Torbay Holdings Limited v Napier

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-7660 [2014] NZHC 1198

BETWEEN

TORBAY HOLDINGS LIMITED

First Plaintiff

TORBAY REST HOME LIMITED Second Plaintiff

AND

DUNCAN JOHN N APIER and

SARA ANN NAPIER First Defendants

DUNCAN JOHN NAPIER SARA ANN NAPIER and CHRISTOPHER JOHN DAVIS

as trustees of the NAPIER FAMILY TRUST

Second Defendants

CIV-2013-404-1406

BETWEEN  DUNCAN JOHN NAPIER and

SARA ANN NAPIER First Plaintiffs

DUNCAN JOHN NPAIER SARA ANN NAPIER and CHRISTOPHER JOHN DAVIS

as trustees of the NAPIER FAMILY TRUST

Second Plaintiffs

ANDSANDSPIT BAY HOLDINGS LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 6 May 2014

Appearances:

D P H Jones QC for Plaintiffs
S J Tee for Defendants

Judgment:

30 May 2014

TORBAY HOLDINGS LIMITED v NAPIER and NAPIER [2014] NZHC 1198 [30 May 2014]

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATEJUDGE BELL

This judgment was delivered by me on  30 May 2014 at 2:30pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

………………………………………….

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:
Sellar Bone, Auckland, for Plaintiffs

Morteon Tee & Co, Takapuna, for Defendants

[1]      This decision is on cross-applications for further discovery.  The defendants apply under r 8.17 of the High Court Rules for a variation of the original discovery order and under r 8.19 for discovery of documents that they say should have been disclosed.  The plaintiffs apply only under r 8.19. The defendants also challenge the plaintiffs’ claim of confidentiality for some documents.

[2]      After the hearing the plaintiffs filed a memorandum explaining that further documents in their control had come to light.  I have taken that into account in my decision.

Background

[3]      The first plaintiff owns and the second plaintiff operates a rest home.  The current director of both companies is Mr Michael Single.  Duncan and Sara Napier used to be but no longer are directors of the company.   The second defendants, trustees of their family trust, are shareholders.  The Napiers worked in the rest home up to 2012, Mr Napier as part-time manager and financial controller, Mrs Napier as nursing manager.   The plaintiffs allege that Mr and Mrs Napier misappropriated funds of Torbay Rest Home Ltd amounting to $1,937,741.31 and of Torbay Holdings Ltd amounting to $70,133.51.  The money taken out of Torbay Rest Home Ltd is said to comprise $1,612,443.83 for unauthorised cheque payments, $312,869.00 for unauthorised remuneration and $12,428.48 for unauthorised transfers.   The funds taken out of Torbay Holdings Ltd are said to comprise $24,330.00 for payments to third parties, $24,981.80 for cash cheques, and $20,822.23 for cheques made out to Mr Napier.

[4]      The  plaintiffs  allege  that  some  of  the  funds  misappropriated  by  the defendants went into a property the second defendants owned at Sandspit Road, Warkworth, and later into the purchase of a property at Whangaripo Valley Road, Wellsford and the construction of a house there.  The plaintiffs’ causes of action are for money had and received, for an institutional constructive trust in the Whangaripo Valley property and for damages for extra payments the plaintiffs made to the Commissioner of Inland Revenue.  The statement of claim expressly disclaims…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Torbay Holdings Limited v Napier and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1198
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved cross-applications for further discovery by both the plaintiffs and defendants in a proceeding concerning allegations of misappropriation of funds by the defendants. The plaintiffs, Torbay Holdings Limited and Torbay Rest Home Limited, alleged that the defendants, Duncan and Sara Napier, misappropriated significant sums of money from the plaintiffs' companies. The defendants denied the allegations and sought further discovery to support their defence that the payments were for proper corporate purposes. The plaintiffs, in turn, sought further discovery from the defendants to substantiate their claims. The court was required to determine whether the additional discovery sought by both parties was relevant and proportionate to the subject matter of the proceeding.

The court found that given the nature of the case, extensive discovery on both sides was warranted. For the plaintiffs, the defendants should disclose documents that could establish whether they misappropriated company funds, and the way they used any proceeds of company cheques was material. The court should not take a niggardly approach in requiring disclosure to establish whether there were misappropriations. Similarly, it was important that the plaintiffs made full disclosure to the defendants to ensure they had ample opportunity to make out their defence. The court considered the specific classes of documents sought by the defendants and plaintiffs, taking into account the pleadings, discovery principles, and the nature of the allegations. The court made orders for the disclosure of specific classes of documents, set aside the plaintiffs' claim of confidentiality for certain documents, and directed the parties to work out protocols for the extraction of documents from a clone of the defendants' computer hard drive. The court also made orders for the disclosure of documents sought by the plaintiffs and reserved leave to apply for further directions. Both sides were invited to confer on costs, with an opportunity for memoranda if they could not agree.

In summary, the court found that extensive discovery was necessary in this case involving allegations of misappropriation of funds. The court made orders for the disclosure of specific classes of documents sought by both parties, set aside the plaintiffs' claim of confidentiality for certain documents, and directed the parties to work out protocols for the extraction of documents from a clone of the defendants' computer hard drive. Both sides were invited to confer on costs, with an opportunity for memoranda if they could not agree.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.