillips Fox (Auckland) for Cathay Pacific

BWF Brown QC; JA Farmer QC; AR Galbraith QC; TC Weston QC; AW Lear

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1] The application for interrogatories  [5] The issues  [11] The nature of the questions  [14] Specific questions  [23] Oppressive questions?

Facts proved by other means?  [26]

Speculative questions  [29] Questions as to accuracy  [33] “Don’t know” answers  [35] Work load         [40] Timing  [50] Particular position of Cathay Pacific  [53] Limited interrogatories?  [56] Result  [58]

Introduction

[1]      In this proceeding the Commerce Commission claims that Cathay Pacific Airways Ltd, along with other airlines, fixed fuel and security surcharges at certain agreed rates.  The proceeding is at present part-heard.  There has been a stage one hearing which  determined  that  there is  a  market  in  New  Zealand  for  air  cargo services from an overseas country or region to New Zealand.  The parties are now preparing for a stage two hearing which will consider the remaining matters.  The core issue to be determined is whether the defendant airlines entered into arrangements, understandings or agreements on fuel and security surcharge rates. That hearing is set down to begin in March 2013.   It may take as long as four months.

[2]      Separate proceedings have been issued against each airline.   However, the proceedings are all to be heard together, and most issues have been determined between the Commerce Commission and the airlines acting collectively.  A number of the defendant airlines pleaded guilty prior to the first stage hearing, and through the course of this year further airlines have entered guilty pleas.  I was informed at the outset of this hearing that Malaysian Airline System Berhad Ltd (“Malaysian”),

the defendant in the still extant proceedings CIV-2008-404-008350, is also in discussions with the Commerce Commission, and with the agreement of both the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Air New Zealand Ltd (No 6) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Commerce Commission is pursuing proceedings against several airlines, including Cathay Pacific Airways Ltd, alleging that they fixed fuel and security surcharge rates in contravention of the Commerce Act. The proceedings are ongoing, and this particular hearing concerns an application for interrogatories issued by the Commerce Commission against three airlines that are still defending the application. The Commission's case is that the defendants were party to and implemented overarching understandings and agreements to fix the price of fuel and security surcharges on worldwide networks and regional agreements to fix the price of fuel surcharges on outbound shipments from certain points of origin. The airlines objected to the interrogatories on the basis that they were not necessary, were oppressive, and imposed an unfair burden on them as they were also preparing for similar proceedings in Australia.

The court found that interrogatories are designed to elicit material that will help the interrogating party's case, and their purpose is different from that of pleadings, requests for particulars, and notices to admit facts. The court also noted that interrogatories must relate to material facts rather than evidence and must not be oppressive. The court found that the specific questions relating to the meetings were relevant and permissible, as they related to what was said between the parties about the surcharges which may prove the key fact of a contract, arrangement, or understanding. However, questions asking for confirmation of the accuracy of the minutes were considered oppressive as they often involved nuanced issues that would require context and opinion. The court also found that some questions relating to meetings where there was no evidence connecting the airline to the meeting were speculative and impermissible. The court concluded that the interrogatories were not oppressive overall, as the airlines had considerable resources and had been grappling with the issues for some time. The court granted the application for interrogatories but with some limitations and extended the deadline for answering the questions to 15 October 2012.

Cathay Pacific Airways Ltd, Singapore Airlines Ltd & Singapore Airlines Cargo Pte Ltd, and Thai Airways International Public Co Ltd are to file and serve answers to the interrogatories contained in the notices of interrogatory of the plaintiff dated 29 June 2012, save for the following questions: (a) Questions which relate to a meeting where it has not been shown that a representative of the defendant airline being asked the question was present, or it is not shown that a group of airlines likely to include the interrogated airline were represented at the meeting, or it is not shown that the particular airline of which the question is asked was sent or received a copy of the minutes. So long as one of the stated criteria is met, the defendant airline has to answer the question. (b) Questions as to the accuracy or completeness of a particular minute or part thereof. The answers are to be provided by 15 October 2012. Costs are reserved for further submissions if the parties consider this necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established