Woodcock v Woodcock (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 1)

Woodcock & Woodcock (No 2) [2022] FedCFamC1F 173

File number(s): MLC 13421 of 2020
Judgment of: WILSON J
Date of judgment: 30 March 2022
Catchwords:

FAMILY LAW – STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION – proper construction of “property” in s 4(1) of the Family Law Act in the context of applications under s 79 of the Family Law Act – Kennon v Spry considered.

FAMILY LAW – MAJOR COMPLEX FINANCIAL PROCEEDINGS LIST – trial of a preliminary issue.

FAMILY LAW – DISCRETIONARY TRUSTS – whether husband’s rights under four discretionary trusts are “property” – consideration of judicial interpretation of “property” – review of High Court authorities – held, property.

FAMILY LAW – VALUATION – valuation of interests held by husband under four discretionary trusts – whether capable of valuation as a matter of fact and law – Kennon v Spry considerations addressed – held, husband’s interest capable of valuation.

FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – determination of preliminary point, namely whether the husband’s interest in four discretionary trusts are “property” and if so, whether that property is capable of valuation – held, yes.   

Legislation:

Family Law Act 1975 ss. 4 & 79

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021 r 1.06

Cases cited:

Armory v Delamirie [1722] 93 ER 664

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Carey (No 6) (2006) 153 FCR 509

Australian Securities Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Ltd (1993) 177 CLR 485

Bass v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 334

Breen v Williams (1996) 186 CLR 71

Chan v Valmorbida Custodians Pty Ltd [2020] VSC 590

Coley v Danae [2020] WASCA 13

Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) v Donaldson (1927) 39 CLR 539

Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64

Commonwealth v WMC Resources Ltd (1998) 194 CLR 1

Darkinjung Pty Ltd v Darkinjung Local Aboriginal Land Council [2006] NSWSC 1217

Erceg v Erceg  [2017] 1 NZLR 320

Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerfords (1997) 188 CLR 241

Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v Say-Dee Pty Ltd (2007) 230 CLR 89

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v St Helen’s Farms (ACT) Pty Ltd (1981) 146 CLR 336

Fordyce v Ryan [2017] 2 Qd R 240

Gartside v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1968] AC 553

General Steel Industries Inc. v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125

Harris v Dewell (2018) 58 Fam LR 313

Hocking v Director-General of the National Archives of Australia (2020) 94 ALJR 569

Hziao v Fazarri (2020) 94 ALJR 961

In re Gulbenkian’s Settlement [1970] AC 508

In Re Prater (1888) 37 Ch D 481

In the Marriage of Evans (1991) 104 FLR 130

In the Marriage of Hauff (1986) 10 Fam LR 1076

Ingles & Ingles [2019] FamCA 33

Jones v Skinner (1836) 5 LJ Ch 87

Kalls Enterprises Pty Ltd (In liq) v Baloglow (2006) 58 ACSR 63

Kennon v Spry (2008) 238 CLR 366

McPhail v Dalton [1971] AC 424

Minister of State for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Woodcock v Woodcock (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC1F 173
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Woodcock v Woodcock (No 2), the parties were involved in a dispute concerning the valuation of the husband's interests under several trusts. The case was heard in the Family Court of Australia. The husband sought to determine the value of his interests in four trusts, namely The B Trust, The F Trust, The E Trust, and The Mr G (1977) Family Trust. The legal issues that arose included whether the husband's interests in these trusts were capable of valuation and whether they constituted property for the purpose of a proceeding for the alteration of property interests under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

The court considered the expert evidence provided by Mr T, who concluded that the husband's rights were capable of being valued both before and after the amending deeds. The court held that the husband's interests in the trusts were in fact and in law "property" within the meaning of the Act. The court accepted that the husband's rights were capable of valuation despite the presence of uncertainties regarding future benefits, earnings, and distributions. The husband's significant level of influence and control over the trustee's decisions further supported the conclusion that his interests constituted property. The court found that the husband's interests in the trusts were capable of valuation and constituted property, as defined in s 4(1) of the Act.

The court determined that the husband's interests under the relevant trusts were capable of valuation and constituted property for the purpose of a proceeding for the alteration of property interests under s 79 of the Act. The court's decision was based on the expert evidence provided and the High Court's principles on the nature of property. The court's reasoning and conclusion provided clarity on the valuation of the husband's interests in the trusts, which would be essential for any future proceedings related to the alteration of property interests.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

As these reasons explain, in my view the husband’s interests under the relevant trusts are capable of valuation and they constitute property, as defined in s 4(1) of the Act, for the purpose of a proceeding for the alteration of property interests under s 79 of the Act.RELEVANT BACKGROUND Some but not all of the relevant background has already been canvassed.[3] The parties agreed to a confidentiality regime applicable to the deeds in issue in this case. Consistent with that regime, in certain instances I directed that particulars of the deeds not be transcribed.[3] Woodcock & Woodcock [2021] FedCFamC1F 88. Agreed exhibit 1 comprised the documentary evidence on this application. It was made up of –(a)the affidavit of Mr K made 2 July 2021 and exhibits thereto;[4](b)the affidavit of Mr Woodcock made 6 July 2021 and exhibits thereto;[5](c)the affidavit of Mr U made 16 February 2022 and exhibits thereto;[6] (d)the affidavit of Peter Nedovic made 30 April 2022 and exhibits thereto;[7] and(e)the affidavit of Mr T made 31 January 2022 and exhibits thereto.[8][4] This affidavit was filed on behalf of the husband. [5] Ibid. [6] Ibid. [7] This affidavit was filed on behalf of the wife. [8] Ibid. Four trusts were in issue, each constituted by deed of trust and a variety of deeds of amendment. It is utile to record the constituent documents of each trust. The F Trust was constituted by deed dated 28 August 1995. The trustee of the trust is F Pty Ltd. The F Trust was varied by deed of variation dated 2003, 24 June 2005 and 30 June 2007, a deed of rectification dated 30 June 2007, an alteration of termination dated 27 March 2017, a supplemental deed of variation dated 1 September 2020, a supplemental deed made in September 2020 and a consolidated deed dated 1 September 2020. The E Trust was constituted by deed dated 1 March 1995. The trustee of that trust is E Pty Ltd. The E Trust was varied by deeds of variation made in 2003, 24 June 2005, 28 June 2007 and 29 November 2010, a supplemental deed of variation dated 1 September 2020, a supplemental deed made in September 2020 and a consolidated deed dated 1 September 2020. The B Trust was constituted by deed dated 1 December 1992. The trustee of that trust is B Pty Ltd. The B Trust was varied by deeds of variation dated 29 November 2010, 26 September 2013 and 1 September 2020, by supplemental deed made in September 2020 and a consolidated deed dated 1 September 2020. The Mr G (1977) Family Trust was constituted by deed dated 30 June 1977. When the trust was created the trustees were three named natural persons. The trust was varied by deeds of variation dated 22 August 1985, 28 April 1992 and 23 May 2013. A deed of appointment of new trustees dated 30 April 1992 took effect so that C Pty Ltd became the trustee of that trust. The husband is a current director of C Pty Ltd (the trustee of The G Family Trust), B Pty Ltd (the trustee of The B Trust), E Pty Ltd (the trustee of The E Trust) and F Pty Ltd (the trustee of The F Trust).[9][9] Exhibit “PN11” to the affidavit of Peter Nedovic sworn 30 April 2021 being current ASIC searches in respect of each company there named.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Drawing some of those threads together, it seems to me that according to existing statements of principle of the High Court, the equitable choses in action of due consideration and due administration under a discretionary trust of the sort illustrated by The B Trust, The F Trust, The E Trust and The Mr G (1977) Family Trust are in fact and in law “property” within the meaning of s 4 and s 79 of the Act. I say that for several reasons. In each of the four trusts, the husband retained power permissibly exercised over a certain thing, within the contemplation of Yanner v Eaton. He held what certain of the authorities describe as a “bundle of rights”. The husband enjoys a position of considerable influence on the Family Council and historically the husband has received distributions of approximately $15 million. He also has the ability to block. To my way of thinking the husband enjoys a legally endorsed concentration of power over things or resources, as Professor Gray describes “property” in his Cambridge University paper Property in Thin Air. THE EXPERT EVIDENCE ON THE FIRST ISSUE While Mr T and Mr U gave evidence on each preliminary issue, only Mr T was cross-examined. It is necessary to record some of the more important matters that emerged from the reports of each. MR T REPORT 31 JANUARY 2022 The report of Mr T is voluminous and complex. Relevantly paraphrased, his findings may be distilled in the manner set out below –(a)the husband’s rights are capable of being valued, both prior to and subsequent to the amending deeds;[85][85] Hall report, paragraph 7. (b)historically, the husband’s rights have given rise to substantial cash flows from distributions from various trusts and may give rise to future cash flows and other benefits;[86][86] Hall report paragraph 8. (c)without the husband’s rights as a beneficiary, the husband would not have been entitled to receive those distributions;[87][87] Ibid. (d)future benefits that will accrue from the husband’s rights are subject to three categories of uncertainty,[88] first, uncertainty about the earnings and distributions of the entity and assets owned or controlled by various trusts, second, uncertainty about the dispositions of the amounts available for distribution by the various trusts (that is to say, the husband’s share of distributions), and third, uncertainty about the survival of the husband to receive distributions; [88] Hall report paragraph 9. (e)uncertainty about the amount and timing of future benefits arising from property to be valued is a common feature of valuation and does not normally make that property incapable of being valued;[89][89] Hall report paragraph 10. (f)it is necessary to consider whether a reasonable basis exists for addressing the uncertainties earlier identified;[90](g)uncertainty about future benefits relating to the underlying earnings and assets and to the husband’s survival do not prevent the husband’s rights from being valued;[91](h)the question of whether a reasonable basis exists for assessing the impact of the uncertainty in relation to the disposition of amounts available for distribution by the various trusts represents a more difficult uncertainty;[92](i)prior to the amending deeds the husband had a significant level of influence and/or control over the trustee’s decisions;[93](j)the husband had control over one trust and in respect of two other trusts he had the effective ability during his lifetime to ensure that each year –(i)he received at least a specified percentage of any distributions made; or (ii)no distribution would be made (with potentially adverse tax consequences);[94] and (k)after the amending deeds the husband still has significant influence on trustee decisions and there is a substantial history of past distribution decisions agreed by the same group of decision-makers (that include the husband).[95][90] Hall report paragraph 11. [91] Hall report paragraph 12. [92] Hall report paragraph 13. [93] Hall report paragraph 15. [94] Ibid. [95] Hall report paragraph 17.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established