Consolidated Alloys (NZ) Limited v Edging Systems (NZ) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-003021 [2012] NZHC 2818

UNDER  the Patents Act 1953 and the Fair Trading

Act 1986

IN THE MATTER OF     patent infringement and breach of the Fair

Trading Act

BETWEEN  CONSOLIDATED ALLOYS (NZ) LIMITED

Plaintiff

ANDEDGING SYSTEMS (NZ) LIMITED First Defendant

ANDROBERT MAX BROUGH Second Defendant

Hearing:         23 October 2012

Counsel:         TJ Walker and JC Dickson for Plaintiff

KW McLeod for Defendants

Judgment:      25 October 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASHER J

This judgment was delivered by me on Thursday, 25 October 2012 at 5pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Simpson Grierson, DX CX 10092, Auckland.

Email: tracey.walker@simpsongrierson.com and  joanne.dickson@simpsongrierson.com

AJ Park, DX CP 21527, Auckland. Email:  kim.mcleod@ajpark.com

CONSOLIDATED ALLOYS (NZ) LTD V EDGING SYSTEMS (NZ) LTD HC AK CIV-2012-404-003021 [25

October 2012]

Introduction

[1]      In this commercial list proceeding the plaintiff, Consolidated Alloys (NZ) Ltd, seeks to issue interrogatories against the second defendant, Robert Max Brough.

[2]      The claims in the proceeding are for patent infringement and misleading and deceptive conduct in terms of s 9 of the Fair Trading Act 1986.   The  essential allegation is that Edging Systems (NZ) Ltd has manufactured, marketed and supplied part of a roof flashing system (“EZ-Edge”) which breaches Consolidated Alloys’ patent, and misleads the public into thinking that it is the product of Consolidated Alloys, and of similar performance and characteristics.

[3]      This application for interrogatories was filed on 15 October 2012.  There is a fixture for the substantive hearing set down for 5 November 2012.

The issues

[4]      The defendants claim that the interrogatories are vexatious and oppressive, particularly given the close proximity to the trial.   It was submitted that because these are commercial list proceedings no interrogatories should be ordered.  It was asserted that the second defendant, Mr Brough, was currently in Greece and cannot be contacted.  It is asserted that many of the interrogatories contain mixed questions of fact and law, or are an attempt to obtain further and better discovery, or an attempt to obtain further and better particulars.  It is said that many of the interrogatories are irrelevant.

[5]      The plaintiff says that the delay in issuing this request for interrogatories is explicable in light of the fact that it was reasonably anticipated that Mr Brough would give evidence by way of a brief.  It was only discovered that he would not be giving any evidence when the briefs of evidence were provided by the defendants on

24 September 2012 (they were due on 7 September 2012).  It is submitted that the plaintiff has acted promptly since then, serving its interrogatories on 28 September

2012.

[6]      An ancillary issue that arises is whether the Court can properly take into account the fact that Mr Brough filed a “will say” statement for a settlement conference in the proceeding in November of last year.

The issue of interrogatories

[7]      Rule 8.40(1) of the High Court Rules provides:1

8.40  Objection to answer

(1)   A party may object…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Consolidated Alloys (NZ) Limited v Edging Systems (NZ) Limit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2818
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Consolidated Alloys (NZ) Ltd initiated proceedings against Edging Systems (NZ) Ltd and Robert Max Brough, the second defendant, alleging patent infringement and misleading or deceptive conduct under the Fair Trading Act 1986. The plaintiff sought to issue interrogatories to the second defendant, who was currently in Greece, shortly before the substantive hearing was set down. The defendants argued that the interrogatories were vexatious and oppressive, particularly given the short time before the hearing. The plaintiff contended that the delay was explicable due to a reasonable expectation that the second defendant would give evidence by way of a brief.

The court considered the nature and purpose of interrogatories, which are designed to elicit material that will help a party’s case, and are different from pleadings or requests for particulars. The court noted that interrogatories must relate to material facts rather than evidence and that they should not be oppressive. The court also considered whether it was proper to take into account a "will say" statement filed by the second defendant for a settlement conference. The court found that the privilege in settlement negotiations protects admissions against interest in settlement negotiations, not the mere fact that such documents have come into existence.

The court examined the interrogatories and found that some were relevant and reasonable, particularly those seeking information about the second defendant's involvement in the alleged unlawful acts. The court directed that some interrogatories be answered with changes to the wording, while declining to issue others that were either too detailed or peripheral to the central issues of the case. The court granted leave for the plaintiff to issue the application but directed that only certain interrogatories be answered.

The court ordered that costs of the application would lie where they fell, as both parties had a measure of success.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established