LV Trust Holdings Ltd v Body Corporate 114424

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-008245 [2012] NZHC 3578

UNDER  Section 74 of the Unit Titles Act 2010

BETWEEN  LV TRUST HOLDINGS LIMITED AND KP TRUST HOLDINGS LIMITED Applicants

ANDBODY CORPORATE 114424 & OTHERS First to Twenty-first Respondents

Hearing:         5-6 November 2012

Counsel:         NR Campbell for Applicants

D Bigio and V Toan for Respondents

Judgment:      20 December 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASHER J

This judgment was delivered by me on Thursday, 20 December 2012 at 1pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

NR Campbell, PO Box 4338, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140. Email:  ncampbell@shortlandchambers.co.nz

ASCO Agmen-Smith & Co, PO Box 3596, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140.

Email:  miles.as@ascolegal.co.nz
D Bigio, PO Box 4338, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140. Email:  dbigio@shortlandchambers.co.nz

Glaister Ennor, DX CX 10236, Auckland. Email:  Vicki.toan@glaister.co.nz

LV TRUST HOLDINGS LIMITED AND KP TRUST HOLDINGS LIMITED V BODY CORPORATE 114424

& OTHERS HC AK CIV-2011-404-008245 [20 December 2012]

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1] The legal framework  [12] The cost allocation

The different approaches  [24]

Relevant facts to cost allocation  [29] Approach  [42] What does the scheme of the Act and the rules/regulations indicate?               [49] Analysis  [58] A fair solution  [65]

Compensation

Background  [69]

Analysis  [79]

Result  [87]

Introduction

[1]      In 1987 a 17 level residential tower, the Shangri La apartments, was erected on Jervois Road, Ponsonby.  It was a unit title development.

[2]      By 2010 the building was leaking.  The unit owners resolved by majority to carry out the work required to make the building weather proof.  This included re- cladding the building with a glass curtain. This work has been done.

[3]      The applicants own unit 15.  They seek approval of a scheme drafted by them under s 74 of the Unit Titles Act 2010.  A proposed scheme is attached to the originating application.   The first to twenty-first respondents include the Body Corporate (“Body Corporate 114424”) and the other owners and some mortgagees.

[4]      The Body Corporate has now filed its own proposed scheme for which it seeks approval under s 74.  It and the other unit owner respondents support that scheme and oppose the applicant’s scheme.  The mortgagees of Shangri La abide the decision of the Court providing their interests are protected.

[5]      There are two particular issues between the parties that I am asked to rule on in an interim decision.

[6]      The first issue is one of cost allocation between units.   It is the applicants’ argument that part of the remedial work applies to common property and part of it to unit property.  They say that the cost of the building work to property for which a unit owner is responsible should be borne by that unit owner, and that it is fair to attribute half of the cost of the overall building work to the unit owners.  Thus, the scheme proposed by the applicants contains a provision that in respect of all the remedial work, 50 per cent of a one-fifteenth share of the total cost…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LV Trust Holdings Ltd v Body Corporate 114424 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3578
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

LV Trust Holdings Ltd v Body Corporate 114424 was a case in the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, which involved a dispute between the applicants, LV Trust Holdings Limited and KP Trust Holdings Limited, and the respondents, Body Corporate 114424 and other unit owners. The dispute centred on the cost allocation of the remedial works required to make the Shangri La residential tower weatherproof, as well as the issue of compensation for the applicants who lost the use of their unit for an extended period during the building works. The court had to decide on two primary issues: the cost allocation between units and the payment of compensation to the applicants.

In terms of cost allocation, the applicants argued that the cost of the building work should be borne by the unit owners, with 50 per cent of the cost attributed to the unit owners and the other 50 per cent apportioned according to the utility interest for each unit. The respondents, on the other hand, argued that all the costs should be borne by all unit owners on a utility interest basis. The court considered the scheme of the Unit Titles Act 2010 and the Body Corporate rules, as well as the guiding principles of balancing the interests of each unit holder. The court found that the applicants' proposal, which would result in a fairer cost allocation for the unit owners, was more in line with the intent of the Act and the Body Corporate rules.

Regarding the issue of compensation, the applicants sought compensation for the period of the loss of use of their unit that exceeded six weeks, as they were deprived of access to their property for 18 months, whereas other unit owners only had to put up with a period of approximately five weeks. The court found that while the Act and the rules were silent on the issue of compensation, there was no barrier to a compensatory award where it was patent that compensation was necessary to do equity between unit owners. The court concluded that the loss of a valuable home for 17 months was undoubtedly a significant event, and granted the applicants' claim for compensation.

In conclusion, the court found in favour of the applicants on both issues in contention and indicated that it would approve clauses 9.2(a) and 10.2 relating to those two issues in the applicants' proposed scheme. The case was decided on an interim basis, with leave to apply for approval of a final scheme reserved to both parties. Costs on this hearing were also reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established