Hannam v Body Corporate 126001

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA779/2023
 [2024] NZCA 274

BETWEEN

GARY KEITH HANNAM AND PATRICIA JOY DRAPER
Appellants

AND

BODY CORPORATE 126001 & ORS
Respondents

(See Schedule A for complete list of Respondents)

Hearing:

22 and 23 May 2024

Court:

Wylie, Lang and Campbell JJ

Counsel:

D R Bigio KC, S N Zellman and G B Lewis for Appellants
J B Orpin-Dowell and T J G Allan for First Respondent
No appearance by or for Second to 50th and 52nd to 54th Respondents
E D Nilsson and K L Calder for 51st Respondent

Judgment:

27 June 2024 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

B    The appellants are to pay costs to each of the first and the 51st respondents for a standard appeal on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.  We certify for second counsel. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Wylie J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction
Background

The Western Park apartment complex
The application for a scheme

The High Court judgment
The notice of appeal
Submissions

For the trustees
For the Body Corporate
For the Subsidiary Body Corporate

Issues on appeal
Analysis
Section 74
The nature of an appeal against the exercise of the s 74(2) and (7) discretion
The Body Corporate’s proposed scheme
The 2019 settlement

The relevance of the 2019 settlement
The Judge’s findings in relation to the 2019 settlement
Was it open to the trustees to challenge the Judge’s finding that there was no material change in circumstances?
The alleged change in circumstances
Did the Judge err in finding that there had been no material change in circumstances and that the trustees remained bound by the 2019 settlement?
The s 74 discretion

Did the Judge err in settling the terms of the scheme?

The cost allocation provisions
The correct approach — relevant principles
The unit plan — unit property versus common property
The limits of the damage
The UTA 1972
The UTA 2010
The position of the unit A owners
The conduct of the trustees
The Body Corporate’s scheme — unanimous support
The Judge’s conclusion

The trustees’ proposed schemes

The trustees’ schemes
Was it open to the Judge to adopt the trustees’ schemes?
Did the Judge err in her consideration of the trustees’ schemes?
A fire safety investigation?

Conclusion
Costs
Result

[1]
[6]
[7]
[10]
[12]
[27]
[28]
[28]
[34]
[38]
[41]
[45]
[45]

[51]
[54]
[64]
[64]
[68]

[70]
[77]

[83]
[88]
[94]
[94]
[97]
[105]
[109]
[111]
[116]
[126]
[134]
[139]
[140]
[141]
[142]
[147]

[153]
[157]
[166]
[168]
[169]

Introduction

  1. The appellants, Gary Hannam and Patricia Draper (jointly the trustees), are the trustees of the GK Hannam Family Trust.  In that capacity, they own the penthouse unit, unit 900, in a residential apartment complex in Freemans Bay, Auckland (the Western Park apartment complex).  The complex leaks, largely from a deck surrounding unit 900.[1]   

    [1]Unit 900 is referred to as unit Q on the unit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hannam v Body Corporate 126001 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 274
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hannam v Body Corporate 126001 dealt with a dispute regarding the terms of a proposed scheme concerning the management of a building under the Unit Titles Act 2010 (UTA 2010). The Body Corporate sought to implement a scheme that would address various issues with the building, including the repair and maintenance of the structure. The trustees of a unit within the building challenged the proposed scheme, arguing that it was unfair and did not adequately address the interests of all unit owners. The primary issues for the court to determine were whether the contractual agreement between the trustees and the Body Corporate had been frustrated, whether the trustees' alternative schemes should be considered, and the fairness of the cost allocations proposed by both parties.

The court found that the contractual agreement between the trustees and the Body Corporate had not been frustrated, and therefore, the trustees were still obligated to consent to the Body Corporate’s proposed scheme. Additionally, the court ruled that the trustees' alternative schemes could not be considered because they had not been properly served on all respondents. In examining the fairness of the proposed scheme, the court determined that the Body Corporate had met the burden of proof, and the scheme was fair and practical. The court further held that the trustees' cost allocation was not equitable and that there was no basis for other proposed amendments. The court concluded that the scheme proposed by the Body Corporate achieved fairness among all unit owners and was an appropriate framework for addressing current and potential issues with the building.

In light of these findings, the court exercised its discretion under section 74 of the UTA 2010 to order the scheme in the terms proposed by the Body Corporate. The trustees appealed certain aspects of the scheme, specifically the allocation of costs for repairs to unit 900 and the costs associated with "mothballing" the unit, as well as the absence of a condition requiring an investigation into the cladding system. The appeal focused on the alleged unfairness of the cost allocation and the need for a broader investigation into the building's structural integrity. The court ultimately upheld the decision to implement the Body Corporate's proposed scheme, rejecting the trustees' arguments that it was unfair and did not adequately balance the interests of all unit owners.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Judge summarised her decision as follows:Summary of decision[383] The contract between the Body Corporate and the [t]rustees, pursuant to which the [t]rustees agreed to consent to a scheme in the same terms as the scheme before the Court, has not been frustrated. The [t]rustees remain contractually bound to consent to the Body Corporate’s proposed scheme. It is, therefore, not open to the [t]rustees to oppose the scheme proposed by the Body Corporate.[384] In the alternative, it is not open to the Court to consider the two alternative schemes proposed by the [t]rustees as they were not served on all respondents.[385] In case I am wrong in my decisions in [383] and [384] above, I have considered the terms of the Body Corporate’s proposed scheme as applied for and the [t]rustees’ two proposed schemes.[386] There are no grounds for appointing an administrator and the [t]rustees’ cost allocation is not fair as between unit owners. Nor is there a basis for other amendments proposed by the [t]rustees.[387] The Body Corporate has satisfied the burden of proof as regards the terms of its proposed scheme. It achieves fairness between all unit owners. The scheme is a fair and practical framework for addressing current and potential issues with the building.[388] I will exercise my discretion under s 74 of the [UTA 2010] to order a scheme in the terms as applied for by the Body Corporate. The trustee’s notice of appeal raised the following matters:(a)The Judge’s findings as to the effect of the 2019 settlement between the trustees and the Body Corporate.(b)The Judge’s findings as to the fairness of the Body Corporate’s cost allocation.(c)The Judge’s findings in respect of the trustees’ cost allocation.(d)The Judge’s finding that the trustees’ request for an urgent investigation into fire safety concerns should not be included in the scheme.(e)The Judge’s findings that the terms of the scheme proposed by the Body Corporate are appropriate and that the costs associated with the deglazing and wrap of unit 900 are payable by the trustees under the scheme.(f)The orders made by the Judge. Mr Bigio KC, appearing for the trustees, confirmed that the trustees wish to have their apartment reinstated and that they support the settling of a scheme under s 74 of the UTA 2010. He made it clear that their appeal is limited to the following aspects of the scheme settled by the Court:(a)the requirement that the trustees pay for all of the direct (and indirect) costs of repair to unit 900;(b)the requirement that the trustees pay the costs of “mothballing” unit 900; and(c)the lack of any condition requiring an investigation of the cladding system, as recommended by Mr Olsson. Mr Bigio referred to Tisch. He discussed the five guiding principles set out by this Court and he analysed the nature of the Court’s discretion, commenting that the Court is required to balance the interests of each owner to achieve the fairest outcome for all unit owners. He submitted that the Body Corporate’s proposed scheme is unfair to the trustees and that the fact that other owners support it is not determinative. He argued that the courts have recognised that it is in the interests of all owners that the exterior of multi-tenanted buildings is kept in good repair and watertight. He noted that levels 9 and 10, including the deck surrounding unit 900, form a roof over the rest of the Western Park apartment complex and he argued that resolution of the watertightness issues on levels 9 and 10 is in the interests of all owners. He put it to us that the Judge failed to identify and balance the interests of all owners as required by Tisch and that the Judge departed from the scheme of the UTA 2010. He also argued that the scheme inappropriately attributes the costs of mothballing the trustees’ unit entirely to them, despite the fact that the mothballing was and still is in the interests of all owners.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.