Body Corporate 396711 v Sentinel Management Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2010-404-007754 [2012] NZHC 1957

UNDER  the Declaratory Judgements Act 1908

IN THE MATTER OF     the Unit Titles Act 2010

BETWEEN  BODY CORPORATE 396711

First Plaintiff

ANDDENNIS JOHN ANSLEY Second Plaintiff

ANDSENTINEL MANAGEMENT LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         3 and 5 October 2011

Counsel:         T J Rainey and J P Wood for Plaintiffs

N R Campbell for Defendant

Judgment:      8 August 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF WOOLFORD J

This judgment was delivered by me on Wednesday, 8 August 2012 at 11:00 am pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Rainey Law, Solicitors, Auckland

Alexander Dorrington, Solicitors, Auckland

BODY CORPORATE 396711 & OR V SENTINEL MANAGEMENT LIMITED HC AK CIV 2010-404-007754 [8 August 2012]

Contents

Introduction ..........................................................................................................[1] Factual background .............................................................................................[7] The Pleadings......................................................................................................[19] Statutory Framework ........................................................................................[22] UTA 1972 – title ...................................................................................................[24] UTA 1972 –governance........................................................................................[27] UTA 2010 – title ...................................................................................................[30] UTA 2010–governance.........................................................................................[32] First Cause of Action – validity of the amended rules ....................................[33] Counsels’ submissions .........................................................................................[34] Legal Principles – amendment .............................................................................[36] Application – Schedule 2 rules.............................................................................[47] Application – Schedule 3 rules.............................................................................[56] Conclusion............................................................................................................[61] Second Cause of Action – ultra vires UTA 1972 ..............................................[62] Counsels’ submissions .........................................................................................[63] Legal Principles – ultra vires...............................................................................[65] Ultra vires the UTA 1972 .....................................................................................[69] Ultra vires the rules .............................................................................................[73] Framing the legal arguments in this case ............................................................[75] Legal principles – severance................................................................................[79] Application – ultra vires.......................................................................................[83] The Letting Service...............................................................................................[84] The Real Estate Sale Service ..............................................................................[100] The Sentinel Residents Service ...........................................................................[102] The Management Service ...................................................................................[103] Conclusions – ultra vires terms..........................................................................[114] Application – severance .....................................................................................[115] Conclusion – second cause of action .................................................................[121] Third Cause of Action – breach of vendor’s duties ......................................[122] Counsels’ submissions .......................................................................................[124] Legal principles – vendor’s duties to purchaser ................................................[126] Legal principles – Dishonest assistance ............................................................[134] Legal principles – relief .....................................................................................[137] Legal principles – affirmation............................................................................[139] Application – vendor’s duties to purchaser .......................................................[140] Application – dishonest assistance.....................................................................[149] Application – relief.............................................................................................[156] Application – affirmation ...................................................................................[159] Conclusion..........................................................................................................[160] Fourth Cause of Action – breach of promoter’s duties ................................[161] Counsels’ submissions .......................................................................................[162] Legal principles – promoter’s duties .................................................................[164] Legal principles - remedy...................................................................................[176] Legal Principles – affirmation ...........................................................................[181] Application – promoter’s duties.........................................................................[182] Application – dishonest assistance.....................................................................[198] Application - remedy ..........................................................................................[199]

Conclusion..........................................................................................................[202] Fifth Cause of Action – unconscionable bargain...........................................[203] Counsels’ submissions .......................................................................................[204] Legal principles – unconscionable bargain .......................................................[206] Application – unconscionable bargain ..............................................................[207] Conclusion..........................................................................................................[201] Sixth Cause of Action – Section 140 UTA 2010 .............................................[211] Counsels’ submissions .......................................................................................[212] Legal principles – section 140 UTA 2010 ..........................................................[214] Legislative History .............................................................................................[215] Comparable statutory provisions .......................................................................[216] Interpretation .....................................................................................................[219] Comparable legal standards: harsh and unconscionable .................................[221] Comparable legal standards: oppressiveness....................................................[222] Comparable legal standards: unconscionability ...............................................[225] Application – time period ...................................................................................[232] Application – harsh and unconscionable ...........................................................[246] Conclusion..........................................................................................................[267] Result .................................................................................................................[269] Relief ..................................................................................................................[270] Costs ..................................................................................................................[272]

Introduction

[1]      The Sentinel is a 30 storey residential complex containing 117 apartments and a number of retail shops situated in Takapuna on Auckland’s North Shore.  It is a unit title development.

[2]      The  first  plaintiff,  Body  Corporate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 396711 v Sentinel Management Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1957
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the Unit Titles Act 2010, Body Corporate 396711 and Dennis John Ansley brought proceedings against Sentinel Management Limited. The plaintiffs alleged that the management agreement between the Body Corporate and Sentinel Management Limited was invalid and unenforceable on several grounds, including that it was ultra vires the Unit Titles Act 1972, constituted an unconscionable bargain, and was harsh and unconscionable under s 140 of the Unit Titles Act 2010. The defendant denied the allegations and raised defences of affirmation and jurisdiction.

The court found that the first cause of action, concerning the validity of the amended rules, failed as the plaintiffs did not establish that the rules were not validly adopted. The court found that the second cause of action, concerning the ultra vires nature of the management agreement, succeeded in part. Certain provisions of the management agreement were found to be ultra vires the Unit Titles Act 1972 and the amended rules. However, the court held that these provisions were severable from the remainder of the agreement, which would otherwise be valid.

The court found that the third and fourth causes of action, concerning breaches of trust and fiduciary duties, failed. The fifth cause of action, concerning an unconscionable bargain, also failed as the plaintiffs could not establish the necessary grounds for relief. However, the sixth cause of action, concerning the harshness and unconscionability of the management agreement under s 140 of the Unit Titles Act 2010, succeeded. The court found that the management agreement was harsh or unconscionable because of the ultra vires clauses, the potential length of the term, and the difference in termination rights. The court terminated the agreement, effective 28 days from the date of the judgment.

In terms of relief, the court granted declarative relief and reserved leave for the parties to apply for clarification on any consequential invalidity of other rules or clauses. The court also requested the parties to consider the position of the Body Corporate and Mr Ansley vis-a-vis costs and asked them to submit memoranda on costs if they could not agree.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.