Body Corporate 406198 v Property Opportunities Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA178/2022
 [2023] NZCA 302

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 406198
Appellant

AND

PROPERTY OPPORTUNITIES LIMITED
First Respondent

SHIRAZ HOLIDAY LIMITED
Second Respondent

BIANCO LIMITED
Third Respondent

AVONDALE PROPERTIES LIMITED
Fourth Respondent

Hearing:

14 February 2023

Court:

Katz, Whata and Davison JJ

Counsel:

D R Bigio KC and H W Struthers for Appellant
T J Rainey for Second Respondent
No appearance for First, Third and Fourth Respondents

Judgment:

19 July 2023 at 11:00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed in part.

BThe matter is referred back to the High Court for reconsideration of the unjust enrichment claim in light of our finding that cl 5.6.6 is ultra vires.

CThe second respondent must pay costs to the appellant for a standard appeal on a band B basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Whata J)

Introduction

  1. This appeal relates to a unit title development in central Auckland known as “Bianco Off Queen”.  The development comprises 157 principal units in two tower blocks.  Some units are used as residential apartments, while others are used as part of a hotel/short-term accommodation business.  One of the units is a commercial unit (Management Unit)[1] owned by the first respondent, Property Opportunities Ltd (POL). 

    [1]Also known as Unit 1F/2.

  2. The appellant, Body Corporate 406198 (Body Corporate) is the body corporate for the development.  The second respondent, Shiraz Holiday Limited (Shiraz) is the building manager (the Manager) pursuant to a management agreement (the Management Agreement) originally entered into between the Body Corporate and Shiraz’s predecessor in 2008.  At that time, the developer of the project, Timothy Manning, had sole control of both contracting parties. 

  3. Under the Management Agreement, Shiraz is given the exclusive right to provide letting services on behalf of the unit owners.  This enables it to operate a hotel/short-term accommodation business on the site.  Shiraz leases the Management Unit from POL for use as the reception and office for the hotel/short‑term accommodation business.  Clause 5.6.6 of the Management Agreement envisages payment of a contribution by the Body Corporate to the rental cost incurred by Shiraz for the Management Unit.

  4. The Body Corporate issued proceedings in the High Court challenging the validity of the Management Agreement.  At heart, the Body Corporate’s concern is that the effect of the Management Agreement is to improperly require unit owners to cross‑subsidise Shiraz’s running of the hotel and short-term accommodation business, in breach of the Unit Titles Act 1972 (UTA 1972).   

  5. The Body Corporate’s claims succeeded in part.  Campbell J found that the provisions in the Management Agreement giving Shiraz exclusive rights to provide letting services and hotel management services were ultra vires the UTA 1972.[2]  The Judge was not satisfied, however, that the Management Agreement as a whole, or cl 5.6.6 in particular, were ultra vires.[3]  The Body Corporate appeals on the grounds that the Judge erred in deciding that clause 5.6.6 is not ultra vires, that the Management Agreement is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 406198 v Property Opportunities Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZCA 302
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal pertains to a unit title development named “Bianco Off Queen,” situated in central Auckland, comprising 157 principal units within two tower blocks. The appellant, Body Corporate 406198 (Body Corporate), serves as the body corporate for the development, while the first respondent, Property Opportunities Limited (POL), owns a commercial unit (Management Unit) leased to Shiraz Holiday Limited (Shiraz), the building manager. The second respondent, Shiraz, operates a hotel/short-term accommodation business on the site under a management agreement (Management Agreement) with the Body Corporate. The Body Corporate initiated proceedings in the High Court, challenging the Management Agreement's validity, asserting it improperly required unit owners to subsidise Shiraz's hotel and short-term accommodation business operations, contravening the Unit Titles Act 1972 (UTA 1972). The Body Corporate's claims partially succeeded; the Judge found certain provisions in the Management Agreement ultra vires the UTA 1972, but not the agreement as a whole or cl 5.6.6 specifically. The Body Corporate appeals, contending the Judge erred in finding that cl 5.6.6 is not ultra vires, that the Management Agreement is intra vires, and that the ultra vires provisions were severable.

The court found that the Judge erred in determining that cl 5.6.6 was not ultra vires. The Body Corporate's actions must be referable to its lawful powers and duties. As the Body Corporate bound itself to an exclusive letting regime, cl 5.6.6, directed at compensating for the rental cost of the unit used for this exclusive letting regime, must also be invalid. However, the Management Agreement is otherwise lawful, and the Body Corporate's remaining powers and duties under it can be discharged without recourse to the provisions relating to the exclusive letting regime.

The appeal is allowed in part. The matter is referred back to the High Court for reconsideration of the unjust enrichment claim in light of the finding that cl 5.6.6 is ultra vires. The second respondent must pay costs to the appellant for a standard appeal on a band B basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established