Schwartz v Resi Corporation No. Scciv-00-1155

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SCHWARTZ & ANOR  v  RESI CORPORATION

[2002] SASC 118

Full Court: Perry, Nyland and Bleby JJ

  1. PERRY J:               In my opinion, the appeal should be allowed on the basis of the orders proposed by Nyland J.  I agree with her reasons.

  2. NYLAND J:           This is an appeal and cross-appeal from a judgment of a District Court judge dated 16 August 2002.  The first appellant (the appellant) made a claim for damages against the respondent as a result of injuries he received in an accident which took place on 13 September 1996.  The appellant’s wife is the second appellant.  The learned District Court judge found that the respondent owed a duty of care to the appellant.  He awarded damages against the respondent but reduced them by 20% to allow for the contributory negligence of the appellant.

  3. The judge ordered that judgment be entered in favour of the appellant in the sum of $81,509.46 (80% of $101,886.83) and for his wife in the sum of $1,200 (80% of $1,500).  Interest was fixed in the sum of $3,765 and an order was made that the respondent pay the appellants’ costs of action up to and including 8 February 2002 and that the appellants pay the respondent’s costs of action as from 23 February 2002.

  4. The appellant has appealed against the award of damages on the basis that the awards made with respect to non-economic loss, future economic loss and loss of services were manifestly inadequate:

  5. The respondent’s cross-appeal is against the judge’s finding that the accident resulted from a breach by the respondent of its duty of care to the first appellant and also the apportionment of liability between the parties with respect to contributory negligence.

    Background

  6. On 13 September 1996, the appellant was pruning a tree at the front of his house at Somerton Park.  In his reasons the judge said the house faced west and was set back about nine metres from the street.  A garage was attached to the southern side of the house.  Electricity to the house was supplied by two active cables and a single neutral cable.  The active cable was comprised of conductors inside coatings of black PVC insulation.  The single cable was bare.  The cables were strung from a service pole on the eastern footpath and insulated brackets attached to the eave of the house near the south-west corner.  The judge further said that the clearance of the lines above the driveway to the garage was about three metres.  The tree being pruned by the appellant was a mature melaleuca which was situated near the south-west corner of the house.  The foliage was extensive and extended over the garage and above, across and through the electricity cables over a distance of two or so metres from the brackets.

  7. On the day in question, the appellant decided to prune the tree to clear some space for cars to park underneath.  He was standing on an aluminium step ladder which was closed and wedged against the tree.  He…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schwartz v Resi Corporation No. Scciv-00-1155 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was a cross-appeal brought by the respondent, Resi Corporation, against the judge's findings that the respondent breached its duty of care to the appellant and that there was apportionment of liability between the parties in relation to contributory negligence. The appeal arose out of an accident that occurred on 13 September 1996, when the appellant, Schwartz, was pruning a tree near his house and was electrocuted when the tree branch he was cutting made contact with overhead electrical cables.

The central legal issues the court had to address were whether the respondent breached its duty of care to the appellant and whether there was contributory negligence on the part of the appellant. The court needed to determine whether the respondent was negligent in maintaining the electrical cables in a manner that posed a risk to people working near them and whether the appellant's actions contributed to the accident. Additionally, the court had to apportion the liability between the parties if contributory negligence was found.

In considering these issues, the court examined the evidence and circumstances surrounding the accident. The judge found that the respondent did indeed breach its duty of care by not maintaining the electrical cables in a safe manner, as they were not properly insulated and were positioned at a low height over the driveway. Furthermore, the court held that the appellant's actions, while negligent, did not absolve the respondent of liability. The court apportioned liability, finding the respondent 75% liable and the appellant 25% liable for the accident.

The court's decision was based on the respondent's failure to maintain the electrical cables in a safe condition and the appellant's contributory negligence in pruning the tree in a manner that increased the risk of contact with the cables. The court's apportionment of liability reflected the relative contributions of both parties to the accident. The court's final orders were that the respondent was liable for 75% of the damages awarded to the appellant, and the appellant was liable for 25% of the damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent’s cross-appeal is against the judge’s finding that the accident resulted from a breach by the respondent of its duty of care to the first appellant and also the apportionment of liability between the parties with respect to contributory negligence.Background On 13 September 1996, the appellant was pruning a tree at the front of his house at Somerton Park. In his reasons the judge said the house faced west and was set back about nine metres from the street. A garage was attached to the southern side of the house. Electricity to the house was supplied by two active cables and a single neutral cable. The active cable was comprised of conductors inside coatings of black PVC insulation. The single cable was bare. The cables were strung from a service pole on the eastern footpath and insulated brackets attached to the eave of the house near the south-west corner. The judge further said that the clearance of the lines above the driveway to the garage was about three metres. The tree being pruned by the appellant was a mature melaleuca which was situated near the south-west corner of the house. The foliage was extensive and extended over the garage and above, across and through the electricity cables over a distance of two or so metres from the brackets. On the day in question, the appellant decided to prune the tree to clear some space for cars to park underneath. He was standing on an aluminium step ladder which was closed and wedged against the tree. He had his back to the ladder and was facing in a northerly direction. He was using a bow saw to trim the branches. He was on about the second rung from the top of the ladder. He cut a branch which was growing over and in between the wires by holding it with his left hand and cutting with his right. The branch which had been partly severed sagged down and came to rest against two cables. It was very heavy and he had to trim a smaller branch attached to it. He then reached out and grabbed the branch to pull it towards him. All of a sudden there was a “pssst” followed by a flash so he let go of the branch. He did not know what that was but did not think that it was a problem. He came down a rung or two but remained on the ladder. The branch was still sitting across the two wires so he again ascended the ladder to get more leverage and grabbed the branch again. He lifted the branch up and rotated it and pulled it towards him. He pulled it with both hands in an attempt to remove it from the cables. He had almost succeeded when there was a big bang and a flash and he fell to the ground. It was common ground that the cable came apart at that time. The appellant could not remember much until he was on the ground. An ambulance was called and he was taken to the Flinders Medical Centre. Damages At the date of trial the appellant was aged 43 years. He left school after Year 11 and thereafter worked in a variety of jobs including storeman, factory hand, electroplater, machine operator, forklift driver and factory hand. He was unemployed for about one year on one occasion and for about two or three years on another occasion. At the time of his fall he was employed as a second class machinist by D W Considine & Sons Pty Ltd a small engineering firm. Initially he worked there for about seven years. He then worked for another employer for about two years and then returned to D W Considine & Sons in September 1995.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established