Zantran Pty Limited v Crown Resorts Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Zantran Pty Limited v Crown Resorts Limited [2019] FCA 641

File number: VID 1317 of 2017
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 8 May 2019
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceeding – potential witnesses in proceeding subject to contractual confidentiality obligations – application for orders allowing applicant’s solicitors to confer with potential witnesses – public interest – whether court should decline to enforce confidentiality obligations on the ground that the relevant clauses have a tendency to interfere adversely with the administration of justice – application granted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where most potential witnesses signed deeds on termination of employment including additional confidentiality obligations – application for suppression or non-publication orders – whether necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice under s 37AG – application refused

Legislation:

Access to Justice (Civil Litigation Reforms) Amendment Act 2009 (Cth)

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)

Civil Procedure Act 2010 (Vic)

Cases cited:

A v Hayden (1984) 156 CLR 532; [1984] HCA 67

AG Australia Holdings Ltd v Burton (2002) 58 NSWLR 464; [2002] NSWSC 170

AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27

AS v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and Others (Ruling No 6) (2016) 53 VR 631; [2016] VSC 774

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coal Pty Ltd (No 4) [2018] FCA 1243

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Valve Corporation (No 5) [2016] FCA 741

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Richards [2013] FCAFC 89

Axon v Axon (1937) 59 CLR 395

Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon “Mikhail Lermontov” (1991) 22 NSWLR 1

Bianca Hope Rinehart v Georgina Hope Rinehart [2014] FCA 1241

Brand v Monks [2009] NSWSC 1454

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Cannon v Griffiths & Ors (No 2) [2015] NSWSC 1329

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Cooke [2000] 1 Qd R 7

Commonwealth v Sanofi (formerly Sanofi-Aventis) [2017] FCA 382

Computer Interchange Pty Ltd v Microsoft Corporation (1999) 88 FCR 438; [1999] FCA 198

Corrs Pavey Whiting and Byrne v Collector of Customs (Vic) (1987) 14 FCR 434

Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR 303; [2013] HCA 46

Gartside v Outram (1856) 26 LJ Ch (NS) 113

Harmony Shipping Co SA v Saudi Europe Line Ltd [1979] 1 WLR 1380

Hogan v Australian Crime Commission (2009) 177 FCR 205; [2009] FCAFC 71

Hogan v Australian Crime Commission (2010) 240 CLR 651; [2010] HCA 21

Initial Services Ltd v Putterill [1968] 1 QB 396

John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v District Court (NSW) (2004) 61 NSWLR 344; [2004] NSWCA 324

Johnson v AED Oil Ltd [2011] VSC 94

Jones v Treasury Wine Estates Ltd (2016) 241 FCR 111; [2016] FCAFC 59

Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liquidation)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zantran Pty Limited v Crown Resorts Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 641
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Zantran Pty Limited v Crown Resorts Limited, the primary issue was whether the Federal Court should grant an application by Zantran to allow its solicitors to confer with potential witnesses who were subject to contractual confidentiality obligations. The court also considered whether it should make suppression or non-publication orders to prevent the disclosure of certain information. The legal issues revolved around the balance between the public interest in maintaining contractual confidentiality and the need for open justice and the efficient administration of justice. The court had to decide whether the confidentiality obligations should be enforced in a way that would potentially interfere with the administration of justice.

The Federal Court found that the public interest in the fair, quick, inexpensive, and efficient administration of justice outweighed the public interest in maintaining the contractual obligations of confidence between Crown and its former employees. The court held that it was appropriate to decline to enforce the confidentiality obligations to the extent and for the limited purposes of the orders sought by Zantran. The court emphasised the importance of the overarching purpose of facilitating the just resolution of disputes according to law and as quickly, inexpensively, and efficiently as possible, as mandated by section 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The court concluded that the orders should be made to allow Zantran's solicitors to confer with the former employees and to provide witness statements or outlines of evidence in the proceeding.

The court also dismissed Crown's application for a suppression or non-publication order, finding that the submissions did not establish a proper basis for such orders. The court noted that section 37AE of the Act required it to treat the public interest in open justice as a primary consideration. The court held that the suppression or non-publication orders sought by Crown were not necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice. The court made orders relieving the named former employees of any obligations of confidence owed to Crown for the limited purposes of conferring with Zantran's legal representatives and providing witness statements or outlines of evidence. The court also vacated the interim suppression and non-publication order previously made.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The persons listed in Appendix “A” are, for the limited purposes of:

(a) conferring with the Applicant’s legal representatives and providing a witness statement or an outline of evidence in this proceeding; and/or

(b) providing to the Applicant’s legal representatives any document produced by the prosecution or the Baoshan District Court in the People’s Republic of China in connection with their criminal prosecution and conviction in China;

relieved of any obligations of confidence owed by them to the Respondent.

2. The Respondent’s application for a suppression or non-publication order under sections 37AF and 37AG of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) be dismissed. The interim suppression and non-publication order made on 20 November 2018 be vacated.

3. The costs of this application be costs in the cause.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Appendix “A”

1. Jiang Ling (also known as Jenny Jiang);

2. Yaohui Gaomu (also known as Alfread Gomez);

3. Wang Xun;

4. Liu Yuanzheng (also known as Lucent Liu);

5. Zhu Bing (also known as Jack Zhu);

6. Wu Xuefen (also known as Carol Wu);

7. Tao Yin (also known as Teresa Tao);

8. He Xi (also known as Jessie He);

9. Xiong Bin (also known as Benny Xiong);

10. Dai Bin (also known as David Dai);

11. Jia Qi (also known as Herbert Jia);

12. Pan Dan (also known as Jane Pan);

13. Xuan Peng (also known as Jerry Xuan);

14. Chi Yang (also known as Edison Chi);

15. Cao Zhiqiang (also known as Frank Cao);

16. Liu Xiaolei (also known as Leo Liu);

17. Tang Xiaoquing (also known as Athena Tang); and

18. Cao Xiaoyu (also known as Fiona Cai)

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons I explain, and particularly having regard to the obligation of the Court under s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA) to exercise its powers in a way that best promotes the overarching purpose of facilitating the just resolution of disputes according to law and as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible, I am satisfied that in the particular circumstances of the case it is appropriate to make the orders Zantran seeks. There is power to make such orders under ss 21, 23, 37P and 33ZF of the FCA and doing so is consistent with the overarching purpose. There is a public interest in the fair, quick, inexpensive and efficient administration of justice and in my opinion, if the orders are not made, it may have a serious adverse effect on the administration of justice. This outweighs the public interest in maintaining the contractual obligations of confidence between Crown and its former employees, and it is appropriate to decline to enforce those obligations, but only to the extent and for the limited purposes of the orders sought. THE FACTS This summary of the relevant facts is drawn from matters which are admitted in the pleadings and from the affidavit evidence filed in the application. I set them out for the purposes of this application only and they should not be taken as factual findings for the substantive proceeding.The pleadings Crown is a publicly listed corporation carrying on a business as one of Australia’s largest gaming and entertainment groups, with operations and investments in Australia, Asia, the United Kingdom and the United States. During the relevant period Crown had 100% ownership of the Crown Melbourne casino and hotel resort (Crown Melbourne), and the Crown Perth casino and hotel resort (Crown Perth). Crown also had an equity stake of between approximately 33.6% and 27.4% in Melco Crown Entertainment which owned and operated casinos in Macau and the Philippines. During the relevant period the customers at Crown Melbourne and Crown Perth included customers who travelled to Australia from other countries, who placed bets in the private gaming rooms of those casinos, were extended credit by Crown to do so including through arrangements known as “rolling chips” with which to gamble, and whom Crown assisted by organising visas and travel plans and providing benefits, including accommodation, meals and refreshments while they were in Australia (Crown’s international VIP gamblers), who I sometimes describe as Chinese “high roller” gamblers. Crown’s China Operations Crown’s international VIP gamblers included Chinese nationals from mainland China (Chinese VIP gamblers). It is uncontroversial that in the period between 2014 and October 2016, at least 19 employees of Crown Resort Pte Ltd (Crown Pte) (a Singaporean subsidiary of Crown Australia Pty Ltd which is a subsidiary of Crown Melbourne Limited which is in turn a subsidiary of Crown) variously performed functions and tasks for Crown’s benefit on mainland China. Although they were employed by Crown Pte rather than Crown itself, for convenience I refer to them as “Crown employees”). Zantran alleges that their functions and tasks in China included:(a)sales, marketing and administrative tasks in teams organised by reference to the regions of China;(b)meeting with Chinese nationals for the purpose of promoting gambling at Crown Melbourne, Crown Perth and Crown Macau casinos;(c)providing assistance to Chinese nationals with arranging travel from mainland China to Australia for the purpose of gambling at Crown Melbourne and Crown Perth and providing assistance with visa applications;(d)organising for Chinese nationals who travelled from mainland China to Australia for the purpose of gambling at Crown Melbourne and Crown Perth to be provided with accommodation, meals and refreshments while in Australia;(e)organising credit for Chinese nationals to use for gambling at Crown Melbourne, Crown Perth and Crown Macau;(f)reporting the results of the sales and marketing performed by Crown employees in China; and (g)contacting Chinese nationals who had engaged in gambling at Crown Melbourne, Crown Perth and Crown Macau casinos for the purpose of requesting those Chinese nationals to pay debts incurred while gambling: (Crown’s China Operations). Crown essentially admits the functions and tasks engaged in by these employees but says in relation to subparagraphs (b), (c) and (d) that the meetings and assistance were engaged in with respect to either individual or small numbers of Chinese nationals and it does not admit the alleged purposes of gambling or promoting gambling. Crown also admits that from time to time employees of Crown Pte, Crown Melbourne Limited and Crown travelled to China and met with actual or prospective Chinese VIP gamblers.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Crown denies that it made the representations alleged and it denies that it engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct or conduct which was likely to mislead or deceive.The affidavit evidence Zantran relies on four affidavits by Mr Andrew Watson, a principal at Maurice Blackburn Lawyers, the solicitors for Zantran, made 26 September 2018, 30 October 2018, 9 November 2018 and 18 January 2019 (respectively the First, Second, Third and Fourth Watson Affidavits). Crown relies on an affidavit by Mr Glen Ward, a partner at Minter Ellison, the solicitors for Crown, made 7 November 2018. Neither Mr Watson nor Mr Ward were cross examined.The application for a suppression or non-publication order Crown seeks a suppression or non-publication order for a period of five years from the date of the orders, subject to any further order of the Court, that the following information be marked “confidential” on the electronic Court file and its contents not be accessed by anyone other than the parties and not be published by any person:(a)paragraphs 14, 15 and 17 of Mr Ward’s affidavit;(b)paragraph 13 of Crown’s submissions dated 7 November 2018; and(c)paragraph 6 of Crown’s submissions dated 21 November 2018.Each of the relevant paragraphs sets out a confidentiality term in the Finalisation Deeds signed by each of the former Crown employees except for Ms Jiang (and Mr Chen who instead signed a Separation Deed). Crown submits, and I accept, that there is a public interest in holding parties to their contractual bargains, including contractual obligations to maintain confidentiality. It contends, and I accept, that this public interest is relevant to the Court’s determination of whether to make the suppression or non-publication order sought. Crown argues that, having regard to the express obligations of confidence contained in the Finalisation Deeds, entered into by persons who are not parties to the proceedings, the Court should make the suppression or non-publication orders it seeks. It describes the orders sought as being of limited scope and duration and as appropriate and necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice. I do not accept Crown’s submissions. In my view its submissions fell well short of establishing a proper basis for the suppression or non-publication orders it seeks. I commence by noting that:(a)section 37AF of the FCA provides that the Court may make a suppression or non-publication order only “on grounds permitted by this Part”;(b)section 37AG sets out the available grounds. Crown relies solely on s 37AG(1)(a), being that such an order “is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice” (emphasis added); and(c)section 37AE provides that in deciding whether to make a suppression or non-publication order the Court “must take into account that a primary objective of the administration of justice is to safeguard the public interest in open justice.” While this requirement does not inevitably lead to the rejection of non-publication or suppression orders, the Court is obliged by s 37AE to treat the public interest in open justice as a primary consideration: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coal Pty Ltd (No 4) [2018] FCA 1243 at [44] (Foster J). Section 37AE reflects the well-recognised importance of open justice, described as “one of the most fundamental aspects of the system of justice in Australia”: John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v District Court (NSW) (2004) 61 NSWLR 344; [2004] NSWCA 324 at [18] (Spigelman CJ).

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to the former Crown employees other than Ms Jiang and Mr Chen, Crown’s opposition to the application is partly based on the contention that there is no recent compelling evidence that any of them would be willing to give evidence on behalf of Zantran. In circumstances where Mr Sikkema apparently did not provide a basis for his statement that they are prepared to give evidence, that submission is not entirely without force. I have given consideration to:(a)making a direction (to the extent necessary) to allow Zantran’s legal representatives to contact each such former employee (other than Ms Jiang and Mr Chen) to ascertain whether he or she is willing to give evidence, but not to make orders to facilitate their making a witness statement at that point; and (b)upon Zantran’s legal representatives filing an affidavit stating that they had been expressly advised that the former employee was willing to give evidence, making the orders Zantran seeks for each such person.In the finish I have not taken that course. Having regard to the view I have reached on the merits of the application, I consider the quicker, less expensive and more efficient course is to make the orders Zantran seeks. The process is no less fair because it is entirely voluntary and those former Crown employees that do not wish to confer with Zantran’s legal representatives may decline to do so. The orders will have no impact in relation to those former employees who do not wish to make a witness statement.CONCLUSION For these reasons I consider the orders should be made. In my view, except in relation to Mr Chen, allowing enforcement of the former Crown employees’ contractual obligations of confidence is likely to have a seriously adverse effect on the administration of justice. In the circumstances of the case the public interest in the just resolution of disputes according to law and as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible outweighs the public interest in maintaining the former employees’ obligations of confidence. I have made orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Zantran alleges that on and from 6 February 2015, being the date of the Chinese government crackdown (or in the alternative on and from 17 June 2015, being the date when South Korean casino employees were detained):(a)Crown’s China Operations were in breach of the Chinese criminal law (the China Operations Illegal Information); and/or(b)Crown’s China Operations possessed characteristics which were a target of the Chinese government gambling crackdown announced in the 6 February 2015 Announcement (the China Operations Crackdown Information).Crown denies that in the relevant period its operations in China were in breach of Chinese law and denies that its operations possessed characteristics which were a target of the Chinese government crackdown. Zantran pleads that on and from 6 February 2015 (or in the alternative on and from 19 June 2015) there existed a risk that: (a)Crown employees would be arrested, detained, charged, prosecuted or convicted by Chinese authorities for commission of crimes in contravention of Chinese laws in relation to gambling (Employee Detention Risk); (b)if that risk came to fruition Crown would be forced to terminate its China operations (China Operations Enforcement Risk);(c)if Crown terminated its China operations it would suffer a significant reduction in the revenue gained from Chinese VIP gamblers (Chinese VIP Revenue Risk); and (d)if there was a significant reduction in the revenue achieved from Chinese VIP gamblers, Crown would suffer a significant reduction in its total revenue (Revenue Risk). Crown denies that any such risks existed. Zantran pleads that on and from 6 February 2015 (or in the alternative 19 June 2015) Crown was aware (within the meaning of the ASX Listing Rule 19.12) of the China Operations Illegal Information, China Operations Crackdown Information, Employee Detention Risk, China Operations Enforcement Risk, Chinese VIP Revenue Risk and the Revenue Risk. Crown denies that such risks existed and denies that it was aware of such risks within the meaning of ASX Listing Rule 19.12.The allegations of breach of the continuous disclosure regime and misleading conduct Zantran pleads that on and from 6 February 2015 (or in the alternative on and from 19 June 2015):(a)the China Operations Illegal Information, China Operations Crackdown Information, Employee Detention Risk, China Operations Enforcement Risk, Chinese VIP Revenue Risk and the Revenue Risk was information that a reasonable person would expect to have a material effect on the price or value of Crown shares within the meaning of ASX Listing Rule 3.1 and s 674(2)(c)(ii) of the Corporations Act, and was not generally available;(b)Crown was therefore obliged to immediately tell the ASX of the alleged information and alleged risks;(c)Crown did not tell the ASX at any stage during the relevant period;(d)the ASX did not become aware of that information and those risks until Crown’s 17 October 2016 Announcement; and(e)Crown thereby contravened s 674(2).