HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Barwick C.J., McTiernan, Menzies, Windeyer and Owen JJ. Barwick C.J., Menzies, Walsh, Gibbs and Stephen JJ.
TUTA PRODUCTS PTY. LTD. v. HUTCHERSON BROS. PTY. LTD.
1 February 1972
Arbitration—Building Contracts
Arbitration—Award—Setting aside—Error of law on face of award—Award expressed to be made in conformity with judgment of Supreme Court on case stated by arbitrators—Whether judgment part of award. Building Contracts—Construction—Remuneration of builder—Interest on progress payments—Failure of architect to issue certificate—Whether further written request for certificate necessary—Increased costs due to delays consequent upon relocation of sewer pipe—Claim under variations clause.
Decisions
1972, February 1.
The following written judgments were delivered : -
BARWICK C.J. The appellant and the respondent were parties to a submission to arbitration by lay arbitrators under the Arbitration Act 1902 (N.S.W.) of certain questions arising under a construction agreement which they had made with each other. During the course of the arbitration, the arbitrators stated a case for the opinion of the Supreme Court. The Court answered the questions thus asked of it. Ultimately the arbitrators made their award. In the course of reciting the circumstances of the submission and of the making of the award, the arbitrators stated that their award was in conformity with the opinion of the Supreme Court, presumably as expressed in answer to the questions asked in the stated case. The relevant statement was as follows "We award in conformity with the said judgment of the Supreme Court as follows". (at p257)
2. The appellant sought to set aside the award for error of law appearing on its face, the error said to be the said opinion of the Supreme Court, or perhaps, more correctly, the error of the arbitrator in expressing that opinion as their own. The judge of the Supreme Court who heard this application in the first instance treated that opinion of the Supreme Court as appearing on the face of the award and himself as bound by it. On appeal from his refusal to set aside the award, the Court of Appeal Division adhered to its previous opinion upon the stated case and dismissed the appeal. The appellant now appeals to this Court on the ground that the Supreme Court was in error in not setting the award aside for error of law appearing on its face. In substance, the error is in the answers to the questions asked in the stated case. We have heard argument as to whether any such error so appears. If it does not, the appeal must be dismissed. If it does, the question whether the propositions of law so held to appear on the face of the award are erroneous remains to be considered. (at p257)
3. It must strike an intelligent observer as somewhat farcical that a procedure designed for resolving questions, of which those arising out of the present submission are a common example, with economy, celerity and finality, should be as protracted and as fraught with such uncertainty and technicality as…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tuta Products Pty Ltd v Hutcherson Bros Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1972] HCA 4
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the respondent was entitled to an extension of time under clause 11(6) of the building contract. This clause stipulated that the respondent would be entitled to an extension of time if the works were delayed by certain specified causes, including "any cause whatsoever beyond the contractor's control". The Court had to determine the scope and meaning of this broad exclusionary phrase and whether the delays experienced by the respondent fell within its ambit.
The Court reasoned that the phrase "any cause whatsoever beyond the contractor's control" should be interpreted in its plain and ordinary meaning, without undue restriction. It was held that the delays encountered by the respondent, which included the late delivery of materials and labour shortages, were indeed beyond its control and therefore entitled it to an extension of time under the contract. The Court emphasised that the intention of the clause was to protect the contractor from the consequences of delays that it could not reasonably prevent.
The High Court allowed the appeal, finding that the respondent was entitled to the extension of time claimed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The High Court held that an error of law on the face of an award refers to a legal proposition that forms the basis of the award and can be identified as erroneous. In this case, the award referred to the Supreme Court's judgment, but the Court found that this did not incorporate the judgment as part of the award. The Court found that no proposition of law appeared on the face of the award and dismissed the appeal. However, the Court later allowed the appeal, finding errors of law in the award, and remitted certain matters to the arbitrators for reconsideration.
This case came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal against a decision of the Court of Appeal Division of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The initial arbitration hearing was conducted under the Arbitration Act 1902 (N.S.W.), with the arbitrators seeking the opinion of the Supreme Court on certain questions through a case stated. The Supreme Court provided its answers, which the arbitrators incorporated into their final award. The appellant, Tuta Products Pty Ltd, sought to set aside the award for error of law appearing on its face, arguing that the Supreme Court's answers were erroneous. The Supreme Court initially dismissed the application, a decision upheld by the Court of Appeal. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Tuta Products appealed to the High Court, which allowed the appeal and remitted certain matters to the arbitrators for reconsideration.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the arbitrators' award contain an error of law on its face?
2. Was the judgment of the Supreme Court on the case stated part of the arbitrators' award?
3. Was the judgment of the Supreme Court on the case stated erroneous in law?
4. Was there an error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award interest on progress payments due to the architect's failure to issue certificates?
5. Was there an error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award additional costs due to delays in the relocation of a sewer pipe?
6. Was there an error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award costs to the builder under the variations clause?
Held
1. The court concluded that there was no error of law on the face of the arbitrators' award, and dismissed the appeal.
2. The court found that the judgment of the Supreme Court on the case stated was not part of the arbitrators' award.
3. The court determined that there was no error of law in the judgment of the Supreme Court on the case stated.
4. The court held that there was no error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award interest on progress payments due to the architect's failure to issue certificates.
5. The court found that there was an error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award additional costs due to delays in the relocation of a sewer pipe.
6. The court concluded that there was no error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award costs to the builder under the variations clause.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Tuta Products Pty Ltd v Hutcherson Bros Pty Ltd, the High Court was called upon to determine whether the arbitrators' award contained errors of law on its face. The Court addressed several issues concerning the award, including the incorporation of the Supreme Court's opinion on a case stated by the arbitrators, the correctness of specific findings in the award, and the appropriate remedy for any identified errors.
First, the Court held that the arbitrators' award did not contain an error of law on its face. The Court emphasized that for an error of law to appear on the face of the award, a clear and identifiable proposition of law must be evident in the award itself. The Court found that the arbitrators' statement that their award was made in conformity with the Supreme Court's opinion did not incorporate the Supreme Court's opinion into the award. Therefore, no erroneous legal proposition was apparent on the face of the award.
Second, the Court examined whether the judgment of the Supreme Court on the case stated was part of the arbitrators' award. The Court found that while the arbitrators referred to the Supreme Court's judgment in their award, this did not mean that the judgment was incorporated into the award. The reference to the Supreme Court's judgment did not transform it into part of the award, and thus, it could not be examined for errors of law.
Third, the Court determined that the judgment of the Supreme Court on the case stated was not erroneous in law. The Court found that the Supreme Court's answers to the questions posed in the case stated were consistent with the contract terms and applicable legal principles.
Fourth, the Court considered whether there was an error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award interest on progress payments due to the architect's failure to issue certificates. The Court found that the builder was entitled to interest under the contract terms, even if the certificates were not signed by the architect, as the original written request for a certificate had a continuing effect.
Fifth, the Court examined whether there was an error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award additional costs due to delays in the relocation of a sewer pipe. The Court held that the arbitrators' findings concerning the builder's entitlement to additional costs were wrong in law because the altered order of work was not a cause of delay or loss, but rather, a mitigation step taken by the builder.
Sixth, the Court considered whether there was an error of law in the arbitrators' decision to award costs to the builder under the variations clause. The Court found that the builder was not entitled to additional costs under the variations clause, as the change in order of work was not a cause of loss but a mitigation step taken by the builder.
Finally, the Court determined that the appropriate remedy was to remit the matters in dispute back to the arbitrators for reconsideration, in accordance with the reasons provided in the Court's judgment. The Court held that remitting the award preserved the effective determination of the numerous items of dispute that were unblemished by error of law.