AAM Limited v Exotica Enterprise Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2016-404-2850

[2018] NZHC 3031

BETWEEN

AAM LIMITED

First Plaintiff

MUMTAJ YUNUS AGARBATTIWALA
Second Plaintiff

AND

EXOTICA ENTERPRISE LIMITED

First Defendant

DARIUS KARANI
Second Defendant

MANUKA MASTERS LIMITED

Third Defendant

Hearing: 5 November 2018

Appearances:

F Pereira for the First Plaintiff

M Y Agarbattiwala, the Second Plaintiff, self-represented L Ponniah for the Defendants

Judgment:

22 November 2018


JUDGMENT (No.2) OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL


This judgment was delivered by me on 22 November 2018 at 3:00pm

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

…………………………………

Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Pereira Law (Ferdinand Pereira), Auckland, for the First Plaintiff

Corban Revell (C Orton), Henderson, Auckland, for the First Defendant

Copy for:

Mumtaj Agarbattiwala, the Second Plaintiff

Lawrence Ponniah, Eastridge, Auckland, for the First Defendant

AAM LIMITED v EXOTICA ENTERPRISE LIMITED [2018] NZHC 3031 [22 November 2018]

[1]    The plaintiffs apply for further discovery under r 8.19 of the High Court Rules. Their application goes to the adequacy of the defendants’ disclosure of financial records for the plaintiffs’ claims for breach of contract and misrepresentation on the defendants’ sale of a business. The plaintiffs say that the defendants have not discovered all the documents they were ordered to and that what they have disclosed shows that they should disclose other categories of documents. The defendants’ general response is that they have already disclosed what was ordered and there is no basis for requiring further discovery. Accordingly, there are two main questions:

·Have the defendants disclosed what was ordered?

·Should they be required to discover other documents?

[2]    This is the third discovery application. In March 2017, by agreement Associate Judge Doogue directed standard discovery. The first and second defendants filed an affidavit of documents in April 2017. The third defendant filed a separate affidavit at the same time. Not satisfied with that discovery, especially the disclosure of the defendants’ financial records of the defendants, the plaintiffs applied for further discovery under r 8.19 of the High Court Rules. Associate Judge Christiansen ordered disclosure of specified classes of financial documents by the defendants.1 Neither side challenged his decision. The defendants filed affidavits of documents on 2 February 2018: one by the first and second defendants and a second by the third defendant. The defendants cross-applied for discovery, and security for costs.   On 16 April 2018,     I gave rulings for the plaintiffs to provide and further discovery.2 The plaintiffs filed the present application on 26 July 2018.

The parties’ representation


1      AAM Ltd v Exotica Enterprise Ltd [2017] NZHC 3033.

2      AAM Ltd v Exotica Enterprise Ltd [2018] NZHC 717.

[3]    The parties’ representation has changed during the proceeding. At the start, the plaintiffs were represented by Vinci Law and instructed a barrister. The defendants were represented  by  Haigh  Lyon. In 2017 the defendants changed solicitors. Mr Ponniah has been counsel for them since then. After Associate Judge Christiansen’s decision, Vinci Law no…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AAM Limited v Exotica Enterprise Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 3031
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs in this proceeding, AAM Limited and Mumtaj Yunus Agarbattiwala, have applied for further discovery under rule 8.19 of the High Court Rules. Their application concerns the adequacy of the defendants’ disclosure of financial records relevant to the plaintiffs’ claims for breach of contract and misrepresentation on the defendants’ sale of a business. The defendants, Exotica Enterprise Limited, Darius Karani, and Manuka Masters Limited, have opposed the application. The main questions are whether the defendants have disclosed what was ordered and whether they should be required to discover other documents. This is the third discovery application in the proceeding. In March 2017, Associate Judge Doogue directed standard discovery. The defendants filed an affidavit of documents in April 2017. Not satisfied with that discovery, especially the disclosure of the defendants’ financial records, the plaintiffs applied for further discovery under rule 8.19 of the High Court Rules. Associate Judge Christiansen ordered disclosure of specified classes of financial documents by the defendants. The defendants filed affidavits of documents on 2 February 2018. The plaintiffs filed the present application on 26 July 2018. The plaintiffs have shown that there are gaps in the defendants’ discovery and discrepancies between their discovery and their annual financial statements. The sums stated for annual turnover, overseas sales and costs of purchases in the financial statements are not fully supported by disclosed invoices. Potential explanations include that the defendants hold those documents but have not disclosed them, that the defendants used to hold the documents but no longer have them, or that there are no further invoices. On an application for further discovery under rule 8.19, the court is not required to make conclusive findings as to reasons why complete discovery has not been made. It is sufficient if there are grounds for believing that a party has not discovered documents that should have been discovered. There are grounds for believing that Exotica Enterprise Limited has not disclosed documents that Associate Judge Christiansen ordered them to discover. The unsatisfactory disclosure by Exotica Enterprise Limited makes it prudent to require similar by Manuka Masters Limited, a related company. It is not however necessary to require disclosure of documents for the year ending 31 March 2013. Exotica Enterprise Limited is to file and serve a further affidavit of documents in which it will address the gaps and discrepancies identified in this decision. In particular, it will disclose all invoices not disclosed to date from 1 April 2013 to 31 March 2018. It will also disclose bank statements, credit card statements, Bartercard and BBX records from 1 April 2013 to 31 March 2018. Within 20 working days of this decision Manuka Masters Limited is to file and serve a further affidavit of documents in which it will disclose bank statements, credit card statements, Bartercard and BBX records from 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2018. The Registrar is to arrange a face-to-face conference after 30 working days to review compliance with these orders and to give further case management directions. The plaintiffs have costs on the application. I invite the parties to confer as to costs. If they cannot agree, memoranda may be filed and I will decide costs on the papers. Leave is reserved to apply for further directions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.