Body Corporate 114424 v LV Trust Holdings Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA50/2013
[2014] NZCA 21 

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 114424
Appellant

AND

LV TRUST HOLDINGS LIMITED AND KP TRUST HOLDINGS LIMITED
First Respondents

SHANGRI-LA APARTMENTS SERVICES LIMITED
Second Respondent
MARCEL VONGUE (AS REPRESENTATIVE OF ESTATE OF EMILE VONGUE)
Third Respondent
ERIC CHARLES SPENCER AND PATRICK WILLIAM FRANK WILSON
Fourth Respondents
WARREN LEE TAMAHORI
Fifth Respondent
PICCOLINA LIMITED
Sixth Respondent
ROBIN ALBERT FLANNAGAN AND SUZANNE JOY ROGERS
Seventh Respondents
ANTHONY DAVID GAULT AND IAN GEORGE GAULT
Eighth Respondents
SHIRLEY PATRICIA KENT
Ninth Respondent
LISA MAREE TAUBER AND RICHARD KRISTIAN HENRY HOLLAND
Tenth Respondents
HEATHER MARGARET ANDERSON, MICHAEL DAVID HOCQUARD CLARK AND RODERICK NEILL GILLESPIE
Eleventh Respondents
OLIVE HILDA-GARDE WALKER
Twelfth Respondent
JOHN REVELL HYNDS AND LEONIE ANDREE HYNDS
Thirteenth Respondents
MITCHELL ROBERT STRONGE AND MRS TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED
Fourteenth Respondents
KARYN LOUISE MILLER AND PHILLIP JOSEPH MILLER
Fifteenth Respondents
THE HONG KONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LIMITED
Sixteenth Respondent
WESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Seventeenth Respondent
ANZ BANK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Eighteenth Respondent
RICE CRAIG SOLICITORS NOMINEE COMPANY LIMITED
Ninetieth Respondent
ASB BANK LIMITED
Twentieth Respondent
AIG INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED (FORMERLY CHARTIS INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED)
Twenty-First Respondent
Hearing:

12 November 2013

Court:

Ellen France, White and Winkelmann JJ

Counsel:

C T Walker for Appellant
N R Campbell QC for First Respondents
No appearance for other Respondents

Judgment:

20 February 2014 at 10.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant is to pay the first respondents’ costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by White J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction  [1]
The cost allocation  

Factual background  [17]
Asher J’s reasons  [25]
Discussion  [26]

Compensation  

Factual background  [44]
Asher J’s reasons  [48]
Discussion  [50]

Result  [66]

Introduction

  1. The 17 level Shangri-La residential apartment tower on Jervois Road, Herne Bay, Auckland, was a “leaky building” which cost over $6 million to make weatherproof by work which included recladding the south-western half of the building with a glass curtain wall.

  2. This appeal relates to a dispute between the majority of the owners of the units in the tower, represented by the appellant, Body Corporate 114424 (the Body Corporate), and the first respondents, LV Trust Holdings Ltd and KP Trust Holdings Ltd (the applicants).  The applicants own the only unit in the tower which occupies more than one level, namely all of level 15 and part of level 16, which is the top level and which also contains a lift and services block and a deck.

  3. The dispute is about two issues:  first, the allocation between the owners of the units of the costs incurred by the Body Corporate in carrying out the remedial work; and, second, a claim for compensation by the applicants for loss of use of their unit while the work was being carried out.

  4. The Shangri-La apartments are a unit title development completed in 1987.  The unit plan for the development was deposited under the Unit Titles…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 114424 v LV Trust Holdings Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Body Corporate 114424 v LV Trust Holdings Ltd, heard by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, involves a dispute over the cost allocation and compensation for remedial work carried out on a residential apartment tower in Auckland. The appellant, Body Corporate 114424, representing the majority of unit owners, appeals against the High Court's approval of a scheme drafted by the first respondents, LV Trust Holdings Ltd and KP Trust Holdings Ltd, who own the largest unit in the tower. The scheme allocates the costs of the remedial work, which included recladding part of the building with a glass curtain wall, and provides for compensation for the loss of use of the applicants' unit during the works.

The Court of Appeal, comprising Ellen France, White, and Winkelmann JJ, dismissed the appeal and upheld the High Court's decision. On the cost allocation issue, the Court found that the High Court Judge, Asher J, correctly applied the principles established in Tisch v Body Corporate No 318596, which outline the criteria for approving a scheme under the Unit Titles Act 2010. The Court agreed with Asher J's conclusion that the applicants' scheme, which proposed a 50/50 split between equal sharing and utility interest basis for certain costs, achieved fairness between the unit owners and was an appropriate solution to the costs allocation problem.

Regarding the compensation issue, the Court of Appeal upheld the High Court's decision to award compensation to the applicants for the period their unit was inaccessible due to the remedial work. The Court found that the High Court had jurisdiction under s 74(7)(b) of the Act to order compensation in an appropriate case and that it was equitable to compensate the applicants for their significant loss of use of their unit for a longer period than the other unit owners.

As a result, the appeal is dismissed, and the Body Corporate is ordered to pay the applicants' costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established