Wright v N & E Enterprises Pty Ltd and Alh Group Pty Ltd No. DCCIV-01-697

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

WRIGHT v N & E ENTERPRISES PTY LTD AND
ALH GROUP PTY LTD
[2003] SADC 103

Judge Rice
Civil

Introduction

  1. This is a claim by the plaintiff for damages arising from an incident in the car‑park of the Ramsgate Hotel, Henley Beach, on Thursday, 20th January, 2000.  Both liability and quantum are in dispute.  The second defendant, ALH Group Pty Ltd (“the hotel”), was the licensee and manager of the Ramsgate Hotel at the relevant time.

  2. The facts of the case are referred to in detail below.  Briefly put, the facts are as follows.  The plaintiff, Ms Lorraine Wright, and her partner of some 16 years, Mr John Hoppe, were guests at the Ramsgate Hotel.  On the morning of 20th January, 2000 they decided to check out of the hotel and commence their return journey to Melbourne.  This was a day earlier than they had originally planned to leave.  Their car was parked in that part of the car-park of the hotel that is normally set aside for patrons of the bottle shop.

  3. On that morning there was a mobile crane operating in the car-park.  The hotel was undergoing some renovations and the mobile crane was necessary to lift air‑conditioning ducts on to the roof of the hotel for later installation.  The first defendant, N & E Enterprises Pty Ltd (“the crane company”), was the operator of the mobile crane.  The mobile crane was of such a size that it had four stabiliser bars or legs that came out from the sides to render it stable when in use.  The position of the crane and its stabilisers was such that Mr Hoppe was unable to move or drive the car from the car-park until the crane was finished and had left.

  4. On the case for the plaintiff, she and Mr Hoppe were told that the work with the crane had been completed and that they could access their car for the purpose of loading their belongings.  Once the crane had moved, they would then be able to move the car itself.

  5. Mr Hoppe had earlier seen the crane in use.  When the lifting was taking place the rear of the crane, its counterweight, swung over Mr Hoppe’s car with a clearance of only about six inches to eight inches (TP219).  Having been told they could put luggage and the like in the car, Mr Hoppe took a number of items to the car-park.  He made a number of trips.  On one of those trips he opened the car and lifted the rear hatch.  The height of the hatch in that position was such that it would be struck by the counterweight of the crane if the crane was operated as it had been earlier.  Mr Hoppe commenced loading items in via the hatch believing, as he had been told, that the job was done.  He crawled into the back of the car to push items against the back of the front seats.  It was only a two-door car with flat…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wright v N & E Enterprises Pty Ltd and Alh Group Pty Ltd No.... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lorraine Wright sued N & E Enterprises Pty Ltd and ALH Group Pty Ltd for damages after she suffered a psychiatric injury when the counterweight of a mobile crane struck the boot of her car in the car-park of the Ramsgate Hotel, Henley Beach. The plaintiff was a guest at the hotel and was attempting to load her belongings into the car when the incident occurred. The defendants were the operator of the crane and the licensee and manager of the hotel respectively. Both defendants were liable to the plaintiff in negligence. The crane company was 80 per cent liable and the hotel 20 per cent liable. The Court awarded the plaintiff $448,378.24 in damages.