McIntyre v Body Corporate 80146

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2023-485-206

[2023] NZHC 3701

BETWEEN

MICHAEL DAVID MCINTYRE

Applicant

AND

BODY CORPORATE 80146

Respondent

Hearing: 29 November 2023 with further written submissions on 11 December 2023

Appearances:

P W Michalik for the Applicant

D C Calder and C P S Tatley for the Respondent

Judgment:

14 December 2023


JUDGMENT OF PALMER J


Counsel/Solicitors

P W Michalik, Barrister, Wellington Whitcombe Law, Dunedin

Gibson Sheat, Wellington

MCINTYRE v BODY CORPORATE 80146 [2023] NZHC 3701 [14 December 2023]

What happened?

Unit 14

[1]                  Mr Michael McIntyre owns Unit 14 (also known as Unit C) in the residential unit title development at 313 The Terrace, in central Wellington, managed by Body Corporate 80146 (the Body Corporate). Unit 14 is a stand-alone house of a different character and construction than the other units. For reasons which are not clear, it has been allocated an ownership interest of 1.38 per cent in the development. By contrast, comparable units 15 and 16 have an allocated ownership interest of 14.17 per cent and

13.77 per cent respectively. On the basis of the current rating valuation of the units, Unit 14 is 12.46 per cent of the total value of the units, compared to 12.02 per cent each for Units 15 and 16. The proportion of the ownership interest flows through to the proportion of levies assessed and the level of voting power in the event of a poll of the Body Corporate. Unit 14 has also recently been repaired for leaks.

The Resolutions

[2]                  On 8 August 2022, the agenda and proposed motions for the 2022 Annual General Meeting (AGM) of the Body Corporate were circulated to unit owners. These included two motions proposed as special resolutions (the Resolutions):

8that the body corporate approves a new method of apportionment of utility interests as presented by the committee.

9that the body corporate reviews the Utility Interests for each unit using the new method and assigns to each unit the new interest or interests.

[3]                  The Resolutions were omitted from the postal voting form sent out with the Agenda and Notice of Proposed Motions. The objective of the Resolutions appears to have been to obtain what the Body Corporate Committee (the Committee) considered to be a more equitable contribution of costs, largely insurance costs, between the units. Before the Resolutions were proposed, the status quo was that the utility interests were based on the ownership interests. The Committee proposed the cost of the insurance premium be shared based on proportion of estimated reinstatement costs. Unit 14’s share of the total replacement value was set at 19.06 per cent. Unit 14’s share of the utilities interest was set at 8.3 per cent.

[4]                  The 2022 AGM was held on 22 August 2022. The draft minutes, that were prepared and issued after the meeting, record the unit holders present or voting by proxy (11 out of 15) as voting unanimously for resolution 9 which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McIntyre v Body Corporate 80146 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 3701
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Michael McIntyre, sought to have a resolution of the Body Corporate 80146, which had reallocated the utility interests for the units in a residential unit title development, set aside on the basis it was procedurally and substantively unfair. The Body Corporate had initially passed two special resolutions to approve a new method of apportionment of utility interests and to review the utility interests of each unit. These resolutions were not included in the postal voting form and the minutes of the meeting only recorded one ordinary resolution being passed. The Body Corporate subsequently passed a designated resolution that recorded the two special resolutions being passed. The applicant sought to have this resolution set aside. The court held that the procedural deficiencies in the passing of the resolutions were egregious, and it was just and equitable to overturn the designated resolution. The court also held that overturning the resolution was just and equitable in terms of the substance of the situation, including for all unit owners. The court set aside the resolution, directed the Body Corporate to obtain the valuation reports necessary to update the registered ownership interests and to update them, and awarded costs to the applicant. The court indicated it was inclined to award increased costs of 25 per cent because of the Body Corporate’s unnecessary contribution to the time and expense of the proceeding.

The court in this case considered whether it was just and equitable to set aside a resolution of a Body Corporate that had reallocated the utility interests for the units in a residential unit title development. The court found that there were significant procedural deficiencies in the passing of the resolutions, and it was just and equitable to overturn the resolution. The court also considered the substantive fairness of the resolution, and held that it was just and equitable to set it aside because the Body Corporate was prepared to reassess the ownership interests, which would provide an equitable baseline between the unit holders. The court set aside the resolution, directed the Body Corporate to update the registered ownership interests, and awarded costs to the applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established