Pinanca Pty Ltd v Trinity Projects Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Serial No 48/1991
List "A"

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:              Pinanca Pty Ltd v Trinity Projects Pty Ltd [1991] TASSC 67; A48/1991

PARTIES:  PINANCA PTY LTD
  v
  TRINITY PROJECTS PTY LTD

FILE NO/S:  M482/1988
DELIVERED ON:  27 June 1991
JUDGMENT OF:  Underwood J

CATCHWORDS:

Arbitration — leave to appeal — Commercial Arbitration Act 1986, s38(2) — meaning of "an award" — incorporation of extraneous documents as part of the award.

Judgment Number:  A48/1991
Number of paragraphs:  38

Serial No 48/1991
List "A"
File No M482/1988

PINANCA PTY LTD v TRINITY PROJECTS PTY LTD

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  UNDERWOOD J

27 June 1991

  1. By a notice of motion the applicant seeks leave to appeal against the award of an arbitrator and an order that the award be set aside, on the grounds respectively that there is a question of law arising out of the award and that the arbitrator misconducted himself.

  1. The arbitrator, Eric Thomas Whitford, made two awards. The first he described as an interim award. It was made on 30 November 1988 and dealt with the substance of the dispute between the parties. The second, described by the arbitrator as the final award, dated 15 January 1989, deals with the costs of the arbitration. The notice of motion, filed seven days after publication of the interim award, refers only to that award but, although no application has been made to amend the notice of motion, it is appropriate in the circumstances to treat the motion as seeking leave to appeal and to appeal against both the interim and the final award. Counsel for the respondent conceded in argument that such a course would not cause any prejudice to the respondent.

Some Background Facts:

  1. The respondent company wished to develop properties known as 31 – 35 Salamanca Place and the adjoining 1 Montpelier Retreat, Hobart for commercial purposes. The project called for the substantial modification of some old buildings, originally used by companies serving the shipping industry in the port of Hobart. On 22 November 1984 the applicant and the respondent entered into a contract. It is a project management contract. In essence, it provides that the respondent will design the proposed development in accordance with drawings and an Outline Elemental Specification prepared by architects engaged by the applicant, arrange for contractors to carry out the necessary works, supervise those works and generally, manage the project through to completion. The contract provides for a specified guaranteed maximum price for the execution of the whole project. As a consequence of disputes which arose during the progress of the works, the parties entered into a second agreement on 16 April 1986 the terms of which modified some of the provisions of the first agreement. Further disputes arose and, in mid–1987, Mr Whitford was appointed arbitrator to determine all matters in dispute. The arbitration hearing occupied something in the order of 113 sitting days, 75 of which were taken up with cross–examination of the respondent's managing director. The net result of this extremely…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pinanca Pty Ltd v Trinity Projects Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] TASSC 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pinanca Pty Ltd, the applicant, has applied for leave to appeal against the awards of Mr Eric Thomas Whitford, the arbitrator, and for an order setting the awards aside on the grounds of alleged error of law and misconduct of the arbitrator. The awards in question are the interim award dated 30 November 1988 and the final award dated 15 January 1989. The applicant argues that the awards should include the arbitrator's notes of evidence, the contracts, and other documents that were before the arbitrator. The respondent, Trinity Projects Pty Ltd, contends that the awards consist solely of the documents published by the arbitrator on the specified dates. The court must determine whether the awards include any documents other than those published by the arbitrator. The court held that the awards do not include the arbitrator's notes of evidence, the final submissions of the parties, or the pleadings. However, the awards do include the general conditions of contract and its annexure, Special Condition 1.02, and the second agreement made between the parties on 16 April 1986. The Outline Elemental Specification is not incorporated into the award. The court will now hear counsel on the remaining issues.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Pinanca Pty Ltd v Trinity Projects Pty Ltd involves a dispute between two companies over a project management contract for the development of properties in Hobart. Pinanca Pty Ltd (the applicant) and Trinity Projects Pty Ltd (the respondent) entered into a project management contract on 22 November 1984, with a second agreement modifying some provisions on 16 April 1986. Disputes arose during the execution of the project, leading to the appointment of an arbitrator, Eric Thomas Whitford, to resolve the matters in contention. The arbitration process involved extensive hearings over 113 days, culminating in an interim award on 30 November 1988 and a final award concerning costs on 15 January 1989. The interim award required Pinanca Pty Ltd to pay Trinity Projects Pty Ltd $129,589.00 and Trinity Projects Pty Ltd to pay Pinanca Pty Ltd $70,802.26, resulting in a net difference of $58,786.74. The lengthy arbitration and its financial implications prompted the arbitrator to remark on the "horrendous proportions" of the costs incurred for such a modest outcome.

The applicant sought leave to appeal against the arbitrator's awards, claiming that there were questions of law arising from the awards and that the arbitrator had misconducted himself. The primary issue before the court was the identification and extent of the awards, particularly whether they included documents beyond the published awards. The court determined that the awards comprised the published documents and certain incorporated contracts and conditions, but not the arbitrator's notes, final submissions, or pleadings. Specifically, the interim award incorporated the general conditions of contract, its annexure, a particular special condition (1.02), and the second agreement dated 16 April 1986. The final award on costs did not incorporate any additional documents. The court ruled out the incorporation of the Outline Elemental Specification and other schedules from the claimant's particulars of claim, as they were not integral to the arbitrator's legal reasoning.

The matter of Pinanca Pty Ltd v Trinity Projects Pty Ltd came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania in the form of an application for leave to appeal against an arbitration award. The applicant, Pinanca Pty Ltd, sought to challenge the award made by the arbitrator, Eric Thomas Whitford, on the grounds of alleged error of law and misconduct by the arbitrator. The arbitration, which arose from a project management contract between the parties, had resulted in an award in favour of Trinity Projects Pty Ltd, with a net difference of $58,786.74. Prior to the application, Pinanca Pty Ltd had filed appeal books containing over 4,000 pages of material before the arbitrator, and submitted 36 questions of law. The respondent, Trinity Projects Pty Ltd, conceded that the application could be treated as seeking leave to appeal against both the interim and final awards. The primary procedural issue before the Court was the scope of the arbitrator's awards, specifically whether the awards included all the material in the appeal books, or only the documents published by the arbitrator. This determination was necessary to define the admissibility of evidence and the relevance of submissions on the hearing of the motion. The Court ordered that the question of the scope of the awards be determined as a preliminary point.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the awards of the arbitrator comprise only the documents published under his hand on 30 November 1988 and 15 January 1989, and if not, what documents or parts of documents constitute the awards which are the subject matter of this notice of motion?
2. Whether the notes of evidence and the exhibits referred to therein, the final submissions of parties and the pleadings form part of the award?
3. Whether the general conditions of contract and its annexure, and the special conditions of contract numbered 1.02 are incorporated into the award?
4. Whether the second agreement made on 16 April 1986 is incorporated into the award?
5. Whether the Outline Elemental Specification is incorporated into the award?

Held
1. The awards of the arbitrator do not comprise only the documents published under his hand on 30 November 1988 and 15 January 1989. In addition, the awards include the general conditions of contract and its annexure, special conditions of contract numbered 1.02, and the second agreement made on 16 April 1986.
2. The notes of evidence and the exhibits referred to therein, the final submissions of parties, and the pleadings do not form part of the award.
3. The general conditions of contract and its annexure, and special conditions of contract numbered 1.02 are incorporated into the award.
4. The second agreement made on 16 April 1986 is incorporated into the award.
5. The Outline Elemental Specification is not incorporated into the award.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the question of what documents comprise the awards which are the subject matter of this notice of motion. The court found that the awards comprise only the documents published by the arbitrator on 30 November 1988 and 15 January 1989. The court ruled that the notes of evidence, exhibits, final submissions, and pleadings do not form part of the award. The court found that the general conditions of contract, its annexure, and special conditions of contract numbered 1.02 are incorporated into the award, as is the second agreement made on 16 April 1986. The court did not find that the Outline Elemental Specification is incorporated into the award.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that where an award refers to another document in terms which show that such document forms part of the reasoning for the award, that document is incorporated into the award. The court distinguished prior authority by finding that references to documents in the award which are not part of the legal reasoning for the award are not incorporated into the award. This case clarifies the law on what documents are incorporated into an award and provides guidance to arbitrators on how to clearly indicate which documents are incorporated into their awards.