Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) v Donaldson

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read
39 CLR 539

THE COMMISSIONER OF STAMP DUTIES

(QUEENSLAND)

RESPONDENT,

DONALDSON AND OTHERS

RESPONDENTS. PETITIONERS,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

QUEENSLAND. Succession Duty (Q.)-Settlement-Beneficial interests determined by settlor-Income

payable to settlor for certain period-Power of settlor to extend period-Death of settlor preventing further extension-Contingent interest converted into absolute interest-Succession and Probate Duties Acts 1892 to 1918 (Q.) (56 Vict. No. 13-9 Geo. v. No. 16), sec. 4.

By sec. 4 of the Succession and Probate Duties Acts 1892 to 1918 it is provided that every disposition of property by reason of which any person "shall become beneficially entitled to any property or the income thereof upon the death of any person

either immediately or after any interval, either certainly or contingently,

shall be deemed the person entitled by reason of such disposition

By indenture dated 6th May 1916 a settlor transferred real and personal property to trustees in trust for himself, his children and his sister in certain proportions. By the indenture it was provided (in substance) that during five years from the date of the indenture and during such extended period or periods (not exceeding in all twenty-one years from the date of the indenture) as the settlor might from time to time resolve, the whole of the profits from the trust premises should be paid to the settlor; and that subject thereto the profits should be divided between all the beneficiaries in proportion to their interests. In April 1921 the settlor duly extended the period during which those profits should be paid to him for a period of five years from 6th May 1921. On 16th December 1924 the settlor died.

39 CLR 540

Held, by Isaacs A.C.J. and Higgins J. (Rich J. dissenting), that upon the death of the settlor the surviving beneficiaries became entitled under sec. 4 to a "succession" in respect of a sum representing the value as at the death of the settlor of the income from the interests of the surviving beneficiaries under the settlement for the period of eleven years beginning 6th May 1926 and ending 5th May 1937, and that duty was payable upon that sum: on the (Q.)

death of the settlor that income became payable to the surviving beneficiaries during that period, whereas, until his death, he might have excluded them from any right to that income during that period.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland (Full Court): Inre Donaldson's Settlement, (1927) S.R. (Q.) 116, reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Queensland.

John Clark Donaldson executed on 6th May 1916 what purported to be an irrevocable settlement of certain real and personal property, deemed to be of a capital value of £24,000. Of that sum realty represented £1,250. The personalty consisted of £15,000 in the Queensland Government Savings Bank; £600, Queensland Govern- ment Savings Bank stock; £2,200 in the Queensland National Bank; £2,890, Queensland National Bank inscribed stock £2,120, shares and stock £300, being the settlor's interest in the estate of his deceased wife £200,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) v Donaldson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1927] HCA 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) appealed to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The dispute concerned the assessment of succession duty on property transferred by John Clark Donaldson to trustees under an indenture dated 6 May 1916. The Commissioner argued that the beneficiaries of the settlement became beneficially entitled to property upon the settlor's death, attracting succession duty under section 4 of the *Succession and Probate Duties Acts 1892 to 1918* (Qld). The respondents, the executors of the settlor's estate, contended that no succession arose on the settlor's death, as the beneficiaries' interests were already vested prior to his death.

The legal issues before the High Court were: (1) whether the beneficiaries of the settlement acquired a "succession" within the meaning of section 4 of the *Succession and Probate Duties Acts* by reason of the settlor's death; and (2) if so, what was the value of that succession for the purposes of duty. Section 4 of the Act deemed a disposition of property to be a succession if it caused any person to become beneficially entitled to property or its income upon the death of any person, either immediately or contingently, and either certainly or contingently.

The High Court, by a majority (Isaacs A.C.J. and Higgins J., with Rich J. dissenting), held that the beneficiaries did become entitled to a succession upon the settlor's death. The Court reasoned that while the beneficiaries held a vested interest in the corpus of the settlement, the settlor retained a significant personal interest and control over the income derived from the property during his lifetime, including the power to extend the period during which he received the profits. The settlor's death removed this personal control and converted the beneficiaries' contingent entitlement to income for a specific future period into an absolute and indefeasible right. This shift in entitlement, occurring upon the settlor's death, constituted a succession under section 4 of the Act.

The Court ordered that the appeal be allowed, the decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland be discharged, and that succession duty was payable on the value, as at the settlor's death, of the income from the beneficiaries' interests for the period of eleven years commencing 6 May 1926 and ending 5 May 1937. The case was remitted to the Supreme Court of Queensland for further determination of the precise value of this succession.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established