| \ | 0 I' - |
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA ) NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
) No. G 1148 of 1988 1 GENERAL DIVISION 1
BETWEEN: EUGEN ALEXANDER WIEST
Appellant
AND : DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC
PROSECUTIONS and ANOR.
Respondents
CORAM: MORLING, BURCHETT AND GUMMOW JJ.
DATE: 16 AUGUST 1988
ORAL REASONS FOR DECISION
THE COURT : As framed, this is a notice of motion that the applicant be granted bail pending the hearing of his appeal against the decision of Pincus J given on 28 July 1988. On
that date the learned judge refused to make an order that the appellant be granted bail pending the determination of his appeal against the learned judge's decision.
interlocutory nature. Accordingly leave to appeal is required. It was conceded by senior counsel for the appellant
that his client needed the leave of this Court to appealagainst Pincus J ' s decision. In my view that concession was
well founded. It is plain that the decision was of an In the substantive application which came before
Pincus J the appellant sought an order of review in respect of a decision of a magistrate under the Extradition (Foreign
States) Act 1966. The learned magistrate had made an order that a warrant should issue committing the appellant to prison
to await the warrant of the Attorney-General for the
appellant's surrender to the Republic of Germany. On 28 July Pincus J ordered that the decision of the magistrate be confirmed and that the application made to him under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act be dismissed.
An appeal against the learned judge's decision has
been lodged and we understand it will be heard in about one
month's time.
In written submissions on behalf of the respondent, it is contended that this Court has no power
to admit the
appellant to bail pending the hearing of his appeal. We do
| c. | not find it necessary to rule upon the submission. The submission raises a point of substance and importance, but since we are of the opinion that we can dispose of the | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
|
application. Those circumstances led to the result that, in his Honour's words, "The matter was finely balanced" before him.
| Pincus J was of the view that he should follow a dictum of French J in Hempel v Moore (1986) 70 A.L.R. 714 at p.722 to the effect that it is the policy of the Act that | |
| M | exceptional circumstances need to be shown before bail is granted in a case such as the present. |
|
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wiest v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1988] FCA 872
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether it had the authority to grant the appellant bail pending the appeal hearing. Additionally, the court needed to consider if the appellant's appeal had a reasonable prospect of success. The respondents argued that the court lacked the power to admit the appellant to bail. The court acknowledged the significance of this argument but determined that it did not need to rule on it since the application could be resolved without addressing the point.
The court considered several factors in its decision. Firstly, the appellant had been convicted in West Germany for the offence related to the extradition proceedings. While his considerable wealth could potentially ensure compliance with bail conditions, it could also motivate him to seek asylum elsewhere. Secondly, the final order by Pincus J was made nearly three weeks prior, and the appeal was scheduled in about a month. Lastly, the appellant's departure from Germany during his trial added to the complexity of the case. Given these factors, the court concluded that granting leave to appeal would likely be futile as the appeal would not succeed.
The court dismissed the application for leave to appeal and determined that the appeal would not succeed. The costs of the application were reserved to be addressed by the court that would hear the appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter began with the appellant seeking an order of review from Pincus J against the magistrate's decision to commit him to prison pending extradition. This application was dismissed on 28 July 1988. The appellant has appealed this decision and applied to the Federal Court for leave to appeal against the refusal of bail by Pincus J. The appeal against the original decision is scheduled to be heard in about one month's time.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Federal Court have the power to admit the appellant to bail pending the hearing of his appeal against the decision of Pincus J?
2. Are exceptional circumstances necessary to warrant the grant of bail in a case such as the present?
3. Should leave to appeal be granted to the appellant, and if so, would the appeal succeed?
Held
1. The Federal Court does not have the power to admit the appellant to bail pending the hearing of his appeal against the decision of Pincus J. The court found it unnecessary to rule on this submission as the application could be disposed of without determining the point.
2. The court held that exceptional circumstances need to be shown before bail is granted in a case such as the present, following a dictum of French J in Hempel v Moore.
3. Leave to appeal was denied to the appellant, and if granted, the appeal would not succeed. Therefore, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the appellant's application to be admitted to bail pending the hearing of his appeal against the decision of Pincus J, who had previously refused to grant bail. The appellant sought leave to appeal against Pincus J's decision, which was conceded by senior counsel to require the leave of the Federal Court. The court did not find it necessary to rule on whether it had the power to admit the appellant to bail as the application could be resolved without determining the point.
Regarding the need for exceptional circumstances to warrant the grant of bail, the court acknowledged the importance of this question. It noted that if it were to grant leave to appeal, it would likely be of no utility to the appellant as the appeal would not succeed. The court considered various circumstances, including the appellant's wealth, the likelihood of answering bail, and the appellant's previous decision to leave Germany during his trial. The court concluded that the circumstances did not warrant the grant of bail, as the appellant's appeal would not succeed. Consequently, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed. The court also noted that the issue of exceptional circumstances in granting bail in such cases remains an important question.